Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around preparing for a PhD exam in quantum mechanics, specifically seeking resources that provide questions and answers. Participants share recommendations for textbooks and resources, while also expressing concerns about the depth of understanding required for such an exam.
Discussion Character
- Homework-related
- Debate/contested
- Exploratory
Main Points Raised
- One participant requests a book that includes only questions and answers for quantum mechanics exam preparation.
- Another participant suggests that merely memorizing answers without understanding is insufficient for a PhD in physics.
- A participant claims to have a good grasp of general concepts but expresses concern about the difficulty of the upcoming exam.
- Multiple participants recommend Weinberg's "Lectures on Quantum Mechanics," noting its quality despite not being a question-and-answer format.
- One participant finds a book specifically designed in a question-and-answer format and shares links to it, emphasizing its unique approach to exercises.
- Another participant lists several books they have read, which may not strictly fit the request but could still be helpful.
- Participants mention "Problems and Solutions on Quantum Mechanics" and a specific series by Y K Lim as useful resources for exam preparation.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
There is no consensus on the best resource for exam preparation, as participants express differing views on the importance of understanding versus memorization and suggest various types of materials.
Contextual Notes
Some participants emphasize the need for a deep understanding of quantum mechanics, while others focus on the practicality of finding specific question-and-answer resources. The discussion reflects a range of expectations and standards within the physics community regarding PhD preparation.