Projectile Motion homework problem

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves projectile motion, specifically analyzing the relationship between the launch angle \( A_o \) and the elevation angle \( B \) of the highest point as seen from the launch point. Participants are tasked with proving the relationship \( \tan B = \frac{1}{2} \tan A_o \) and calculating \( B \) for \( A_o = 45^\circ \).

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the conditions at the highest point of the projectile's trajectory, questioning how to express height \( H \) and range \( R \) in terms of the launch angle \( A_o \). There are attempts to derive relationships between these variables and the angles involved.

Discussion Status

Several participants are exploring different methods to express height and range, with some suggesting the use of kinematic equations. There is a mix of confusion and clarification regarding the steps needed to prove the relationship between \( A_o \) and \( B \). Some participants have provided guidance on using trigonometric identities and kinematic principles, but no consensus has been reached on a clear path forward.

Contextual Notes

Participants are working under the constraints of deriving relationships without using the statement they are trying to prove. There is an emphasis on expressing variables in terms of initial velocity and angles, and some participants express uncertainty about the complexity of the problem.

Destrio
Messages
211
Reaction score
0
A projectile is fired from the surface of level ground at an angle Ao above the horizontal.
A) Show that the elevation angle B of the highest point as seem from the launch point is related to Ao by tanB = (1/2)tanAo
B) Calculate B for Ao = 45 deg

So
I figure at the highest point, Vy must equal 0.
let H be height of launch
let R by range of launch

so tanB = H/(1/2)R
and tanB = (1/2)tanAo

therefore
H/(1/2)R = (1/2)tanAo
tanAo = H/(1/4)R

I'm not sure how to proceed, do I want to derive H or R in terms of velocity/acceleration?

Thanks,
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Destrio said:
A projectile is fired from the surface of level ground at an angle Ao above the horizontal.
A) Show that the elevation angle B of the highest point as seem from the launch point is related to Ao by tanB = (1/2)tanAo
B) Calculate B for Ao = 45 deg

So
I figure at the highest point, Vy must equal 0.
let H be height of launch
let R by range of launch

so tanB = H/(1/2)R
and tanB = (1/2)tanAo

I'm confused... how did you do this last step? This is what you're supposed to prove, but you haven't proven it...

Find H and R in terms of Ao... then you can substitute them into tanB = H/(R/2)
 
I was just stating what it has to equal, I guess I can't do that since that is what I'm trying to prove

Can I use the statement: tanB = (1/2)tanAo to prove it?
for instance
H/(1/2)R = (1/2)tanAo
tanAo = H/(1/4)R

H = (1/4)R*tanAo
R = H/(1/4)tanAo
 
Destrio said:
I was just stating what it has to equal, I guess I can't do that since that is what I'm trying to prove

Can I use the statement: tanB = (1/2)tanAo to prove it?
for instance
H/(1/2)R = (1/2)tanAo
tanAo = H/(1/4)R

H = (1/4)R*tanAo
R = H/(1/4)tanAo

no. you can't use the statement that you're trying to prove...

forget about B for now... try to get H and R in terms of Ao... suppose you have an object with initial velocity v at an angle Ao... now what is the height in terms of v and Ao? What is the range in terms of v and Ao?
 
Alright

When Vy = 0
the height will = H
and the range will = (1/2)R

since the opposite and adjacent side of tanAo won't be in terms of H yet
let J = tanAo(1/2)R
since the adjacent side of both angles will be equal

for initial velocity

Vox = VocosAo
Voy = VosinAo

velocity components:
Vx = Vox
Vy = Voy - gt

for displacement
x = Voxt
y = Voyt - (1/2)gt^2

y = (tanAo)x -[g/(2VocosAo)]x^2

R = (2Vo^2)sinAocosAo / g
R = (Vo^2)(sin2Ao) / g
R = (2Vo^2)(cosAo^2)(tanAo) / g

tanAo = gR / (2Vo^2)(cosAo^2)

I'm getting lost here
 
I think you're making it more complicated than it needs to be...

You know the time taken to get to maximum height is Vosin(theta)/g. So the time to hit the range is 2Vosin(theta)/g

x = Vocos(theta)t

R = Vocos(theta)(2Vosin(theta)/g = 2Vo^2sin(theta)cos(theta)/g (this is what you got, but I'm not sure how you got it... I wasn't able to follow).

What is H?
 
is there a simpler way that you would approach R?

wont H just be tanAo x (1/2) R
except that it is on a curve

or H = Voyt - (1/2)gt^2

but at H Vy = 0
im sortof lost here
 
Try this:

This is somewhat a special case
1 Vyf=Vyi+Ayt
2 0=Visin(yourangle)-gt1
3 t1=((Vi)/g)sin(yourangle)
4 h=[(Visin(yourangle)]∗((Visin(yourangle))/g)-(1/2)g(((Visin(yourangle))/g))²
5 h=((Vi²sin²(yourangle))/(2g))
6 R=Vxit2=(Vicos(yourangle)2t1
7 =(vicos(yourangle))((2Visin(yourangle))/g)=((2Vi²sin(yourangle)cos(yourangle))/g)
8 From trigonometry sin2(yourangle)=2sin(yourangle)cos(yourangle)
9 so R=((Vi²sin2(yourangle))/g)
10 range will max out at 45 degrees
 
"your angle" referring to the angle Ao (angle of the launch) as opposed to B (angle who's hypotenuse will touch the highest point)
 
  • #10
Destrio said:
is there a simpler way that you would approach R?

wont H just be tanAo x (1/2) R

no, H = tanB*(1/2)R

except that it is on a curve

or H = Voyt - (1/2)gt^2

but at H Vy = 0
im sortof lost here

plug in t = Vosin(theta)/g into

H = Vosin(theta)t - (1/2)gt^2

to get H...

or better yet.. using the kinematics equation vf^2 = vi^2 + 2ad. you know a = -g, vf = 0, vi = Vosin(theta)

what is d?
 
  • #11
H = Vosin(theta)Vosin(theta)/g - (1/2)g(Vosin(theta)/g)^2
H = Vosin(theta)^2 / g - (1/2)Vosin(theta)^2 / g
H = Vosin(theta)^2 - (1/2)Vosin(theta)^2 /g
H = (1/2)Vosin(theta)^2 / g

or

vf^2 = vi^2 + 2ad
0 = Vosin(theta)^2 +2gd
d = -(Vosin(theta)^2) / 2(-g)
d = (1/2)Vosin(theta)^2 / g

can I use these to compare the 2 initial equations?
 
  • #12
Destrio said:
H = Vosin(theta)Vosin(theta)/g - (1/2)g(Vosin(theta)/g)^2
H = Vosin(theta)^2 / g - (1/2)Vosin(theta)^2 / g
H = Vosin(theta)^2 - (1/2)Vosin(theta)^2 /g
H = (1/2)Vosin(theta)^2 / g

or

vf^2 = vi^2 + 2ad
0 = Vosin(theta)^2 +2gd
d = -(Vosin(theta)^2) / 2(-g)
d = (1/2)Vosin(theta)^2 / g

can I use these to compare the 2 initial equations?

Now you know H and R...

R = 2Vo^2sin(theta)cos(theta)/g
H = (1/2)Vosin(theta)^2 / g


substitute them into tanB = H/(R/2)

simplify...
 
  • #13
awesome
thanks
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
40
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
27K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
2K