Pore pressure due to capillary rise

9 replies · 3K views · last reply
tzx9633

Homework Statement


Why there's no pore pressure due to capillary rise at point A and point D ? There's only pore pressure due to capillary rise at B ..

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


i think the author is wrong . There's should be also ore pressure due to capillary rise at A and D . Because the capillary rise can occur anywhere in the soil .
 
Attachments
  • Textbook page excerpt titled 9.10 Effective Stress in the Zone of Capillary Rise, stating σ = σ′ + u and that pore water pressure in capillary-saturated soil equals −γw h, where h is height above the water table.
    678.PNG
    12.8 KB · Views: 574
  • Textbook page excerpt showing equation 9.33 for pore pressure from partial saturation: u = -(S/100)γw h, with S defined as degree of saturation in percent.
    679.PNG
    10 KB · Views: 585
  • Soil profile diagram with layers labelled H1, H2 and H3, points A to D marked, a zone of capillary rise above the groundwater table, and a legend for sand, saturated clay and rock.
    680.PNG
    50.2 KB · Views: 626
  • Worked stress calculation for moist sand over saturated clay, listing unit weights, void ratio, total stress, pore pressure and effective stress at points A, B, C and D.
    681.png
    40.5 KB · Views: 543
tzx9633 said:

Homework Statement


Why there's no pore pressure due to capillary rise at point A and point D ? There's only pore pressure due to capillary rise at B ..

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


i think the author is wrong . There's should be also ore pressure due to capillary rise at A and D . Because the capillary rise can occur anywhere in the soil .
Can you please define the variables in your equations.
 
Chestermiller said:
Can you please define the variables in your equations.
Huh , what do you mean ?

It's the pore water pressure due to capillary rise , u = -s(yw)(H2)
 
There is no water in the pores at A; it is above the saturation zone. At D, the pores are all fully saturated, because it is below the water table, and there is no capillary pressure there because there is no free surface (between air and water) in this zone. So the author is correct.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: tzx9633
Chestermiller said:
there is no capillary pressure there because there is no free surface (between air and water) in this zone. So the author is correct.
Having said that there's capillary rise at B , means that there is free surface (between air and water) in this zone ?

I didnt see there's air at B , can you explain further ?
 
tzx9633 said:
Having said that there's capillary rise at B , means that there is free surface (between air and water) in this zone ?
Sure.
I didnt see there's air at B , can you explain further ?
What do the words "50% saturated" mean to you?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: tzx9633
Chestermiller said:
Sure.

What do the words "50% saturated" mean to you?
ok , noted . Why there is no pore pressure due to capillary rise at C ?
 
tzx9633 said:
ok , noted . Why there is no pore pressure due to capillary rise at C ?
At C and below, the pores are completely full of water.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: tzx9633
Chestermiller said:
There is no water in the pores at A; it is above the saturation zone. At D, the pores are all fully saturated, because it is below the water table, and there is no capillary pressure there because there is no free surface (between air and water) in this zone. So the author is correct.
How do you know that there's no water at A ? How do you know that there's water at B ?
 
tzx9633 said:
How do you know that there's no water at A ? How do you know that there's water at B ?
The figure implies that, between A and B, there is dry sand and between B and C, there is partially saturated sand. So, B is the top of the region containing water in some of the pores.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: tzx9633