Magnetism, electricity, and photons

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the relationship between photons, electricity, and magnetism, exploring concepts related to measuring photons, their role in electric circuits, and the potential for innovative applications in electric motor efficiency. Participants engage with theoretical and practical aspects of these topics, including the nature of photons and their interaction with electromagnetic fields.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants question whether photons are part of a magnetic field like electrons, while others clarify that electrons are not part of the electromagnetic field in the same way photons are.
  • Several types of detectors, such as CCD or CMOS sensors, are mentioned as capable of measuring or counting photons.
  • Participants discuss the nature of photons, noting that they are excitations of the electromagnetic field and encompass a range of electromagnetic radiation.
  • There is a proposal that photons can be created using an external energy source, which some participants agree with, while others express skepticism about the relationship between photons and electrical circuits.
  • One participant expresses interest in measuring photons within a conductor during current flow, questioning if this could be a viable method for reading voltage and amperage.
  • Some participants argue that low-energy photons cannot propagate inside a conductor, while high-energy photons like X-rays and gamma rays could pass through but do not follow the circuit like current does.
  • There is a discussion about the role of photons in current flow, with conflicting views on whether photons influence electron movement or are merely part of electromagnetic interactions.
  • One participant mentions virtual photons, describing them as a mathematical tool rather than a physical entity, which leads to further clarification about their applicability in practical scenarios.
  • A participant shares a design for a magnetic motor and inquires about its longevity, receiving a response focused on the need for energy input and potential wear over time.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

The discussion features multiple competing views regarding the role of photons in electricity and magnetism, with no consensus reached on several key points, including the feasibility of measuring photons in conductors and their influence on electron flow.

Contextual Notes

Participants express uncertainty about the definitions and roles of photons in electrical contexts, highlighting the complexity of the interactions involved and the limitations of current understanding.

Alan Tomazin
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
If photons are part of a magnetic field like electrons, which electrons can be read with an amp meter, what can measure or count photons? Electrons are not counted but the magnetic field changes when more current flows and the ammeter reads a change in the magnetic field.
What type of light are photons?
I've seen some of the folks in here talking about creating photons?
Energy can not be created nor destroyed, so are the photons redirected, collected, trapped, or redistributed, with a magnetic field?
Like measuring amperage, how do I measure photons? RF?
What would happen if you took an x-ray of a magnetic field?
I am trying to come up with ways to make electric motors more efficient and to devise a way to read current flow by measuring photons instead of amperage.
Ohms law doesn't incorporate photons. There is a lot of new information about power generation. It's not just an emf exciting electrons causing a chain reaction in a conductor, it's also photons, but how does a photon travel thru a solid?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Alan Tomazin said:
If photons are part of a magnetic field like electrons

Electrons are not part of the electromagnetic field like photons are.

Alan Tomazin said:
what can measure or count photons?

Several different types of detectors are available. CCD or CMOS sensors are probably the most common devices out there, but there are a few others.

Alan Tomazin said:
What type of light are photons?

Photons are the excitations of the electromagnetic field, of which visible light is merely a small sliver. Radio waves, microwaves, infrared radiation, UV radiation, X-rays, and gamma rays are all electromagnetic radiation, and all EM radiation is composed of photons.

Alan Tomazin said:
I've seen some of the folks in here talking about creating photons?
Energy can not be created nor destroyed, so are the photons redirected, collected, trapped, or redistributed, with a magnetic field?

The photons are literally created. Energy conservation is not being violated because an external source of energy is used to create them.

Alan Tomazin said:
I am trying to come up with ways to make electric motors more efficient and to devise a way to read current flow by measuring photons instead of amperage.
Ohms law doesn't incorporate photons. There is a lot of new information about power generation. It's not just an emf exciting electrons causing a chain reaction in a conductor, it's also photons, but how does a photon travel thru a solid?

Photons have nothing to do with electrical circuits except where a sensor or emitter absorbs or emits light or other EM radiation.
 
Thank you, thank you for the responses. I hope you guys don't mind if I ask a lot of questions, I am trying my best to understand the reality of physics and thermodynamics. As an electrician I know theory, but have been researching the new information about how energy and transmission are produced. I am an entrepreneur and am always testing myself with new and innovative ways to make things more efficient, but don't know all the laws of physics as they do challenge even the best of the best. I feel that if new processes are not tried then you get nowhere. I am interested in Tesla and have researched his work, but this new understanding of the flow of electrons is really not as simple as it sounds. Photons and the way they coincide with electricity intrigues me and I want to understand more about it. Can you turn me on to a good read.
 
Alan Tomazin said:
Thank you, thank you for the responses. I hope you guys don't mind if I ask a lot of questions, I am trying my best to understand the reality of physics and thermodynamics. As an electrician I know theory, but have been researching the new information about how energy and transmission are produced. I am an entrepreneur and am always testing myself with new and innovative ways to make things more efficient, but don't know all the laws of physics as they do challenge even the best of the best. I feel that if new processes are not tried then you get nowhere. I am interested in Tesla and have researched his work, but this new understanding of the flow of electrons is really not as simple as it sounds. Photons and the way they coincide with electricity intrigues me and I want to understand more about it. Can you turn me on to a good read.
Is there a way to measure photons within a conductor when there is current flow, like an amp meter reads current flow?
There are photons in the conductor? In the magnetic field around the conductor with current flow? I am trying to come up with a new way to read voltage and amperage by photons? Is this a dumb idea?
 
Alan Tomazin said:
Photons and the way they coincide with electricity intrigues me and I want to understand more about it. Can you turn me on to a good read.

Photons and electricity only coincide in a few very specific situations, such as photovoltaics, so there's not much to read on the subject other than that.

Alan Tomazin said:
Is there a way to measure photons within a conductor when there is current flow, like an amp meter reads current flow?

No, because low-energy photons cannot propagate inside a conductor, regardless of whether there is current flow or not. You'd have to generate photons in the x-ray and gamma ray ranges to get them to move through a conductor and even then they simply pass through, they don't follow the circuit like current does.

Alan Tomazin said:
I am trying to come up with a new way to read voltage and amperage by photons? Is this a dumb idea?

Dumb? No. Valid? Also no. Not in the way you've presented here.
 
Drakkith said:
Photons and electricity only coincide in a few very specific situations, such as photovoltaics, so there's not much to read on the subject other than that.
No, because low-energy photons cannot propagate inside a conductor, regardless of whether there is current flow or not. You'd have to generate photons in the x-ray and gamma ray ranges to get them to move through a conductor and even then they simply pass through, they don't follow the circuit like current does.
Dumb? No. Valid? Also no. Not in the way you've presented here.
I understand that current flow is not just excited electrons, but photons are what moves electrons, or that they are behind electron flow?
 
Alan Tomazin said:
I understand that current flow is not just excited electrons, but photons are what moves electrons, or that they are behind electron flow?

No, not really. The electric field driving the current through a circuit is not composed of photons. Photons exist as part of electromagnetic waves. They are what an EM wave interacts by to influence matter. And even then they only exist in the far-field portion of the EM field surrounding an electrical device, so even an AC circuit, which has changing electric and magnetic fields running through it, does not have photons propagating through the circuit.
 
Are you absolutely sure that photons are not part of electron flow or excitation and chain reaction of electron flow?
 
To the best of my knowledge, yes.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: mfb and davenn
  • #10
You may have read about virtual photons having something to do with changing electromagnetic fields. This is an unfortunate case of pop science sources presenting a mathematical tool as something real. Actually, they are a mathematical trick used by physicists to organise their calculations. They aren't detectable or useable practically because they are simply an accounting trick - unfortunately, one that sounds cool so gets presented as more than that.

Edit: and it's not a mathematical tool you'd ever use to describe something as large as a wire, either, if I understand correctly. A couple of electrons interacting in free space, yes. A wire, no.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: mfb, davenn and OmCheeto
  • #11
I've got a design for a magnetic motor. If it runs how long will it last?
 
  • #12
Alan Tomazin said:
I've got a design for a magnetic motor. If it runs how long will it last?

As long as you input energy to power it, it will last until something breaks or wears down.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Ibix and davenn

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
4K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
715
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • · Replies 42 ·
2
Replies
42
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
4K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K