MHB Manipulation of negative square root of a negative term/#

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on solving the equation y = (x - 1)² under the condition x ≤ 1. It clarifies that while (x - 1) is non-positive, the square root of y must be taken as positive since y is always non-negative. The participants point out that taking the negative square root of y is incorrect, as it leads to contradictions in the equations. They emphasize that the correct approach involves recognizing that the square root of (x - 1)² is the absolute value, which changes the interpretation of the equation. Ultimately, the conversation highlights the importance of correctly applying square root properties in relation to the defined domain and range.
hatelove
Messages
101
Reaction score
1
Suppose I have to solve for y:

x\leq 1

(x - 1)^{2} = y

So I know that (x - 1) will always be 0 or a negative, therefore I must take the negative square root of (x - 1):

-\sqrt{(x - 1)^{2}} = -\sqrt{y}

Am I to understand that this is the same as:

-1 \cdot \sqrt{(x - 1)^{2}} = -1 \cdot \sqrt{y}
=
-1 \cdot (x - 1) = -1 \cdot \sqrt{y}
=
-x + 1 = -1 \cdot \sqrt{y}

Or how does this work?
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
daigo said:
Suppose I have to solve for y:

x\leq 1

(x - 1)^{2} = y

So I know that (x - 1) will always be 0 or a negative, therefore I must take the negative square root of (x - 1):

-\sqrt{(x - 1)^{2}} = -\sqrt{y}

Am I to understand that this is the same as:

-1 \cdot \sqrt{(x - 1)^{2}} = -1 \cdot \sqrt{y}
=
-1 \cdot (x - 1) = -1 \cdot \sqrt{y}
=
-x + 1 = -1 \cdot \sqrt{y}

Or how does this work?

Do you have another example? The equation you've given already has y as the subject.

For the equation $y = (x-1)^2$ where $x \leq 1$ you can deduce that $y \geq 0$ (in other words the range of the function is $f(x) \geq 0$)

As you said you must take the negative root of $x$ but not of $y$ because $y$ is always non-negative so we take the positive square root. In essence I'm not sure what you want to do with the equation? Do you want to solve for x (and basically find the inverse function)? If you do then remember the domain and range are swapped.

One of the easier things to do is consider and ordered pair.
$f(x) = (x-1)^2$
$f(0) = (0-1)^2 = 1$

So (0,1) is an ordered pair. If we try this in your final equation (which you've done correctly bar taking the negative root of y): $-0+1 = -1 \cdot \sqrt{1} \rightarrow 1 \neq -1$ so that equation doesn't hold.

If you took the positive root of y (ending up with $-x+1 = \sqrt{y} \rightarrow -0+1 = \sqrt{1} $ which works. Try it for another ordered pair (but remember that $y \geq 0$)
 
daigo said:
Suppose I have to solve for y:

x\leq 1

(x - 1)^{2} = y

So I know that (x - 1) will always be 0 or a negative, therefore I must take the negative square root of (x - 1):

-\sqrt{(x - 1)^{2}} = -\sqrt{y}

Am I to understand that this is the same as:

-1 \cdot \sqrt{(x - 1)^{2}} = -1 \cdot \sqrt{y}
=
-1 \cdot (x - 1) = -1 \cdot \sqrt{y}
This is an error \sqrt{(x-1)^2}= |x- 1| not x- 1. Here, since x-1< 0, |x- 1|= -(x- 1) so what you should have is
-1(-(x-1))= x-1= -\sqrt{y}

=
-x + 1 = -1 \cdot \sqrt{y}
This can't be right because if x< 1, -x+ 1> 0 and -\sqrt{y} is positive.

Or how does this work?
Again, \sqrt{x^2}= |x|.
 
daigo said:
Suppose I have to solve for y:

x\leq 1

(x - 1)^{2} = y
This is already "solved for y". Did you mean "solve for x"?

So I know that (x - 1) will always be 0 or a negative, therefore I must take the negative square root of (x - 1):

-\sqrt{(x - 1)^{2}} = -\sqrt{y}
What?? You have squared one side and taken the square root of the other side! From \sqrt{4}= 2 it does NOT follow that 4= \sqrt{2}
What you need to do, to solve for x, is square both sides: x- 1= y^2 and form that x= 1+ y^2. It follows automatically that x is less than of equal to 1 because, with x\le 1, x- 1\le 0 so y is an imaginary number, or 0, and y^2 is less than or equal to 0.

the rest of this is relevant.
Am I to understand that this is the same as:

-1 \cdot \sqrt{(x - 1)^{2}} = -1 \cdot \sqrt{y}
=
-1 \cdot (x - 1) = -1 \cdot \sqrt{y}
=
-x + 1 = -1 \cdot \sqrt{y}

Or how does this work?
 
Insights auto threads is broken atm, so I'm manually creating these for new Insight articles. In Dirac’s Principles of Quantum Mechanics published in 1930 he introduced a “convenient notation” he referred to as a “delta function” which he treated as a continuum analog to the discrete Kronecker delta. The Kronecker delta is simply the indexed components of the identity operator in matrix algebra Source: https://www.physicsforums.com/insights/what-exactly-is-diracs-delta-function/ by...
Suppose ,instead of the usual x,y coordinate system with an I basis vector along the x -axis and a corresponding j basis vector along the y-axis we instead have a different pair of basis vectors ,call them e and f along their respective axes. I have seen that this is an important subject in maths My question is what physical applications does such a model apply to? I am asking here because I have devoted quite a lot of time in the past to understanding convectors and the dual...
Back
Top