Product with an undefined term

In summary: I'm now wondering if this is an elaborate troll and I'm falling for it.In summary, the conversation discusses the concept of undefined values in mathematical expressions. It is concluded that in the given scenario, where c=ab and b is undefined but finite, if a=0, then c must be 0. The use of limits and the distributive law are mentioned as well as the assumption of numbers being real. The conversation also touches on the concept of undefined products and the existence of limits.
  • #1
mathman
Science Advisor
8,140
572
TL;DR Summary
product with undefined term
Let c=ab. Let b be undefined (but finite). If a=0, is c undefined or does c=0?
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Since B is finite and we assume B is element of the Reals and A is 0 then C must be 0.

"0 times any real number = 0" is a property of 0.
 
  • #3
What does ##b## finite but undefined even mean??
 
  • Like
Likes Vanadium 50, Delta2, Stephen Tashi and 1 other person
  • #4
Or what does c=ab mean? For the conclusion 0b=0 we need the distributive law and a loop for a.
 
  • #5
mathman said:
Summary: product with undefined term

Let c=ab. Let b be undefined (but finite). If a=0, is c undefined or does c=0?
It is 0, afaik. Using limits, let ##\epsilon \rightarrow 0## assume a is not really zero but very small and you can make the product very small thanks to the bound on c: ## ab < Max(b) \frac {\epsilon}{ Max(b)} ## for all ##\epsilon##.
 
  • #6
WWGD said:
It is 0, afaik.
Not necessarily. Even if we assume ##0## as neutral element of addition, and the unwritten operation as a multiplication, it is not clear if we have the distributive law, or another combination of the two operations. Furthermore, we need an additive inverse and an element ##a\neq 0##. If we lack any of these, then I don't know a valid proof for ##0\cdot b=0##.
 
  • #7
Math_QED said:
What does ##b## finite but undefined even mean??

Perhaps it means that the vlerth level of b is less than 16, but we don't know what a vlerth level is.
 
  • Like
Likes member 587159
  • #8
fresh_42 said:
Not necessarily. Even if we assume ##0## as neutral element of addition, and the unwritten operation as a multiplication, it is not clear if we have the distributive law, or another combination of the two operations. Furthermore, we need an additive inverse and an element ##a\neq 0##. If we lack any of these, then I don't know a valid proof for ##0\cdot b=0##.
See my previous. This is used e.g. to conclude that lim h-->0 hSin(1/h)=0 . The expression is bounded above by ##Max(a)\frac{\epsilon}{Max(a)}## for all ##\epsilon##.
 
  • #9
WWGD said:
See my previous. This is used e.g. to conclude that lim h-->0 hSin(1/h)=0 . The expression is bounded above by ##Max(a)\frac{\epsilon}{Max(a)}## for all ##\epsilon##.
Yes, but you already make a hidden assumption, namely that we are talking about ordinary numbers.
 
  • #10
fresh_42 said:
Yes, but you already make a hidden assumption, namely that we are talking about ordinary numbers.
How are they not ordinary numbers? Arent they all assumed to be Real numbers? Whatever value the bounded undefined takes, the product will be bounded above by epsilon.
 
  • #11
WWGD said:
How are they not ordinary numbers? Arent they all assumed to be Real numbers?
Who knows? I always think in terms of algebras, in which multiplication is not a natural given extension of school counting. But I admit that distribution is one of the very basic and here crucial properties, which is usually assumed.
 
  • Like
Likes jedishrfu
  • #12
fresh_42 said:
Who knows? I always think in terms of algebras, in which multiplication is not a natural given extension of school counting.
Fair enough, I was assuming numbers were Real. If not, it is a whole different situation. When we talk about bounded I guess we assume a modulus or valuation.
 
  • #13
But in what setting outside of the Reals does a question like this make sense? Maybe @mathman can clarify the setting?
 
  • #14
WWGD said:
But in what setting outside of the Reals does a question like this make sense? Maybe @mathman can clarify the setting?
I have found another proof, which only uses the distributive law, and characteristic not two. Again, everything depends on the distributive law. Given that we can conclude with ##a-a=0##, either for an ##a\neq 0## or for ##a=0## with ##\operatorname{char} \neq 2##.

However, if distribution is not given, then everything is possible.
 
  • #15
But there was a notion of boundedness used, so there is a norm or valuation too.
 
  • #16
mathman said:
Let c=ab. Let b be undefined (but finite). If a=0, is c undefined or does c=0?
Instead of making assumptions about what is being asked here, why don't we hold off until @mathman returns to clarify what sorts of things a, b, and c are?
Clearly if a, b, and c are members of the real or complex field, the question is trivial and undeserving of an 'A' tag.
 
  • Like
Likes jedishrfu
  • #17
Clarification: I was thinking about expressions like xsin(1/x) for x=0. Real numbers and ordinary multiplication.
 
  • #18
mathman said:
Clarification: I was thinking about expressions like xsin(1/x) for x=0. Real numbers and ordinary multiplication.
Then just let x approach 0 as ##\epsilon/(Max(Sin(1/x))= \epsilon/1 ## so that ## xsin(1/x) < \epsilon \cdot 1 = \epsilon ## for all ## \epsilon##
 
  • #19
I am well aware that the limitng process gives 0. However there seems to be a school of thought which asserts that sin(1/0) being undefined, multiplying by 0 results in an undefined product.

An interest variation is about ##f(x)=x^2sin(1/x)##, with ##f'(x)=2xsin(1/x)-cos(1/x)## for ##x\ne 0##, which is undefined as ##x\to 0##, but ##f'(0)=0##
 
  • #20
Computer math follows that trend when some factor isn't computable then a NaN is returned and this taints the rest of the calculation resulting in a NaN as the final answer.
 
  • #21
WWGD said:
Then just let x approach 0 as ##\epsilon/(Max(Sin(1/x))= \epsilon/1 ## so that ## xsin(1/x) < \epsilon \cdot 1 = \epsilon ## for all ## \epsilon##
Then the operation of multiplication is undefined. Axioms/rules only stipulate multiplication within the Real numbers.
 
  • #22
mathman said:
An interest variation is about ##f(x)=x^2sin(1/x)##, with ##f'(x)=2xsin(1/x)-cos(1/x)## for ##x\ne 0##, which is undefined as ##x\to 0##, but ##f'(0)=0##

f'(x) is defined as ##\lim_{h \rightarrow 0} \frac{f(x+h) - f(x)}{h}##, so ##f'(x)## doesn't exist at a value ##x## where ##f(x)## doesn't exist. So I assume you are defining ##f(0)## to be ##\lim_{x \rightarrow 0}x^2 sin(1/x) = 0##.

I don't understand how this example illustrates the question in your original post.
 
  • #23
mathman said:
However there seems to be a school of thought which asserts that sin(1/0) being undefined, multiplying by 0 results in an undefined product.
Yes, since 1/0 is undefined, then so is sin(1/0), so the product 0 * sin(1/0) is undefined.
mathman said:
Let c=ab. Let b be undefined (but finite). If a=0, is c undefined or does c=0?
You can't even say that b (= sin(1/0) here) is finite.

However, you can work with limits to establish that ##\lim_{x \to 0} x \cdot \sin(\frac 1 x)## exists and is 0, which is easy to show without resorting to the limit definition. I.e., ##\forall x \gt 0, -x \le x \cdot \sin(\frac 1 x) \le x ##. Since both bounds approach 0 as x approaches 0, so must the expression in the middle.
 
  • #24
jedishrfu said:
Computer math follows that trend when some factor isn't computable then a NaN is returned and this taints the rest of the calculation resulting in a NaN as the final answer.
But computer floating point math isn't relevant here because of the inherent limitations of representing very small or very large numbers in a finite number of bits, particularly floating point numbers as described by IEEE-754, which describes different situations in which NANs (both signalling and nonsignalling) are produced. I'm aware that there are libraries that support larger numbers and higher precision than the 2-, 4-, 8, or 10-byte floating point numbers described in IEEE-754, but I'm not familiar with the limitations of those libraries. In any case, if these libraries store numbers have less than infinite precision, and signal events such as underflow and the like, then they too have limitations.
 
  • Like
Likes jedishrfu
  • #25
At the time, I felt the computer math rule of returning a NaN was useful in explaining how an inner expression that’s undefined can taint the final result making it undefined not that computer math was needed to answer the question.

My apologies for sidetracking the thread.
 

FAQ: Product with an undefined term

What is a "Product with an undefined term"?

A "Product with an undefined term" refers to a product or item that contains a term or component that is not clearly defined or specified. This could be a physical product, such as a new technology or device, or it could be a concept or idea that is still in the early stages of development.

Why are products with undefined terms important in scientific research?

Products with undefined terms are important in scientific research because they often represent new or innovative ideas or technologies that have the potential to advance our understanding of the world. By studying and testing these products, scientists can gain new insights and make important discoveries.

How do scientists approach studying products with undefined terms?

Scientists approach studying products with undefined terms by first identifying the specific term or component that is undefined and then conducting thorough research and experimentation to better understand its properties and potential uses. This may involve collaboration with other scientists and experts in the field.

What are the potential benefits of products with undefined terms?

The potential benefits of products with undefined terms are vast and varied. These products have the potential to revolutionize industries, improve quality of life, and advance scientific knowledge. They may also lead to new inventions and discoveries that have a positive impact on society.

What are the challenges associated with studying products with undefined terms?

There are several challenges associated with studying products with undefined terms. These may include limited funding and resources, difficulty in understanding and defining the undefined term, and potential risks or unknown consequences associated with the product. Scientists must carefully consider these challenges and take appropriate precautions in their research.

Similar threads

Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
15
Views
3K
Replies
20
Views
3K
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
17
Views
4K
Replies
45
Views
4K
Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Back
Top