Which Physics Subfield Offers the Best Job Prospects in Canada?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers around the job prospects for Ph.D. graduates in various subfields of physics in Canada. Participants explore different areas of physics, including medical physics, quantum optics, and engineering, while considering the balance between intense physics and mathematics and career opportunities.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants suggest that engineering may offer better job prospects compared to physics, especially for undergraduates.
  • Others express a desire to focus on physics and explore various fields rather than switch to engineering.
  • Concerns are raised about the applicability of physics degrees in non-related fields, citing examples of graduates working in data analysis instead of their studied fields.
  • Interest in medical physics is noted, with some participants questioning the intensity of mathematics and physics involved compared to other fields.
  • Participants mention specific career paths for physics graduates, including chip manufacturing, materials science, photonics, and data science.
  • There is a discussion about the competitive nature of job opportunities in optical physics and the importance of internships or research placements for gaining experience.
  • Salary comparisons between optical physicists and medical physicists are presented, highlighting a significant gap that raises concerns about living standards in Canada.
  • Geographical location is emphasized as a crucial factor influencing job opportunities in different physics subfields.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express multiple competing views regarding the best subfield of physics for job prospects, with no consensus reached on a single field being superior. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the balance between personal interest in research and practical job opportunities.

Contextual Notes

Participants note that career opportunities can vary significantly based on location, and the discussion reflects a range of personal preferences and experiences related to job prospects in physics and engineering.

AryaKimiaghalam
Messages
88
Reaction score
7
Hi,
I'm starting my undergrad studies in math and physics this fall. I wanted to know what subfield of physics gives the best job opportunity to a Ph.D. graduate? I want to work in a field that I studied in. Not like particle physicists working in financial maths. Which field uses intense physics and mathematics and have a good career path at the same time? I've heard of medical physics, but I'm not sure they use a lot of intense math/physics compared to other fields like solid state physics or etc?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Have you considered engineering? It tends to be a lot more career focused than math or physics.

Especially since you're just starting your undergrad, and you're talking about jobs you'd get after a Ph.D.- that's 10+ years away. A lot can change in that time, which makes it hard to make predictions about any specific physics subfields. An engineering degree would let you get a related job right after undergrad though, or after a (relatively short compared to a Ph.D.) master's degree.
 
Hi pi-r8
I'm planning for physics. I don't like engineering. It feels too focused for now! I want to explore different things.
 
AryaKimiaghalam said:
Hi pi-r8
I'm planning for physics. I don't like engineering. It feels too focused for now! I want to explore different things.
To me that sounds like it will fundamentally conflict with "I want to work in a field that I studied in". Would you be ok exploring a few different things, and then picking just one to work in?
 
I don’t want to be forced to get a job in a non related field. One of my relatives studied geophysics but he is doing data analysis in a tech company now
 
I find engineering too focused for undergrad
 
AryaKimiaghalam said:
I find engineering too focused for undergrad
You need to read about the local Engineering program options carefully. Engineering is too big a field and is filled with a great deal many kinds of courses. Physics and Engineering are different in the way that you are beginning to understand, in that people become engineering graduates so that they can find jobs to design, find ways to monitor, and to develop processes and products. People get degrees in Physics if they wish to explore and understand.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Hypercube
I like the research side more. I'm very interested in applying mathematics and physics into medicine like molecular imaging research, and radiation oncology. I also like astrophysics but I'm sure the job opportunity is not good.
 
AryaKimiaghalam said:
I like the research side more. I'm very interested in applying mathematics and physics into medicine like molecular imaging research, and radiation oncology. I also like astrophysics but I'm sure the job opportunity is not good.
Very good; and all of that relies on technology which is why I say to look into what is in an engineering degree program. I'm not saying that you should switch to engineering instead. Just I'm saying you need to become more aware.
 
  • #10
symbolipoint said:
Very good; and all of that relies on technology which is why I say to look into what is in an engineering degree program. I'm not saying that you should switch to engineering instead. Just I'm saying you need to become more aware.
It's true. engineering is more practical. I'll research about it. But do you know which field in physics gives you the best job opportunity?
 
  • #11
AryaKimiaghalam said:
Hi,
I'm starting my undergrad studies in math and physics this fall. I wanted to know what subfield of physics gives the best job opportunity to a Ph.D. graduate? I want to work in a field that I studied in. Not like particle physicists working in financial maths. Which field uses intense physics and mathematics and have a good career path at the same time? I've heard of medical physics, but I'm not sure they use a lot of intense math/physics compared to other fields like solid state physics or etc?

To the OP:

One thing you need to note that degrees in physics and math are not vocational degrees, so you need to expand your definition on what is a field that you studied in. For a PhD in physics, that could mean the following, if you work in industry:

1. chip manufacturing at places like Intel (if you do research in, say, experimental condensed matter physics)
2. materials science (again, for those in experimental condensed matter physics)
3. photonics (if you specialize in optics)
4. medical physics
5. scientific computing
6. data science

Please note that when you say "use intense physics and mathematics" -- all intense physics and math type jobs will involve at some level a lot of coding/programming, so practically any job that involves considerable scientific programming or data science will involve physics and math at varying levels of intensity.

Of course, the most intense physics and math jobs will be in academia, but I'm assuming you posted because you realize that academic jobs are relatively sparse.
 
  • #12
Yes i don t like to work in academia. The pay raise is non existent
 
  • #13
I like medical physics but i fear there is no much math and physics in the work compared to other fields.
 
  • #14
In all of this back-and-forth, not once did the OP mentioned, or anyone responding to this asked, where in the world the OP is, or where he/she intends on seeking employment.

Career opportunities in ANY field is highly dependent on LOCATION. Someone with a Ph.D in astrophysics has a significantly different career opportunity in Ethiopia when compared to, say, in the UK. So, shouldn't this factor matter as much as anything else?

Zz.
 
  • #15
I want to stay in Canada for work. I'm deciding between specializing in quantum optics and work as a optical physicist, or specialize in medical physics and work as a radiation physicist.
 
  • #16
AryaKimiaghalam said:
I want to stay in Canada for work. I'm deciding between specializing in quantum optics and work as a optical physicist, or specialize in medical physics and work as a radiation physicist.

As someone from Canada myself, I can state that there are opportunities in both optical physics and in medical physics. My understanding is that optical physics positions are highly competitive, so if that is the area you wish to go into, I strongly advise you to pursue an internship or a research placement (e.g. through the NSERC USRA program) in a research lab during your undergraduate studies.

With respect to medical physics, @Choppy is a medical physicist in Canada, so he should be the person you should direct your questions to regarding medical physics opportunities.
 
  • #17
AryaKimiaghalam said:
I like the research side more. I'm very interested in applying mathematics and physics into medicine like molecular imaging research, and radiation oncology. I also like astrophysics but I'm sure the job opportunity is not good.
Biomedical engineering
 
  • #18
I researched about the salaries in both fields. Median (Canada)
Optical physicist: 88k
Medical physicist: 135k
This is a huge gap. I guess a phd in quantum optics will at most get 100k. It’s a bit disappointing.
 
  • #19
I don’t think you can have a convenient life with 88k in Canada. Living is very costly in Ontario.
 
  • #20
AryaKimiaghalam said:
I don’t think you can have a convenient life with 88k in Canada. Living is very costly in Ontario.

Can't live "conveniently" off 88k a year? I know of couples who make less than that with combined salaries, and they live quite comfortably. In Ontario as well!

Unless your goal is to buy property in Vancouver or downtown Toronto right off the bat, I can assure you that you can make a living making 88k a year in Canada.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: symbolipoint
  • #21
AryaKimiaghalam said:
I researched about the salaries in both fields. Median (Canada)
Optical physicist: 88k
Medical physicist: 135k
This is a huge gap. I guess a phd in quantum optics will at most get 100k. It’s a bit disappointing.

AryaKimiaghalam said:
I don’t think you can have a convenient life with 88k in Canada. Living is very costly in Ontario.

Y'know, this is getting to be a bit exasperating.

First you never revealed where you were. Then, after you were given a bunch of info, you suddenly sprang upon us your "hidden" criteria of making money. You could have EASILY researched this already and, if this is all you cared about, could have made your own decision without needing any input from us. So now, that "135k" suddenly is the over-riding factor in your choice.

So what was that "... they use a lot of intense math/physics compared to other fields ... " all about in your first post? Nowhere in there was average salary was ever mentioned. All you wanted was a field that "use a lot of intense math/physics".

I'm checking out. Good luck!

Zz.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: StoneTemplePython
  • #22
AryaKimiaghalam said:
I don’t think you can have a convenient life with 88k in Canada. Living is very costly in Ontario.

As a Canadian who has lived and worked in five different provinces, I find this post to be very offensive.

"Ontario" does not equal "Canada", and "GTA" does not equal "Ontario"!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: atyy
  • #23
Those salaries are before taxation and that 88 actually becomes 65k . Also, if you can't make "enough" money in your field of interest, it's better to give up some things for the sake of future! My true interest is astrophysics, but I know that job opportunities are limited and having a stable job is a lifelong challenge. I'm not jumping on any conclusion, but you think I do! I'm just trying to find the best option, that has "physics/math intense content" and "enough money to have a convenient life". I know some people who did not think about this and they feel terrible for themselves and their family now. Don't get hostile please.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: nrqed
  • #24
George Jones said:
As a Canadian who has lived and worked in five different provinces, I find this post to be very offensive.

"Ontario" does not equal "Canada", and "GTA" does not equal "Ontario"!

I apologize if I offended you. "convenient life" is a subjective thing. people have different standards.
 
  • #25
as far as I know most jobs (physics related) are in big cities. So there are some geographical boundaries to it!
 
  • #26
AryaKimiaghalam said:
Those salaries are before taxation and that 88 actually becomes 65k . Also, if you can't make "enough" money in your field of interest, it's better to give up some things for the sake of future! My true interest is astrophysics, but I know that job opportunities are limited and having a stable job is a lifelong challenge. I'm not jumping on any conclusion, but you think I do! I'm just trying to find the best option, that has "physics/math intense content" and "enough money to have a convenient life". I know some people who did not think about this and they feel terrible for themselves and their family now. Don't get hostile please.
Okay so you are worried about salary and you want to do mathematics/physics intensive things. Pick Engineering and get your degree, ... and be done with it. Maybe include a Minor concentration in Physics.
 
  • #27
symbolipoint said:
Okay so you are worried about salary and you want to do mathematics/physics intensive things. Pick Engineering and get your degree, ... and be done with it. Maybe include a Minor concentration in Physics.

I still want to be in the field of physics but that's not a bad idea!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: symbolipoint
  • #28
AryaKimiaghalam said:
as far as I know most jobs (physics related) are in big cities. So there are some geographical boundaries to it!

It is such a competitive market that most folks are willing to go where the job is. There are more jobs in bigger cities, but I have met research astrophysicists from small cities, e.g., Brandon Manitoba, Sackville New Brunswick, and Antigonish Nova Scotia.
 
  • #29
George Jones said:
It is such a competitive market that most folks are willing to go where the job is. There are more jobs in bigger cities, but I have met research astrophysicists from small cities, e.g., Brandon Manitoba, Sackville New Brunswick, and Antigonish Nova Scotia.
but they are exceptions.
 
  • #30
AryaKimiaghalam said:
but they are exceptions.

Also, I have met research astrophysicists from St. John's Newfoundland, Halifax Nova Scotia, Fredericton New Brunswick, Lennoxville Quebec, Kingston Ontario, London Ontario, Windsor Ontario, Lethbridge Alberta, and Kelowna British Columbia.

These so-called exceptions quickly add up, and if you are not willing to consider places like I the ones I have listed here and in my previous post, you really limit yourself.

By the way, all of these places are located in Canada.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: atyy and AryaKimiaghalam

Similar threads

  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
4K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
4K
Replies
13
Views
4K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
5K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
4K
Replies
5
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
5K