Mech Engineer to a PhD in Physics

In summary, the graduate in Mechanical Engineering (BEng 1st) has an interest in further study, but has not acted on it due to dissatisfaction with work. After working in the oil and gas industry for a year and a half, the graduate has decided to pursue further education and has the further education bug. The graduate would like to do research in physics, but is unsure of what steps need to be taken to pursue this goal. The graduate is looking for advice on what steps need to be taken to pursue a PhD in physics.
  • #1
lazypast
85
0
Hi, I'm a graduate in Mechanical Engineering (BEng 1st). The idea of further study has interested me for many years but I have never acted on it. Currently after working for a year and a half in the oil and gas industry I have the further education bug again, but I would love to follow it this time.

I'm not particularly satisfied at work, especially as the company becomes more paper-orientated (which I accept I would have to do anywhere). I would quit my job to continue further education.

I've always had a love for physics, and when work sent me to China I read an introductory book on quantum physics during all the travelling, which I enjoyed more than the reason for being in China. I've bought several extra books but perhaps my biggest downfall is the mathematics. I would be more than happy now to study after work or in my free time.

I would like to do research in physics. Ultimately a PhD, and that would be ideal now, but I think it's too big a jump from a bachelors in Mech Eng. Is it possible someone could explain what I would have to do to start research in physics or other ways to work towards my goal of a PhD in physics.

I graduated when I was 22 in 2010. I've looked at Marie Curie fellowships, or working at CERN, I would love to pursue that!
Thanks,
Ryan
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
You need to look at degree planners for typical BSc and MSc for quantum physics and see what you are lacking compare to other potential applicants applying for quantum physics PhD's.

It is not impossible, but you've got a lot of work ahead of you.
 
  • #3
That's grest that you enjoyed the quantum physics text.

The next step is to find avjob in your current area or a closely related one that you enjoy more than the one you have.

Meanwhile continue studying the quantum text on your own while making use of resources like this website to help you along.
 
  • #4
Please note that physics isn't JUST "quantum physics"!

You cannot get a degree in physics, or be called a physicist, when ALL you know is quantum physics.

There is already a thread that I created about jumping from a different major to do physics PhD program and what you need to do a self-test. I've also written a chapter on this in my So You Want To Be A Physicist essay:

https://www.physicsforums.com/showpost.php?p=4501336&postcount=10 [Broken]

I have seen students with a B.Sc in Mech. Engineering struggling to pass such qualifying exams, more so than a student in chemistry or EE.

Zz.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #5
ZapperZ said:
I have seen students with a B.Sc in Mech. Engineering struggling to pass such qualifying exams, more so than a student in chemistry or EE.

Maybe that is not very surprising, considering that even the existence of atoms (let alone anything about their structure and behavior) is irrelevant for almost all of mechanical engineering.
 
  • #6
Thanks for the replies, I will go through that 'So you want to be a physicist' thread. I think I was too eager about the whole PhD thing. I've taken a step back and would now rather do a Masters in Physics. Some are research masters and some are taught. If I follow my gut feeling I would chose the research, however due to my engineering background a taught degree might be better as my Physics goes as far as A-level which was done about 8 year ago!
 
  • #7
AlephZero said:
Maybe that is not very surprising, considering that even the existence of atoms (let alone anything about their structure and behavior) is irrelevant for almost all of mechanical engineering.

Wrong. I am working on my PhD in mechanical engineering and I do research in quantum mechanics and phonon transport related to heat transfer. I do molecular dynamics for a variety of materials and relate the atomic properties to the macroscopic thermal properties. Most of mechanical engineering is going down this path now to complete a "bottom-up" approach.
 
  • #8
Why not just go for a PhD in mechanical engineering? You seem to be interested in quantum mechanics, and I can promise you that MANY mechanical engineering professors do research in quantum mechanics. I'm working on my PhD in mechanical engineering and I do the same. You can get plenty of theoretical quantum physics work while obtaining your mechanical engineering PhD.

A physics PhD will include less classical mechanics and more relativity and electromagnetism, while a mechanical engineering PhD will include less relativity and more classical and continuum mechanics. BOTH can have quantum mechanics (if you decide to do QM research as a mechanical engineer, I do it!). If you like relating quantum mechanics to classical mechanics then mechanical engineering is the way to go.
 
  • #9
Hi cytochrome. Thanks for sharing that. It did occur to me about doing a PhD in mech engineering, and I didn't know QM would play any part in your research. I have a love for physics though and I just want to learn about it, all of it.
 
  • #10
lazypast said:
Hi cytochrome. Thanks for sharing that. It did occur to me about doing a PhD in mech engineering, and I didn't know QM would play any part in your research. I have a love for physics though and I just want to learn about it, all of it.

I understand, I too also want to learn all of it.

Just realize that a PhD in mechanical engineering is very physics based and you will still be able to learn any part of physics you wish.

It basically depends on what fields of physics you're more interested in...

Analytical mechanics, continuum mechanics, thermal physics? Go for mechanical engineering.

Electromagnetism, particle physics, general relativity? Go for physics.

Both have their equal share of quantum mechanics, from what I've seen. Keep in mind that a PhD in physics must also know about analytical mechanics, continuum mechanics, and thermal physics and a PhD in mechanical engineering must also know about electromagnetism and most of them are generally educated on topics like general relativity out of pure interest.
 
Last edited:
  • #11
cytochrome said:
I understand, I too also want to learn all of it.

Just realize that a PhD in mechanical engineering is very physics based and you will still be able to learn any part of physics you wish.

It basically depends on what fields of physics you're more interested in...

Analytical mechanics, continuum mechanics, thermal physics? Go for mechanical engineering.

Electromagnetism, particle physics, general relativity? Go for physics.

Both have their equal share of quantum mechanics, from what I've seen. Keep in mind that a PhD in physics must also know about analytical mechanics, continuum mechanics, and thermal physics and a PhD in mechanical engineering must also know about electromagnetism and most of them are generally educated on topics like general relativity out of pure interest.

I went to see my old professor from my Mech Eng degree. I told him my ultimate goal is research in Physics and he said I should just go straight for that, I needn't 'waste' my time do a Masters. I was so happy when he said that. There is a new Physics department starting in my old university so he put me in contact with the Physics BSC tutor.
I think I'll read up on different topics in Physics so I have a better understanding as where I want to be. For example I'm unfamiliar with condensed matter physics.
 
  • #12
How well do you know physics? You should acquire a working knowledge equal to or greater than a typical physics bachelor, even before you start grad school. I assume you have a good grasp of mechanics. How is your E&M? Do you know Maxwell's equations by heart? Can you solve problems involving vector calculus? In quantum, you should know stuff like nondegenerate perturbation theory, variational approximation for ground state energies, indistinguishable particle statistics, selection rules, angular momentum addition. How about thermodynamics?

I don't think there's much condensed matter physics at the undergraduate level, so you may be ok without knowing it, though it's a nice bonus.
 

1. What made you decide to switch from being a mechanical engineer to pursuing a PhD in physics?

I have always been fascinated by the fundamental laws and principles that govern our universe. As a mechanical engineer, I was able to apply these principles to solve practical problems, but I wanted to delve deeper into the theoretical aspects of physics and contribute to the advancement of our understanding of the universe.

2. How did your background in mechanical engineering prepare you for a PhD in physics?

My background in mechanical engineering provided me with a strong foundation in math, physics, and problem-solving skills. These skills have been invaluable in my transition to studying physics at a higher level. Additionally, my experience with designing and building complex systems has given me a unique perspective and approach to conducting experiments and analyzing data in physics research.

3. What challenges did you face in the transition from being a mechanical engineer to a PhD student in physics?

One of the main challenges I faced was learning the advanced mathematical techniques and concepts used in theoretical physics. As a mechanical engineer, I had a solid understanding of calculus and differential equations, but I had to work hard to catch up on topics such as complex analysis, group theory, and tensor calculus. Additionally, I had to adjust to a different style of thinking and problem-solving in physics, which is more theoretical and abstract compared to engineering.

4. How do you see your background in mechanical engineering influencing your research in physics?

My background in mechanical engineering has given me a unique perspective and approach to conducting research in physics. I am able to combine my knowledge of engineering principles with my understanding of theoretical physics to develop innovative solutions to complex problems. Additionally, my experience with designing and building experimental setups has been beneficial in my research, as I am able to troubleshoot and optimize experiments more efficiently.

5. What advice do you have for someone considering a similar transition from engineering to physics?

My advice would be to start by taking some introductory physics courses to get a feel for the subject and see if it interests you. It's also important to be open to learning new mathematical concepts and approaches to problem-solving. Don't be discouraged if it takes some time to adjust to the different style of thinking in physics. Also, make use of your engineering background and apply it to your research in physics – it can give you a unique perspective and set you apart from other students. Lastly, surround yourself with supportive peers and mentors who can guide you through the transition and help you succeed in your new field of study.

Similar threads

  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
19
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
2
Replies
50
Views
4K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
9
Views
790
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
13
Views
271
  • STEM Academic Advising
2
Replies
37
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
3
Views
289
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
3
Views
806
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
6
Views
781
Replies
3
Views
856
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
3
Views
828
Back
Top