Newton's Laws - Incline. Do I have the right idea?

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a physics problem involving Newton's Laws applied to a block sliding down an incline. The incline is characterized by an angle of 24 degrees, a length of 50 meters, a base of 45.7 meters, and a height of 20.3 meters. Participants explore various aspects of motion, forces, and friction in this context.

Discussion Character

  • Mixed

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • The original poster attempts to analyze the motion of a block on an incline, considering both frictionless and frictional scenarios. They raise questions about the forces acting on the block and the implications of mass on speed. Some participants question the derivation of acceleration and the role of velocity in determining the coefficient of kinetic friction.

Discussion Status

Participants are actively engaging with the problem, providing feedback on each other's reasoning and calculations. Some guidance has been offered regarding the need to include certain factors in equations and the importance of using derived relationships. There is an ongoing exploration of different interpretations of the problem, particularly concerning the effects of mass and friction.

Contextual Notes

There are constraints related to the assumptions made, such as ignoring air resistance and the need for clarity on the forces involved in the free-body diagram. The original poster expresses uncertainty about their answers and seeks confirmation and further assistance.

Lauren0619
Messages
11
Reaction score
1
I am hoping that I can have someone look over my answers. I have provided what I think is necessary to be appropriate posting, including the questions and attempts at all my answers. I would just like some feedback that I am correct in my answers. Thank you!

This is an overview that all the questions are based off of: An incline with theta 24 degrees, length of incline is 50m, base is 45.7 m, and height is 20.3 meters.

Question 1) 1. Homework Statement

Assuming a block at the top starts from rest (ignoring friction), how fast would it be moving when it reaches the bottom of the ramp? i.e. after sliding a distance of 50m.

Homework Equations


a=gsintheta
v=sqrt2gh

The Attempt at a Solution


mgh=.5mv^2
gh=.5v^2
v=sqrt2gh = 19.94 m/s

Question 2) [/B]Now include sliding friction. Draw a free-body diagram for the block when it is partway down the ramp. Label all the forces

No relevant Equations needed

Attempt at solution: Since I can't upload a photo, I'll describe my free body diagram: dot in middle represents block, downward arrow represents gravity, upward and to the right represents normal force, and upward perpendicular to normal force (to the left) represents friction. Am I missing any forces?

Question 3)
Using the free body diagram and Newton's 2nd law to derive the acceleration down the ramp (assume coefficient of kinetic fricion uk) Show reasoning/derivation.

Attempt at solution: Solve for Normal, N=mgcostheta
Sum of forces down the ramp are positive = ma=mgsintheta-friction
Friction is negative because it opposes the motion. Friction =uN Friction = umgcostheta
So, ma=mgsintheta-umgcostheta
a=g(sintheta) - uk (costheta)

Question 4) In the show watched in class (I don't think anyone needs to watch this to help), Adam suggests the second block will go faster down the incline because it weighs more. Based on your result in #2, do you agree?

Relevant Equations:
v=sqrt(2gh) Conservation of Energy

Attempt at solution: No, I don't agree. This is tricky. If I assume no air resistance (which since this hasn't been mentioned in the assignment, I'll assume no air resistance), then mass won't matter. If air resistance is considered, then yes - he would move faster.

Question 5) Suppose the block starts at rest, slides a distance of 50m to the bottom of the ramp, ending at a known (measured) speed v. Which expression tells us the coefficient of kinetic friction? Show the algebra.

My options for this one are:

A) tan(theta)
B) tan(theta) + v^2/2gL
C) tan(theta) - v^2/2gl
D) tan(theta) + v^2/2gl(cos(theta))
E) tan(theta) - v^2/2gl(cos(theta))

Relevant Equations:

Fr=uN

Attempt at a solution:

I believe the answer for this one is A because i think i remember it being taught in class that way. However, I'm not sure how to derive the answer. I know I have to start with the kinetic friction formula which is Fr=uN with N being the force of gravity? This is the one that I need more help on. I hesitate to choose that answer because my intuition tells me that this equation should include velocity.

Thanks for all the help, everyone!


 
Physics news on Phys.org
Lauren0619 said:
So, ma=mgsintheta-umgcostheta
a=g(sintheta) - uk (costheta)
Good, but make sure you don't leave out that factor of 'g' in the second term.

Lauren0619 said:
I believe the answer for this one is A because i think i remember it being taught in class that way. However, I'm not sure how to derive the answer. I know I have to start with the kinetic friction formula which is Fr=uN with N being the force of gravity? This is the one that I need more help on. I hesitate to choose that answer because my intuition tells me that this equation should include velocity.
Your intuition is correct: you'll need to use the given velocity. Hint: You just derived a formula that relates the acceleration and the coefficient of friction. Use it! Hint 2: Use kinematics to derive another equation for acceleration.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Lauren0619
Doc Al, Thank you for your very helpful quick reply. I redid Question 5 and got E) for my answer.
I have one more question pertaining to this problem set:

Homework Statement


We are told the block reaches a max speed of about 30 mi/h at the bottom of the ramp. Use question 5 to calculate the coefficient of kinetic friction down the incline.

Homework Equations


tan(theta) - v^2/2gL(costheta)

The Attempt at a Solution


Using dimensional analysis, I converted 30 mi/h to 13.4 m/s.
tan(24) - 13.4^2/2(9.8)(50)(cos24)
.445 - 13.4^2/895.27
.445 - .201 = .244
 
Excellent! :smile:
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Lauren0619

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
786
Replies
24
Views
3K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
4K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
3K