Proving Vector Cross Product Properties in ℝ3?

In summary, the conversation discusses the relationship between vectors in ℝ3 and the cross product. The participants attempt to prove that e1 x e2 = e3, e2 x e3 = e1 and e3 x e1 = e2, but are unable to do so and question if their textbook is incorrect. They realize that the equation is only true for special vectors and it is not true for any three vectors. The concept of the cross product being "bilinear" and anti-commutative is also mentioned.
  • #1
Jow
69
0
If e1 and e2 are vectors in ℝ3 show that e1 x e2 = e3, e2 x e3 = e1 and e3 x e1 = e2. I have tried to prove this but I can't get it.

My attempt:
Step 1: [a1, a2, a3] x [b1, b2, b3] = [a2b3-a3b2, a3b1-a1b3, a1b2-a2b1]
Step 2: [b1, b2, b3] x [a2b3-b2a3, a3b1-a1b3, a1b2-a2b1] = [b2(a1b2-a2b1)-b3(a3b1-a1b3), b3(a2b3-a3b2)-b1(a1b2-a2b1), b1(a3b1-a1b3)-b2(a2b3-b2a3)] ... nothing cancels and I do not end up with [a1, a2, a3], which I should shouldn't I?
I also try this with actual numbers but it still doesn't work. Am I doing something completely wrong? I understand, geometrically, why this should happen because the cross product is orthogonal to the two vectors. Am I doing something wrong or is my textbook wrong? (I am pretty sure the former is the right answer to that question).
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Jow said:
If e1 and e2 are vectors in ℝ3 show that e1 x e2 = e3, e2 x e3 = e1 and e3 x e1 = e2. I have tried to prove this but I can't get it.

My attempt:
Step 1: [a1, a2, a3] x [b1, b2, b3] = [a2b3-a3b2, a3b1-a1b3, a1b2-a2b1]
Step 2: [b1, b2, b3] x [a2b3-b2a3, a3b1-a1b3, a1b2-a2b1] = [b2(a1b2-a2b1)-b3(a3b1-a1b3), b3(a2b3-a3b2)-b1(a1b2-a2b1), b1(a3b1-a1b3)-b2(a2b3-b2a3)] ... nothing cancels and I do not end up with [a1, a2, a3], which I should shouldn't I?
I also try this with actual numbers but it still doesn't work. Am I doing something completely wrong? I understand, geometrically, why this should happen because the cross product is orthogonal to the two vectors. Am I doing something wrong or is my textbook wrong? (I am pretty sure the former is the right answer to that question).

I think they mean e1=[1,0,0], e2=[0,1,0] and e3=[0,0,1]. They are special vectors. It's not true for any three vectors.
 
  • #3
Oh good. I thought I was missing something really important. I must have just misread the question. Thanks.
 
  • #4
In fact, one way of defining the "cross product" is to assert that [itex]e_1\times e_2= e_3[/itex], [itex]e_2\times e_3= e_1[/itex], [itex]e_3\times e_1= e_2[/itex], that the product is "bilinear" and anti-commutative.
 
Back
Top