Primes and Associates in Rings

Zoe-b

1. Homework Statement
Let a, b be members of a commutative ring with identity R. If a is a a prime and a, b are associates then b is also prime. True/False

2. Homework Equations
Definitions: a is prime if a|xy implies a|x or a|y
a and b are associates if there exists a unit u s.t a=bu

3. The Attempt at a Solution
First off I'm not sure whether its even true or not; so I've tried to both prove it and find a counter example:
Attempt at a proof:
let b|xy.
Then if b = au for some unit u, au|xy, that is for some k in R auk = xy.
so ak divides xy(u^(-1))
but k does not necessarily have an inverse so this doesn't really get me anywhere.

I've shown in an earlier question that if a is irreducible and a, b are associates then b is irreducible. Prime implies irreducible but not vice versa so if there is a counter example it will depend on an element of R that is irreducible but not prime. I know examples of these can be found in rings such as Z(5i) (the set of numbers a+5bi for a, b in Z). But I don't know how to find units of this ring.
Consider (a+5bi)(c+5di) = 1.
This gives the simultaneous equations 1+25bd-ac = 0 = ad+bc
But so far I have not managed to find any integer solutions (and to be honest I don't know any way of doing this other than trial and error).

Thanks for any help!

Related Calculus and Beyond Homework Help News on Phys.org

micromass

First off I'm not sure whether its even true or not; so I've tried to both prove it and find a counter example:
Attempt at a proof:
let b|xy.
Then if b = au for some unit u, au|xy, that is for some k in R auk = xy.
OK, so stop here. We know that auk=xy. So this implies that $ak=u^{-1}xy$. Thus a divides $u^{-1}xy$. Now use that a is prime.

Zoe-b

Thank you! Done it now :)

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving