Need help - Developing a self study plan as a high schooler

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around a high school junior seeking advice on developing a self-study plan for mathematics, particularly in preparation for college-level courses in engineering. The participant expresses a desire to strengthen their mathematical background while concurrently taking Pre-Calculus and planning to take Calculus 1, Statistics, and possibly Calculus 2 in the following year.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • The original poster (OP) is interested in self-studying college-level math while still enrolled in Pre-Calculus, questioning the feasibility of this approach.
  • Some participants suggest that building a strong foundation in algebra and precalculus is crucial before advancing to calculus.
  • Several self-study resources are proposed, including an online calculus book, Euclid's Elements for geometry, and texts on abstract algebra and linear algebra, with varying opinions on their accessibility and prerequisites.
  • There is a comparison between studying from the recommended calculus book and taking a free online course from Coursera, with some participants expressing skepticism about the effectiveness of Coursera for deep learning.
  • One participant emphasizes the importance of mastering the skill of studying from actual books as part of the self-study process.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on the importance of a strong mathematical foundation and suggest various self-study resources. However, there is no consensus on the best method for self-studying calculus, as opinions differ regarding the effectiveness of online courses versus traditional textbooks.

Contextual Notes

Some limitations are noted regarding the prerequisites for certain subjects and the varying depth of resources available for self-study. The discussion reflects differing views on the effectiveness of online learning platforms compared to traditional study methods.

RoZ589
Messages
23
Reaction score
0
Currently a junior in high school taking Pre-Calc. Next year I'll be taking Calc 1, Statistics, and MAYBE Calc 2 (if it's offered in the second semester).

I'm wanting to learn more math than I currently am however. I love math, and I want to have a very strong background before I go into college (where I will be going into engineering, which requires plenty of math). I want to start now, but I'm not sure what to do.

I want to start self-studying/ reading up on college-level math. Is it possible to do this while still in the process of taking pre-calc? I've actually thought about starting to self-study Calc 1 at the same time as I'm taking pre-calc, even though I would be officially taking Calc 1 at my school next year. Is this a bad thing to do? I want to be self-studying math from now until when I graduate (3 semesters, one summer). I'm hoping to develop some sort of schedule that I can follow. I'm okay with some rigor and difficult subjects, as I am very disciplined and eager to learn more.. but I'm not a genius or anything (32 math ACT, 130 IQ).

It was a little difficult to articulate my situation, but hopefully you get the gist. Can anyone help me?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
It wouldn't hurt to read ahead on calculus I suppose to get an idea of what it's all about, but I would seriously focus on building a strong background in algebra/precalculus before moving on. I believe this is where most people fail in calculus classes.
 
RoZ589 said:
Currently a junior in high school taking Pre-Calc. Next year I'll be taking Calc 1, Statistics, and MAYBE Calc 2 (if it's offered in the second semester).

I'm wanting to learn more math than I currently am however. I love math, and I want to have a very strong background before I go into college (where I will be going into engineering, which requires plenty of math). I want to start now, but I'm not sure what to do.

I want to start self-studying/ reading up on college-level math. Is it possible to do this while still in the process of taking pre-calc? I've actually thought about starting to self-study Calc 1 at the same time as I'm taking pre-calc, even though I would be officially taking Calc 1 at my school next year. Is this a bad thing to do? I want to be self-studying math from now until when I graduate (3 semesters, one summer). I'm hoping to develop some sort of schedule that I can follow. I'm okay with some rigor and difficult subjects, as I am very disciplined and eager to learn more.. but I'm not a genius or anything (32 math ACT, 130 IQ).

It was a little difficult to articulate my situation, but hopefully you get the gist. Can anyone help me?

Yes, there are plenty of self-study options open for you. Here are some options that you might want to look at:
1) Calculus
If you know trigonometry, basic geometry like equations of lines and are comfortable with algebra, then you will have no problem with calculus. I recommend the online free book https://www.math.wisc.edu/~keisler/calc.html It's an excellent book, with excellent explanations. It has the additional benefit that it treats the very important notion of infinitesimals rigorously, as opposed to other calculus books.

2) Geometry
The most important math book ever written is Euclid's Elements. Why not take some time going through this excellent book. You will become comfortable at proofs, geometry, and you'll gain a whole lot of maturity. The Elements is the book that almost every mathematician in the history has read, and it continues to be a beautiful piece of writing. I don't think anybody is really able to grasp the history of math without this book.

3) Abstract Algebra
Yes, abstract algebra. It is usually seen as something very difficult that people take only after calculus, but it can in fact be learned very early on. Calculus is not a prerequisite at all. Only a willingness to work hard is important. Good books are Pinter's "A book on abstract algebra", together with the very beautiful (but lacking enough problems) "Groups and symmetry" from Armstrong.

4) Linear algebra
I personally think linear algebra is somewhat more difficult than abstract algebra. But that doesn't mean you're not able to do it. You can start by learning about matrices, their operations, determinants, solving systems of equations. Then you can start with the really important stuff: vector spaces. Again, calculus is not a prerequisite here.

Feel free to PM me if you wish to know more!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: kswgrad2012
micromass said:
Yes, there are plenty of self-study options open for you. Here are some options that you might want to look at:
1) Calculus
If you know trigonometry, basic geometry like equations of lines and are comfortable with algebra, then you will have no problem with calculus. I recommend the online free book https://www.math.wisc.edu/~keisler/calc.html It's an excellent book, with excellent explanations. It has the additional benefit that it treats the very important notion of infinitesimals rigorously, as opposed to other calculus books.

2) Geometry
The most important math book ever written is Euclid's Elements. Why not take some time going through this excellent book. You will become comfortable at proofs, geometry, and you'll gain a whole lot of maturity. The Elements is the book that almost every mathematician in the history has read, and it continues to be a beautiful piece of writing. I don't think anybody is really able to grasp the history of math without this book.

3) Abstract Algebra
Yes, abstract algebra. It is usually seen as something very difficult that people take only after calculus, but it can in fact be learned very early on. Calculus is not a prerequisite at all. Only a willingness to work hard is important. Good books are Pinter's "A book on abstract algebra", together with the very beautiful (but lacking enough problems) "Groups and symmetry" from Armstrong.

4) Linear algebra
I personally think linear algebra is somewhat more difficult than abstract algebra. But that doesn't mean you're not able to do it. You can start by learning about matrices, their operations, determinants, solving systems of equations. Then you can start with the really important stuff: vector spaces. Again, calculus is not a prerequisite here.

Feel free to PM me if you wish to know more!
Thanks for the info!

I've heard that that calc book recommended plenty of times, and I'm definitely okay with going through it. However, how would you compare reading through that book versus doing a Calc 1 course through coursera (it's free) - https://www.coursera.org/learn/calculus1
 
Last edited by a moderator:
RoZ589 said:
Thanks for the info!

I've heard that that calc book recommended plenty of times, and I'm definitely okay with going through it. However, how would you compare reading through that book versus doing a Calc 1 course through coursera (it's free) - https://www.coursera.org/learn/calculus1

I don't know about these precise courses, but I've always been very unimpressed with coursera as a formal learning device. It's great if you want to get the gist of something, but not if you want to know something well. In my opinion, it lacks many problems, a good feedback system and depth. You can do better for self-study. I guess as a secondary resource, it's ok. But going through an actual book is a skill on its own that needs to be mastered.
 
micromass said:
I don't know about these precise courses, but I've always been very unimpressed with coursera as a formal learning device. It's great if you want to get the gist of something, but not if you want to know something well. In my opinion, it lacks many problems, a good feedback system and depth. You can do better for self-study. I guess as a secondary resource, it's ok. But going through an actual book is a skill on its own that needs to be mastered.
Okay. I may start out taking a look at both then deciding which method of self-studying suits me better.

Thanks for the advice
 
RoZ589 said:
Okay. I may start out taking a look at both then deciding which method of self-studying suits me better.

At the risk of sounding annoying, but it's not about the method which suits you better. Of course, the coursera course will suit everybody better. But that doesn't mean that basing yourself primarly on coursera will be beneficial in the long run. It's not about "which method suits me better now", but about "which will get me the best results in the long run".
 
micromass said:
At the risk of sounding annoying, but it's not about the method which suits you better. Of course, the coursera course will suit everybody better. But that doesn't mean that basing yourself primarly on coursera will be beneficial in the long run. It's not about "which method suits me better now", but about "which will get me the best results in the long run".
I see what you mean.

I'll self-study using Keisler's then (probably going to buy a paperback of it instead of using the online pdfs). Another question, do you think this book could be completed by the start of my senior year (one semester and summer)? I'd be most likely going through it 20-30 mins/day.
 
RoZ589 said:
I see what you mean.

I'll self-study using Keisler's then (probably going to buy a paperback of it instead of using the online pdfs). Another question, do you think this book could be completed by the start of my senior year (one semester and summer)? I'd be most likely going through it 20-30 mins/day.

No, at a rate of 30 minutes a day, you can't hope to complete this book in that timeframe. That is, unless you skip important things like the problems. Don't forget that Keisler covers calculus I to III in his book. So you're looking at three semesters of college-level material.
 
  • #10
micromass said:
No, at a rate of 30 minutes a day, you can't hope to complete this book in that timeframe. That is, unless you skip important things like the problems. Don't forget that Keisler covers calculus I to III in his book. So you're looking at three semesters of college-level material.
OH I thought it was just Calc 1. I'm definitely okay with not completing it in that time-frame then.

Would you happen to know which chapters are which calculus levels?
 
  • #11
Chapter 1-6 seems to be roughly Calc I
Chapter 6-9 seems to be Calc II
Chapters 10-13 are standard in Calc III
Chapter 14 is something you might see in one of those three courses, but I don't know which one (probably calc II).
 
  • #12
micromass said:
Chapter 1-6 seems to be roughly Calc I
Chapter 6-9 seems to be Calc II
Chapters 10-13 are standard in Calc III
Chapter 14 is something you might see in one of those three courses, but I don't know which one (probably calc II).
Gotcha.

Thanks a lot for the help.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 102 ·
4
Replies
102
Views
9K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
3K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
2K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
4K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
7K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K