Mixed Melting Point of Two Pure Solid Crystals

In summary, In this example, the vapour pressure of a saturated solution of sodium chloride is greater than the liquid pressure of water. This means that the sodium chloride will condense out of the water and form a solid.
  • #1
Mike Dacre
19
10
I understand why an impure solid will have a decreased melting point, however, in my recent organic chemistry lab section I mixed two finely ground pure solids together and observed that the mixture melted at a lower temperature than either pure solid.

I understand this in principle, but whenever mixed melting point theory is taught, it is taught from the perspective that impurities reduce the strength of a crystal structure. However, in my experiment I had two *solid* pure substances, mixed together. The crystal structure could not possibly be disrupted, as the compounds had never mixed in liquid form. So my question is: how does that work? Is it just the case that a small amount of one or both of the pure substances is melting at the edges of the crystals, and that when this happens, this tiny amount of impure liquid can dissolve more of the two pure solids, and that this is what causes the melting point depression?
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
  • #2
That's one way to look at it. Strictly? Recall Gibbs' Phase Rule and realize you've got a vapor phase of A and of B in equilibrium with solid A and B, giving you a mixed solid.
 
  • Like
Likes Mike Dacre
  • #3
Bystander said:
That's one way to look at it. Strictly? Recall Gibbs' Phase Rule and realize you've got a vapor phase of A and of B in equilibrium with solid A and B, giving you a mixed solid.

Hi Bystander, thank you for your help but I would like a little extra clarification if possible. Unfortunately, the course I am taking has a separate lab and lecture that aren't always synchronized and I have not learned about Gibb's Phase Rule in class yet. I just went to YouTube and Wikipedia university and I think I understand the phase rule now, but I am not confident that I understand how it relates to this problem.

Here is what I think is happening from your answer: for both A and B, there is a dynamic equilibrium between the solid and vapor phases, meaning that there is deposition of a mixture of A and B on all of the surfaces of the previously pure crystals, which then melt at a lower temperature. As they melt, the mixed liquid is able to dissolve the remaining pure solids, resulting in a pure molten mixture at a temperature well below the melting point of either pure solid. Does that make sense? Or is it that the mixed vapor phase is condensing into a mixed liquid? I am discounting that possibility because I assume that the intermolecular forces that dominate in the condensed phases play only a very minor role in the gas phase, and thus shouldn't play a large role. However, even as I type that I am doubting myself, is that the case?

I assume there are also entropic considerations here, in that the mixed liquid has greater entropy than pure liquids (for ideal mixtures) and thus is generally favored. Is that a safe assumption? Or are so few liquids ideal that assuming anything about entropy is foolish?
 
  • #4
Mike Dacre said:
As they melt, the mixed liquid is able to dissolve the remaining pure solids, resulting in a pure molten mixture at a temperature well below the melting point of either pure solid.
Pretty much nails it --- the rest of your understanding/discussion looks solid as well.
 
  • Like
Likes Mike Dacre
  • #5
I think the main mechanism is the contact between the crystals. The crystal surfaces are less stable than the bulk of the crystal and are already liquid at temperatures well below the melting point. The liquid boundaries of touching crystals will mix which reduces the melting point further.
 
  • Like
Likes Mike Dacre
  • #6
Mike Dacre said:
Here is what I think is happening from your answer: for both A and B, there is a dynamic equilibrium between the solid and vapor phases, meaning that there is deposition of a mixture of A and B on all of the surfaces of the previously pure crystals, which then melt at a lower temperature. As they melt, the mixed liquid is able to dissolve the remaining pure solids, resulting in a pure molten mixture at a temperature well below the melting point of either pure solid. Does that make sense? Or is it that the mixed vapor phase is condensing into a mixed liquid? I am discounting that possibility because I assume that the intermolecular forces that dominate in the condensed phases play only a very minor role in the gas phase, and thus shouldn't play a large role.
Presence of significant amounts of vapour is unimportant. Look at a simple case, of bringing into contact solid single crystal sodium chloride with solid single crystal ice.
Saturated solution of sodium chloride in water freezes into eutectic mixture at -21 degrees. Sodium chloride melts at over 800 degrees and boils at over 1400 degrees. At -20 degrees, the vapour pressure of sodium chloride is thus very low.
The mechanism of "surface melting" might count. Still... how quickly is melting initiated at the contact point between ice and salt at -20 degrees?
 
  • #7
Great, thank you all for your help.

snorkack said:
how quickly is melting initiated at the contact point between ice and salt at -20 degrees

That is actually an interesting kinetics question, and one that I couldn't find an answer to after a little brief searching. If they behave anything like my two unknowns for my organic chemistry lab, they start melting very quickly. Does anyone know the answer? If my proposed mechanism is correct, the rate of melting will be dependent on the surface area of contact between the two crystals, and so finely ground salt added to finely ground ice held at -20 ºC should melt very rapidly (on the order of a few minutes). However, I am not sure what the rate would be if one added coarse salt to the surface of sheet ice, my instinct is that although melting would be initiated quite quickly at the contact point between the surface of the ice and the surface of the salt crystals, so little would melt in that initial contact that the resultant rate would be very slow.

If anyone has anything more quantitative to offer on this, I would be interested to hear.

Thanks again everyone!
 
  • #8
Mike Dacre said:
I mixed two finely ground pure solids together and observed that the mixture melted at a lower temperature than either pure solid.
Not knowing your setup, you might have an experimental error, such as,

There could be interaction between the solids.
There could be presence of water which will lower the melting point. Humidity from the air would be more readily |"absorbed " with a finer powders.
A section of the crucible could hot enough to melt one of the solids, therby enhancing the other solid to dissolve in the liquid.
Your temperature sensing device would most likely record average temperature throughout the sample and not hotter or cooler sections.

I would tend to think that on one trial it would be difficult to conclusively say what is going on, and form a totally conclusive explanation.
 

1. What is a mixed melting point?

A mixed melting point is the temperature at which a mixture of two pure solid crystals begins to melt. It is a useful technique for determining the purity of a substance or identifying unknown compounds.

2. How is a mixed melting point determined?

To determine a mixed melting point, a small amount of the mixture is placed in a capillary tube and heated gradually until it begins to melt. The temperature at which the first signs of melting occur is recorded as the mixed melting point of the two substances.

3. What factors can affect the accuracy of a mixed melting point?

The accuracy of a mixed melting point can be affected by factors such as impurities in the substances, incorrect temperature measurement, and the rate of heating. It is important to use pure substances and to heat the mixture slowly and evenly to get an accurate result.

4. How does the mixed melting point method distinguish between two substances?

If the two substances have different melting points, the mixed melting point will be lower than the melting point of either pure substance. This is because the mixture will melt over a range of temperatures, rather than at a specific temperature. If the two substances have the same melting point, the mixed melting point will be the same as the melting point of each pure substance.

5. What are the limitations of using mixed melting point to identify substances?

Mixed melting point is a useful technique, but it is not always reliable for identifying substances. Substances with similar melting points or mixtures of multiple substances can result in inaccurate or inconclusive results. In these cases, other analytical techniques may be necessary to accurately identify the substances present.

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
981
  • Classical Physics
Replies
3
Views
961
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
5K
Replies
2
Views
42K
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
716
Replies
5
Views
4K
Back
Top