Partial Fractions, Method of Cancelling

In summary, the process of using partial fractions to expand a function involves integrating afterwards, but this does not affect the method. The method used is to rearrange the function into the form of A/(x+1) + B/(x-4) and solve for the constants A and B by canceling out factors of x. This method has been used since high school and is also stated in the textbook, but the instructor insists it is incorrect because finding constants for specific values of x does not guarantee they will work for all x. However, this is not true as the relation should hold for all x if it holds for specific values. This method can be linked to the method of residues, and while it may get tricky with
  • #1
Ledge
4
0

Homework Statement


Expand Using Partial Fractions:
f(x) = ( 5x-10 )/ ( (x+1)(x-4) )

Involves Integrating afterwards but I don't think this affects my method.

Homework Equations


This was a question in my mid semester exam, I got the answer correct but he insists my method is wrong.

The Attempt at a Solution



The method I used was to get into the form of:
( 5x-10 )/ ( (x+1)(x-4) ) = A/(x+1) + B/(x-4)
then, rearrange to:
5x-10 = A(x-4) + B(x+1)
and pick values of x to cancel the factors such as 4 and -1 and solve for A & B.
so:
5(4)-10 = B(4+1) → B = 2
5(-1)-10 = A(-1-4) → A = 3

I got this method from high school and have been using it ever since, I also found it clearly stated in the textbook we are currently using. After showing him he still insists the textbook and I are wrong. His reasoning is that finding A & B for a specific value of x cannot be assumed to work for all x. I don't understand his logic as A & B are constants.
Is there any way I can prove this to him? Like a rigorous proof of some sort. Or if I am possibly wrong, can someone explain it to me as he is not good with articulating at all.

Thanks in advance for any help :).
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Your method is fine. If the relation holds for all x, it should certainly hold for specific values of x, like x=4.

I'm not sure how you can convince your instructor, though.
 
  • #3
Isn't partial fractions included as a part of calculus classes?
 
  • #4
Yeah sorry it is, I thought it was assumed knowledge from high school and guessed it was algebra.

EDIT: Thanks vela, I guess I'll try to continue to get it through to him, if not I'll have to make a complaint or something.
 
Last edited:
  • #5
Ledge, I agree with you and vela. When you solve for the constants in a partial fractions decomposition, the equation you set up is an identity - one that holds for all values of x other than those that make any of the denominators vanish.

I sympathize with your frustration. I worked with a guy one time who insisted that all of his peer instructors at our college, and the textbook were doing things wrong. During my stint as the head of the math department, I tried to get him fired, but since he was a member of the union, all my efforts were in vain. Fortunately for the college and his students, he retired.
 
  • #6
Oh, yeah, I know that type! When I was chair of a math department (yes, my shameful past) we had hired a guy that I soon found out had told Calculus students to find "max" and "min" values by just comparing the values of f(x) for integer x. For that and other reasons, we dismissed him after one semester. Fortunately, because he was a new hire, it was in his contract that the first semester was a "trial".
 
  • #7
Ledge said:
Is there any way I can prove this to him? Like a rigorous proof of some sort. Or if I am possibly wrong, can someone explain it to me as he is not good with articulating at all.

Thanks in advance for any help :).

Your method can probably be directly tied to the method of residues shown in the following reference. The case of degenerate poles gets a little more tricky, but this is an accepted method.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partial_fraction
 
Last edited:

1. What is the partial fractions method?

The partial fractions method is a technique used to simplify complex rational expressions into simpler forms. It involves breaking down a rational expression into multiple smaller fractions with simpler denominators.

2. When is the partial fractions method used?

The partial fractions method is typically used when integrating rational functions or solving equations involving rational expressions. It can also be used to simplify complex algebraic expressions.

3. What is the process for using the partial fractions method?

The process for using the partial fractions method involves the following steps:

  1. Factor the denominator of the rational expression into irreducible factors.
  2. Write out the partial fractions for each factor, with unknown constants as coefficients.
  3. Set up equations by equating the original rational expression to the sum of the partial fractions.
  4. Solve for the unknown constants by comparing coefficients.
  5. Combine the partial fractions and simplify if possible.

4. What is the method of cancelling in partial fractions?

The method of cancelling in partial fractions involves cancelling out common factors in the numerator and denominator of a rational expression to simplify it. This can be done after the partial fractions have been set up and before solving for the unknown constants.

5. What are the advantages of using the partial fractions method?

Using the partial fractions method allows for complex rational expressions to be broken down into simpler forms, making them easier to integrate, solve, or simplify. It also allows for the use of known integration formulas for each individual partial fraction, making the overall process more manageable.

Similar threads

  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
8
Views
897
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
9
Views
1K
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
10
Views
287
Replies
9
Views
661
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
954
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
8
Views
871
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
690
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
564
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
774
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
11
Views
917
Back
Top