- #31
Mk
- 2,039
- 4
w00t TSO! :!)DaveC426913 said:
After I learn how to play guitar I know I am going to do that. Although a band would be better than one person.
Pachelbel's Canon in the 21st Century
- Thread starter neutrino
- Start date
Click For Summary
Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the reinterpretation of Pachelbel's Canon in modern music, particularly its adaptations in rock and metal genres. Participants express their opinions on various renditions, the emotional impact of the piece, and the reasons behind its popularity across different musical backgrounds.
Discussion Character
- Debate/contested
- Exploratory
- Conceptual clarification
Main Points Raised
- Some participants express strong negative feelings towards modern adaptations of Pachelbel's Canon, describing them as "mangled" or "misabused".
- Others argue that certain modern renditions, such as those by younger musicians, can be enjoyable and showcase talent.
- A few participants seek recommendations for traditional arrangements of the Canon, indicating a preference for classical interpretations over modern takes.
- Some contributors reflect on the emotional resonance of the Canon, suggesting that its simplicity and beauty appeal to a wide audience.
- There are discussions about the technical aspects of different performances, with participants debating the smoothness and complexity of various guitar interpretations.
- One participant expresses a desire to create a group that performs classical pieces using modern instruments, indicating a potential interest in blending genres.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants generally do not reach a consensus; there are multiple competing views regarding the value and quality of modern adaptations of Pachelbel's Canon. Some appreciate the reinterpretations, while others vehemently oppose them.
Contextual Notes
Participants express varying degrees of familiarity with musical scales and arrangements, which may influence their perspectives on the Canon's adaptations. There is also mention of overexposure to the piece, which affects individual responses to its modern renditions.
Who May Find This Useful
This discussion may be of interest to music enthusiasts, particularly those interested in classical music adaptations, the emotional impact of musical compositions, and the blending of genres in contemporary music.
After I learn how to play guitar I know I am going to do that. Although a band would be better than one person.
- #32
Kurdt
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 4,859
- 6
In the best songs thread I posted the link to the guy who arranged this piece and who the person in the original post was immitating.
http://jerryc.tw/
The guy is excellent and he has a few vids on there and a few original compositions. I particularly like his rock on many techniques displayed there.
http://jerryc.tw/
The guy is excellent and he has a few vids on there and a few original compositions. I particularly like his rock on many techniques displayed there.
Last edited:
- #33
moose
- 556
- 0
Yes! I love his rock on video O.O!
- #34
Anttech
- 233
- 0
neutrino said:This is a must hear!
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=551670992127427964
Its very good, he has a lot of talent...
The most classical I ever get is derek May Strings of Life anyway
Last edited by a moderator:
- #35
Kurdt
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 4,859
- 6
I remember seeing a while back when he (jerryC) posted the canon rock video on a guitar forum he went to and people went nuts. The place he hosted it had to take it down because the bandwidth usage went through the roof. his career really took off from that one video and I must say I really do like the guys stuff a lot.
- #36
The Bob
- 1,126
- 0
Castilla said:
Well as no one has picked this up I believe I will
'Do mayor' is the equivalent to 'C major' (but the cannon was originally in D major).
Here are the other key relationships (Spanish to English):
'La' is equivalent to 'A'
'Si' is equivalent to 'B'
'Do' is equivalent to 'C'
'Re' is equivalent to 'D'
'Mi' is equivalent to 'E'
'Fa' is equivalent to 'F'
'Sol' is equivalent to 'G'
The Bob (2006 ©)
- #37
Castilla
- 241
- 0
Thanks, Bob.
In George Winston’s piano version, the tune is in C major. In six pages of sheet music you touch a black keyboard only once.
It seems to me that a minor tune can’t achieve the popularity of a major one. I doubt, for example, that the Beethoven’s moonlight sonata (mentioned by Neutrino) will be translated in rythms akin to the youngers. It is too sad.
Regarding the canon, I love both the George Winston and the Jerry C versions (Jerry C is the taiwanase young man that has made the speed metal arrangements). But if your mood fails easily on melancholy, without doubt I recommend you the speed metal version. I am sure it will enlive and strength you (it is the good word?).
In George Winston’s piano version, the tune is in C major. In six pages of sheet music you touch a black keyboard only once.
It seems to me that a minor tune can’t achieve the popularity of a major one. I doubt, for example, that the Beethoven’s moonlight sonata (mentioned by Neutrino) will be translated in rythms akin to the youngers. It is too sad.
Regarding the canon, I love both the George Winston and the Jerry C versions (Jerry C is the taiwanase young man that has made the speed metal arrangements). But if your mood fails easily on melancholy, without doubt I recommend you the speed metal version. I am sure it will enlive and strength you (it is the good word?).
Last edited:
- #38
Castilla
- 241
- 0
More or less what I think:
(From an Oregon daily)
"I know. We're all sick to death of the Canon, except for those weepy brides who insist on walking down the aisle to its solemn beat. But this kid utterly transforms the piece. You won't believe how good he is.
A typical reaction from a viewer:
"I've been in the music biz for over 30 years..this is one othe best demos i have ever seen/heard..period."
- David Stabler"
(From an Oregon daily)
"I know. We're all sick to death of the Canon, except for those weepy brides who insist on walking down the aisle to its solemn beat. But this kid utterly transforms the piece. You won't believe how good he is.
A typical reaction from a viewer:
"I've been in the music biz for over 30 years..this is one othe best demos i have ever seen/heard..period."
- David Stabler"