Position of speaker in front of tube to produce stationary wave

Click For Summary
The discussion centers on the optimal positioning of a speaker to create stationary waves in a tube. It emphasizes that placing the speaker at a 45-degree angle helps minimize the coupling of the loudspeaker diaphragm to the wave, allowing reflections to be directed away from the tube. This positioning prevents reflections from re-entering the tube, which could disrupt resonance. The exact angle may not be critical, suggesting that other angles, like 60 degrees, could also work. Proper speaker placement is essential for effective wave formation and resonance in the experiment.
songoku
Messages
2,497
Reaction score
400
1621262147437.png


That is part of the article. I want to ask about step 4. I know the basic theory of how stationary wave is formed (superposition of incoming and reflected wave) and also basic concept about stationary wave in open and closed tube, something like this:
1621262304441.png

But I don't know the reason why in step 4, the speaker must be placed at angle 45o, not pointed directly into it. If I imagine it, putting the speaker directly in front of the tube will also produce reflection and possibly stationary wave.

Why should be the speaker placed at certain angle? And must it be 45o, or can it be some other angle such as 60o?

Thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
songoku said:
Summary:: I googled a lot of thing related to experiment to produce stationary wave using speaker and open / closed pipe and I saw an article.

Why should be the speaker placed at certain angle? And must it be 45o, or can it be some other angle such as 60o?
I think it must be to reduce the 'coupling' of the loudspeaker diaphragm to the wave in the tube and so that the reflection of the exiting wave will tend to be deflected away from the tube and not back into the tube and present an 'almost closed' end to that wave, affecting the resonance. The angle won't be ever so critical.
 
  • Like
Likes songoku and tech99
sophiecentaur said:
I think it must be to reduce the 'coupling' of the loudspeaker diaphragm to the wave in the tube and so that the reflection of the exiting wave will tend to be deflected away from the tube and not back into the tube and present an 'almost closed' end to that wave, affecting the resonance. The angle won't be ever so critical.
Thank you very much sophiecentaur
 
For fun I was trying to use energy considerations to determine the depth to which a solid object will sink in a fluid to reach equilibrium. The first approach that I tried was just to consider the change in potential energy of the block and the fluid as the block is lowered some unknown distance d into the fluid similar to what is shown in the answer to this post. Upon taking the limit as the vessel's cross sectional area approaches infinity I have an extra factor of 2 in the equilibrium...