Magnetic Field: Find the Right Magnet for a Foot Away

AI Thread Summary
A project requires a magnet capable of attracting from at least a foot away, but a previously purchased hook magnet with a 130lbs pull force only attracts from 2 inches. The discussion highlights that magnet geometry significantly affects the magnetic field range, with bar magnets (dipoles) being recommended for their open geometry. However, the pull force diminishes at greater distances, making it challenging to find a suitable option. Custom magnets may be necessary, potentially costing several hundred dollars. The user seeks a magnet or solenoid that can pull from at least 9 inches without using an electromagnet for a personal project.
linux kid
Messages
101
Reaction score
0
I'm engaged in a project that requires a magnet that can attract from at least a foot away. I mistakenly thought that a larger pull force would also mean a larger field and wasted $15 on a hook magnet with 130lbs pull force but only attracts from abut 2 inches away.

So what kind of magnet would fit my need? Is it the dimension that determines the size of the field?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
As with electric charge, you will find that the field of an infinite current sheet is uniform and independent of the distance a point is from the sheet.
Check out:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Current_sheet
Of course you cannot hope to make an infinitely big sheet but a larger sheet will result in a larger range.
 
Thanks for the reply LHarriger but that is way ahead of my current level. That seems like collage stuff and I'm only in 11th grade.
 
Your hook magnet confines the fields to a small annulus between the magnet disk at center and the steel cup it's mounted in. This field drops quickly if your metal object isn't right up against the assembly. Why is it done that way? By confining the field to a tiny volume, its strength (hence pull force) goes way up.

To pull from a distance you need a magnet with "open" geometry, that is the fields extend away from the body. The most open geometry is a bar magnet (technically it's called a dipole), so look for the combination of biggest and strongest bar magnet. Beware that the pull force 1 foot away will be tiny.
 
Last edited:
Last edited by a moderator:
What are those tubular magnets called that when you put a metal rod inside it will shoot the rod out. I heard they are used in car locks.
 
What are your desired specs, and what are you trying to accomplish?
 
marcusl said:
What are your desired specs, and what are you trying to accomplish?

I need a magnet the will pull from at least 9" away or a solenoid that will shoot something outwards, but WITHOUT an electromagnet. It's for a personal project.
 
Back
Top