Problem in getting correct coefficients of frictional forces

9 replies · 2K views · last reply
Amitayas Banerjee
Messages
31
Reaction score
2
I am getting correct equations on using the Lagrangian method in Systems with no non conservative forces, but when I use it in Systems with friction, sometimes I get correct equations, and sometimes I do not. Most of the equations have some problem with the coefficients of the frictional forces.
For example, let us take a look at this system...
Hand-drawn diagram of two masses connected by a rope over a pulley: block m2 on a horizontal surface with friction force f2 acting on it, and hanging block m1 with friction force f1 acting on its side.


Here f1,f2 are the frictional forces(and not the coefficients of friction)

Now, let the block with mass $m_2$ move through a distance $x$ to ward the right.
Handwritten derivation: V = -2m1gx, T = 1/2 m1(2x')^2 + 1/2 m2 x'^2, so L = x'^2(2m1 + 1/2 m2) + 2m1gx, then d/dt(dL/dx') - dL/dx = -f1 - f2, giving x'' = (2m1g - f1 - f2)/(4m1 + m2).


now, when we apply Newton's second law, we see that this is wrong and the coefficient of f1should have been 2
Why is the problem?...on the right hand side I have written the generalized force and the the two Lagrangian terms on the left hand side. Please help me out.
 
Attachments
  • Hand-drawn diagram of two masses connected by a rope over a pulley: block m2 on a horizontal surface with friction force f2 acting on it, and hanging block m1 with friction force f1 acting on its side.
    ss3iS.jpg
    31.5 KB · Views: 598
  • Handwritten derivation: V = -2m1gx, T = 1/2 m1(2x')^2 + 1/2 m2 x'^2, so L = x'^2(2m1 + 1/2 m2) + 2m1gx, then d/dt(dL/dx') - dL/dx = -f1 - f2, giving x'' = (2m1g - f1 - f2)/(4m1 + m2).
    Vqyxs.jpg
    32.4 KB · Views: 589
Orodruin said:
Standard Lagrangian mechanics does not handle dissipative systems.
I have not used that...I have used the version with generalized forces(RHS has got -f1-f2)
 
Amitayas Banerjee said:
I have not used that...I have used the version with generalized forces(RHS has got -f1-f2)
The RHS that you wrote is not the generalized forces, it is the regular forces. The generalized forces are
$$F_i \cdot \frac{\partial v_i}{\partial \dot{q_j}}$$
That is where the factor of 2 comes in
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Amitayas Banerjee
Dale said:
The RHS that you wrote is not the generalized forces, it is the regular forces. The generalized forces are
$$F_i \cdot \frac{\partial v_i}{\partial \dot{q_j}}$$
That is where the factor of 2 comes in
Sirl, is that vi=xdot i?
 
Orodruin said:
Standard Lagrangian mechanics does not handle dissipative systems.

I'm not sure what "standard" means in this context, but I use Lagrange frequently for systems involving losses. See Goldstein, pp. 38 - 40.
 
Amitayas Banerjee said:
Sirl, is that vi=xdot i?
@Dr.D Sir, can you clarify this?
 
Dr.D said:
I'm not sure what "standard" means in this context, but I use Lagrange frequently for systems involving losses. See Goldstein, pp. 38 - 40.
What edition are you using? Pages 38 to 40 in my Goldstein is just general variational calculus.

Anyway, I read the OP and replied a bit fast it seems. By "standard" I was meaning only letting the variation of an action be equal to zero, which is what most students learn first and many do not go beyond. For some reason I thought the OP was trying to do something like trying to introduce friction forces in the Lagrangian.
 
Orodruin said:
What edition are you using?
There is no edition number in my copy, only a 1959 copyright date and the notation 6th printing. For this reason, I presume it is a 1st edition. I used it as a textbook in the school year 1963-64. I've been using this to good effect ever since.