Magnet is used to levitate another magnet

  • Thread starter Thread starter arul_k
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Magnet
AI Thread Summary
Using a magnet to levitate another magnet through repulsion does not constitute "work" in the physics sense, as work requires displacement. While energy is expended to maintain the levitation, particularly if the magnets are not in motion, this energy does not equate to mechanical work since there is no distance moved. The discussion draws a parallel to a book resting on a table, which also resists gravity without expending energy. Holding the book involves energy use, but this energy is not transferred to the book itself, highlighting the distinction between internal muscle work and external mechanical work. Ultimately, the concept of work in physics is strictly defined by the relationship between force and displacement.
arul_k
Messages
95
Reaction score
1
If a magnet is used to levitate another magnet (using the force of repulsion) can it be considered as doing "work" in opposing the force of gravity? If yes then why does the energy required to do this "work" not diminish over a period of time?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Your scenario is not so clear. I just guess. If a magnet can repulse another magnet (or levitate), it creates some work. But the work comes from you when you try to place the 'another' magnet close enough to the first magnet (in case the first is a permanent one). If the first magnet is electrical, then the work comes from the electricity energy. It is very much like you try to lift a heavy bar up and let it drop, or you press a spring then release it.
 
If the magnets are stationary, then there is no work being done.
 
Zorodius said:
If the magnets are stationary, then there is no work being done.

Yes, I understand that since there is no displacement no work is being done, but there is obvisously some energy being used to keep the magnet levitated and opposing gravity
 
arul_k said:
Yes, I understand that since there is no displacement no work is being done, but there is obvisously some energy being used to keep the magnet levitated and opposing gravity
A book resting on a table is being held against gravity too, but no energy is being expended to keep it there.
 
Zorodius said:
A book resting on a table is being held against gravity too, but no energy is being expended to keep it there.

Yes, but if you were to take the book and hold it up, you would be using energy to do so, not only to lift the book but also to hold it in a fixed position above the table
 
The chemical energy that your body uses to do everyday things is different from the mechanical work that goes on outside your body. From that standpoint, your body is very inefficient. Your body truly is doing no work on that book. Look at the definition of work! w=fd. If there is no distance (no motion), there is no work.
 
russ_watters said:
Your body truly is doing no work on that book.

The key phrase here is "on that book". As you hold the book up, there is activity going on inside your arm muscles, with muscle fibers ratcheting back and forth. Those fibers are doing work which consumes chemical energy and gets transformed into heat, and makes you get tired eventually, but none of that energy gets transferred to the book.
 
Back
Top