Problems faced in passenger aircraft

  • Thread starter Thread starter rambharath94
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Aircraft
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around identifying and proposing solutions to real-time problems associated with passenger aircraft, particularly from a mechanical engineering perspective. Topics include safety, efficiency, and operational challenges within the aviation industry.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants suggest problems such as stress reduction in aircraft, reducing chances of overrun, and improving visibility in overcast conditions.
  • One participant proposes an ejection-type black box that floats on impact, raising questions about regulatory challenges and technical feasibility.
  • Another participant introduces the idea of optimizing carry-on luggage placement to enhance boarding efficiency.
  • Concerns are raised about the additional weight and complexity of solutions like Kinetic Energy Recovery Systems (KERS) for taxiing.
  • Fuel sloshing is identified as a problem affecting aircraft dynamics, with suggestions for solutions involving low-weight materials to stabilize fuel movement.
  • Participants discuss the implications of FAA regulations on proposed solutions, particularly regarding black box designs and safety measures for short runways.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a variety of viewpoints on the problems and potential solutions, with no consensus reached on which issues to prioritize or how to effectively address them. Multiple competing ideas and concerns remain unresolved.

Contextual Notes

Participants note the limitations imposed by existing regulations and the technical challenges associated with implementing new solutions, particularly regarding safety and operational efficiency in aircraft design.

rambharath94
Messages
22
Reaction score
0
Hey Guys,
Me and my friends are planning to work on a project to solve some real time problem associated with passenger aircrafts.i would like you guys to suggest some problems faced by the industry so that we can solve them.Since i'am an mechanical engineer it would be better if the problem falls within this domain.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
rambharath94 said:
Hey Guys,
Me and my friends are planning to work on a project to solve some real time problem associated with passenger aircrafts.i would like you guys to suggest some problems faced by the industry so that we can solve them.Since i'am an mechanical engineer it would be better if the problem falls within this domain.

Since this is your schoolwork project, how about you tell us what your ideas are so far?
 
The guy in the window seat keeps getting up and waking me up.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: 1 person
I have a problem that you can try to solve... however I want to see your response to berkeman first.
 
berkeman said:
Since this is your schoolwork project, how about you tell us what your ideas are so far?

Actually i came across many problems and i have just noted down some.I'am trying to finilaize on something.

1)stress reduction in aircrafts.
2)Reducing chances of overrun of aircrafts.
3)Ejection type black box on impact which does not sink along with the aircraft but floats.
4)improving visibility in overcast conditions.
5)using Kinetic Energy Recovery System(KERS) for taxiiing.
 
rambharath94 said:
Actually i came across many problems and i have just noted down some.I'am trying to finilaize on something.

1)stress reduction in aircrafts.
2)Reducing chances of overrun of aircrafts.
3)Ejection type black box on impact which does not sink along with the aircraft but floats.
4)improving visibility in overcast conditions.
5)using Kinetic Energy Recovery System(KERS) for taxiiing.

I'd be interested in what you mean by the KERS...

One problem that would be nice to address is how to optimize the placement of carry-on luggage in the overhead bins and at people's feet. Can you think of something that could be done ahead of time before boarding, that would make it much more convenient, orderly and efficient in placing carry-on luggage? I can...
 
Over the years various proposals have been made to reduce fuel consumption of taxiing aircraft. The usual killer is the additional weight. Be sure to factor in the cost of carrying any solution around with the plane.

OT: A lot of know problems already have technical solutions. What's needed is the political will to implement them. For example it's daft that some cockpit voice recorders have to over write recordings after a few hours because they don't have enough memory!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: 1 person
I would go with whatever problem interests you the most.

The problem I have that you could look into is fuel sloshing. As the aircraft uses fuel the fuel tank empty's, which allows the fuel to move around, or "slosh", in the tank. This changes the dynamics of the aircraft. How can you prevent it.

I can tell you that to solve #3 you would have to change a whole lot of current FAA and EASA regulations. It would be very difficult to accomplish. However I am curious as to what you could come up with.

Can you elaborate on problem 2 and 5 for me?
 
I'm guessing that FAA regulations and procedures are beyond the scope of your homework problem. Anything you do to a commercial airline - especially ATP operations - will involve a lot of FAA scrutiny.
 
  • #10
donpacino said:
I would go with whatever problem interests you the most.

The problem I have that you could look into is fuel sloshing. As the aircraft uses fuel the fuel tank empty's, which allows the fuel to move around, or "slosh", in the tank. This changes the dynamics of the aircraft. How can you prevent it.

I can tell you that to solve #3 you would have to change a whole lot of current FAA and EASA regulations. It would be very difficult to accomplish. However I am curious as to what you could come up with.

Can you elaborate on problem 2 and 5 for me?



I appreciate your involvement ! What about a sheet of low-weight material that can prevent the movement of fuel inside the container ? it would be like... that the fuel is full at all times and hence it won't SLOSH ! But We need to rethink the fuel gauge designs again as they depend on the olden tech right ??

We first came up with a Floater design that would keep the recorders above the water surface ( I assume the crash happens above the oceans...most of the times they are ) but then that became absurd as that would carry it away from the crash site !
And then we came up with this..The blackbox be provided with a GPS ( in the existing design ).
We also thought about an idea of black box fitted with impact sensors ! which will send all the data which it has recorded to the ground station immaediately after impact ! But that would make it complicated !and Its not our field , so we were afraid to pursue/reject that idea !

regarding #2 ... Its an idea of reducing the accidents that occur due to the small length of the runways ! ( Many small airports suffer from these )

#5... Its is an idea of effectively using the KERS to recover energy from aircraft and to use it during taxiing

Thanks
 
  • #11
berkeman said:
I'd be interested in what you mean by the KERS...

One problem that would be nice to address is how to optimize the placement of carry-on luggage in the overhead bins and at people's feet. Can you think of something that could be done ahead of time before boarding, that would make it much more convenient, orderly and efficient in placing carry-on luggage? I can...


Thank you for the suggestion ! I will try to discuss this with my friends and get to you back shortly ! Ya You can ! and Yeah KERS is a very good concept ! But It increases the weight and complexity of the aircraft ! And WE are trying to overcome its limitations ! You can even share your ideas if you have any !
 
  • #12
rambharath94 said:
You can even share your ideas if you have any !

It's your project, so that's why I made my suggestion in the form of a hint and a question. The rest is up to you and your group's creativity. :smile:
 
  • #13
rambharath94 said:
We first came up with a Floater design that would keep the recorders above the water surface ( I assume the crash happens above the oceans...most of the times they are ) but then that became absurd as that would carry it away from the crash site !
And then we came up with this..The blackbox be provided with a GPS ( in the existing design ).
We also thought about an idea of black box fitted with impact sensors ! which will send all the data which it has recorded to the ground station immaediately after impact ! But that would make it complicated !and Its not our field , so we were afraid to pursue/reject that idea !

regarding #2 ... Its an idea of reducing the accidents that occur due to the small length of the runways ! ( Many small airports suffer from these )

#5... Its is an idea of effectively using the KERS to recover energy from aircraft and to use it during taxiing

Thanks
In order for the black boxes to float, they would need to separate from the aircraft - even after the aircraft has been severely crumpled. Also, the float mechanism would need to inflate even after being subjected to very high G forces and high temperatures. And there should be essentially no chance of the black box separating from the aircraft or the floatation mechanism inflating except during a crash.

I think you'll find that airports with very short runways, like Washington Reagan, have pretty good safety records. This is because pilots recognize the runway as a problem and make their approach and departure plans accordingly. Factors include:
* Aircraft type, gross weight
* Atmospheric conditions - temp, pressure, humidity, wind speed and direction
* Runway conditions - direction, take off location, obstacles, type of surface, inclination
* Aircraft configuration - flaps, etc.
There are apps to assist pilots with these calculations - for both takeoff and landings.

KERS: Of course, you will be absorbing energy from the braking system and restoring it to the propeller or jet engines - and doing it without adding a lot of weight to the aircraft.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 49 ·
2
Replies
49
Views
5K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 18 ·
Replies
18
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K