- #31
J77
- 1,091
- 1
Yeah - that's why I stuck it in inverted commasZapperZ said:
Personal Fable: The Illusion of Greatness in Science
- Thread starter tim_lou
- Start date
-
- Tags
- Noble prize Reality
Click For Summary
The discussion revolves around the tension between aspiring to greatness in physics and the harsh realities of the field. Many participants reflect on their initial ambitions to achieve significant discoveries, often comparing themselves to renowned figures like Einstein. However, they acknowledge that the path to becoming a successful physicist is long, challenging, and often discouraging, requiring deep passion rather than a desire for fame. The conversation highlights the psychological journey of students as they confront competition and the realization that many share similar lofty dreams, which can lead to disillusionment. Ultimately, the consensus is that while ambition is important, it must be grounded in a genuine love for the subject and an understanding of the difficulties involved.
- #32
genxhis
- 37
- 1
It isn't such a bad idea to imagine your a great physicist, at least once in a while. It boosts your self-confidence and makes you feel better. But realizing your not so spectacular isn't such a bad thing either; certainly, it taught me some humility.
For the most part though, I like to think of the whole physics community as one unit. Every one, even the great ones, are "standing on the shoulders of giants." (Newton's line if you haven't heard it.)
For the most part though, I like to think of the whole physics community as one unit. Every one, even the great ones, are "standing on the shoulders of giants." (Newton's line if you haven't heard it.)
- #33
mathwonk
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
2024 Award
- 11,957
- 2,231
Zapper is right on. Go with what you love. American idol is an absurd comparison for academia. Academic life is the opposite: to be happy one has to be content helping people, and advancing the subject you work in, in a way that will probably never bring any recognition, or even compensation remotely commensurate with your effort and ability.
American idol is perversely entertaining precisely for those persons who hope to hit the jackpot with a modicum of ability and even less effort. Don't be one of them.
American idol is perversely entertaining precisely for those persons who hope to hit the jackpot with a modicum of ability and even less effort. Don't be one of them.
Last edited:
Similar threads
- · Replies 11 ·
- · Replies 22 ·
- · Replies 19 ·
- · Replies 4 ·
- · Replies 17 ·
- · Replies 10 ·
Admissions
Phyics REU personal statement critiques?
- · Replies 6 ·
- · Replies 5 ·