Optimizing Page Dimensions for Minimum Paper Usage

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves optimizing the dimensions of a printed page to minimize paper usage while maintaining a specified printed area of 81 cm². The margins are defined as 3 cm at the top and bottom, and 2 cm on the sides, leading to a relationship between the total dimensions and the printed area.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Mathematical reasoning, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the relationship between the total page dimensions and the printed area, exploring how to express the total area in terms of one variable. There are attempts to derive the area function and set its derivative to zero for optimization. Some participants express confusion over the differentiation process and the resulting equations.

Discussion Status

The discussion is ongoing, with participants sharing their attempts at differentiation and expressing difficulties in arriving at the correct derivative. Some guidance has been offered regarding potential errors in the differentiation process, and there is an acknowledgment of the need to clarify the expressions used.

Contextual Notes

Participants are working under the constraints of a specific printed area and defined margins, which influence the relationships they are exploring. There is an emphasis on ensuring correct differentiation to find the optimal dimensions.

Fifty
Messages
33
Reaction score
0
"The printed area of a book will be 81 cm2. The margins at the top and bottom of the page will each be 3 cm deep. The margins at the sides of the page will each be 2 cm wide. What page dimensions will minimize the amount of paper?" (Calculus and Vectors, Peter Crippin et al., 158).

[I added the citation just in case!]

I first thought...
"the width of the entire page will be x and the length will be y. The width of the printed area then is x - 4 (excluding the side margins) and the length of the printed area is y - 6. So (x - 4)(y - 6) = 81 cm2.

The total area is A = xy. y, in terms of x, is y = \frac{1000}{x - 4} + 6. So then I figured:

A(x) = x ( \frac{1000}{x - 4} + 6 ) would be the area and I would take its derivative and set A'(x) = 0."

I always end up with 81x - 81x in the differentiated function and get 0 = -324. I've tried multiple approaches (including setting x to the width of the printed page and then the total width being x + 4) and using different methods to get to the derivative, but this always happens.

Thanks for the help!

EDIT: Whoops! Thanks, chet!

unsimplified:
A'(x) =\frac{81(x-4) - 81x}{(x - 4)}

Sorry, apparently formatting the fraction won't work if I include the exponent formatting as well, but the (x - 4) in the denominator is supposed to be squared.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Fifty said:
"The printed area of a book will be 81 cm2. The margins at the top and bottom of the page will each be 3 cm deep. The margins at the sides of the page will each be 2 cm wide. What page dimensions will minimize the amount of paper?" (Calculus and Vectors, Peter Crippin et al., 158).

[I added the citation just in case!]

I first thought...
"the width of the entire page will be x and the length will be y. The width of the printed area then is x - 4 (excluding the side margins) and the length of the printed area is y - 6. So (x - 4)(y - 6) = 81 cm2.

The total area is A = xy. y, in terms of x, is y = \frac{1000}{x - 4} + 6. So then I figured:

A(x) = x ( \frac{1000}{x - 4} + 6 ) would be the area and I would take its derivative and set A'(x) = 0."

I always end up with 81x - 81x in the differentiated function and get 0 = -324. I've tried multiple approaches (including setting x to the width of the printed page and then the total width being x + 4) and using different methods to get to the derivative, but this always happens.

Thanks for the help!
It's hard to help unless you show us what you got for the derivative.

Chet
 
Fifty said:
"The printed area of a book will be 81 cm2. The margins at the top and bottom of the page will each be 3 cm deep. The margins at the sides of the page will each be 2 cm wide. What page dimensions will minimize the amount of paper?" (Calculus and Vectors, Peter Crippin et al., 158).

[I added the citation just in case!]

I first thought...
"the width of the entire page will be x and the length will be y. The width of the printed area then is x - 4 (excluding the side margins) and the length of the printed area is y - 6. So (x - 4)(y - 6) = 81 cm2.

The total area is A = xy. y, in terms of x, is y = \frac{1000}{x - 4} + 6. So then I figured:

If (x - 4)(y - 6) = 81 then surely y = \frac{81}{x - 4} + 6?

A(x) = x ( \frac{1000}{x - 4} + 6 ) would be the area and I would take its derivative and set A'(x) = 0."

I always end up with 81x - 81x in the differentiated function and get 0 = -324. I've tried multiple approaches (including setting x to the width of the printed page and then the total width being x + 4) and using different methods to get to the derivative, but this always happens.

Thanks for the help!

EDIT: Whoops! Thanks, chet!

unsimplified:
A'(x) =\frac{81(x-4) - 81x}{(x - 4)^2}

(LaTeX fixed)

I think you're missing a 6(x-4)^2 from the numerator; you should have A'(x) = xy'(x) + y(x).
 
pasmith said:
If (x - 4)(y - 6) = 81 then surely y = \frac{81}{x - 4} + 6?



(LaTeX fixed)

I think you're missing a 6(x-4)^2 from the numerator; you should have A'(x) = xy'(x) + y(x).

I see what I did wrong; I didn't differentiate correctly. I got it now, thanks :D
 

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
6K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
5K
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
941
Replies
3
Views
4K