Mass dropped with preloaded spring

  • Level: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter carb
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Mass Spring
4 replies · 3K views · last reply
carb
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
Hello everybody,
I'm trying to figure out how to calculate xadd, the additional compression of a preloaded spring (initially compressed of xp) on which a mass is dropped from a height "h".
I also wonder :
- if the final compressed spring length is the same with or without preload ?
- if the spring receive an additional compression xadd >0 whatever the drop height ? (even at h=0.001 ?)

I have some remembering about my academic studies (Energy conservation laws applied to spring) but I feel quite uncomfortable since I did not practice for a long time. Thanks a lot for any kind of help.

Diagram of a blue-outlined frame holding a grey cylinder of mass m on a preloaded spring of free length L, compressed by xp, with drop height h to a green ground block; labels list rigid body and massless properties, stiffness k.
Diagram of a box-shaped object above a compressed spring on a green base, with a blue frame and a double-headed arrow labelled x_add marking the additional compression after a drop.
 
carb said:
the final compressed spring length is the same with or without preload ?
It is not the same.
carb said:
the spring receive an additional compression xadd >0 whatever the drop height ? (even at h=0.001 ?)
Yes it does.

Consider the energy of the cylinder, just before the frame hits the ground:
E1 = m*g*(L-xp) + ½*m*v2
Now consider the energy, E2 , when the cylinder has been brought to a halt ( last figure ).

The difference in energies: ( E1 - E2 ) must have been absorbed by the spring, so:

( E1 - E2 ) = ∫xadd Fspring(x) dx
 
Last edited:
Hello Hesch !
Thanks to your help I did it this way :
E1 (just before hit) = m*g*(L-xp) + ½*m*v2 + ½*k*xp2
with v = √(2*g*h)
E2 (just before rebund phase) = m*g*(L -xp -xadd) + 0 + ½*k*(xp + xadd)2

Then E1 = E2 led me to this factorisation form (xadd as variable) :
½*k*xadd2 + (k*xp - m*g)*xadd - m*g*h = 0

but I actually changed my mind about the study result and decided to get xadd as an input and to find the corresponding height ("how high can I drop the cylinder to get exactly 100% of potential energy absorbed by the spring").

==> h = [½*k*xadd2 + (k*xp - m*g)*xadd] / (m*g)

k: 10 000N/m
m: 1kg
g: 9.81 m/s2

Spring
L: 0.010 m
xp: 0.003 m
xadd_max: 0.006 m (considering a minimal spring contiguous wire height of 0.001 m)

calculation led to h_max = 0.0307m (max height avoiding potential energy causing impact on the ground)

to confirm the results, here is what I got using a mechanism simulation software :
(velocity as initial condition of the dynamic study (just before hit) : v = √(2*g*h) = 776.067 mm/s)

Good to see that lowest reached position is 1mm according to minimal spring height used is previous calculation (contiguous wire)
Line graph of position (blue, left scale, 0 to 10) and velocity (orange, right scale, 0 to 900) against time from 0 to 0.045 s; position falls to a minimum near 0.013 s then rises steeply, velocity dips to near zero at that minimum and peaks near 0.029 s.


I hope the results are not accidentally good :nb).
Thanks again Hesch ! :wink:
 
carb said:
but I actually changed my mind about the study result and decided to get xadd as an input and to find the corresponding height ("how high can I drop the cylinder to get exactly 100% of potential energy absorbed by the spring").
What ?? So you gave up finding an algebraic solution, and started playing with numbers instead ?

Well, I calculated that

E1 = m*g*(L-xp) + ½*m*2*g*h = m*g*(h+L-xp)
E2 = m*g*(L-xp-xadd)
→
E1-E2 = m*g*(h+xadd)

Espring = k*(xp*xadd + ½*xadd2 )

More calculations leads to:

½*xadd2 + (xp-1)*xadd - h*m*g/k = 0 ( solve xadd )

I'm not sure if this is correct, but anyway it makes sense that the calculations ends up in a 2. order equation, giving two solutions:
One when the box is dropped with the spring below the mass, the other when the box is dropped upside down. :smile:
 
Hello Hesch,
I need to re-do your calculations now ;)
Thank you for your help and explanation !