Quaternions in Clifford algebras

  • Level: Graduate 
  • Thread starter mnb96
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Quaternions
11 replies · 4K views · last reply
mnb96
Messages
711
Reaction score
5
Hello,
it is known quaternions are isomorphic to [tex]\mathcal{C}\ell^{+}_{3,0}[/tex], which is the even subalgebra of [tex]\mathcal{C}\ell_{3,0}[/tex]

Is it possible to find an isomorphism between [tex]\mathcal{C}\ell_{2,0}[/tex] and [tex]\mathbb{H} \cong \mathcal{C}\ell^{+}_{3,0}[/tex] ?

*** my attempt was: ***

Let's consider [tex]\{1,e_1, e_2, e_{12}\}[/tex] and the morphism f defined as follows:

[tex]f(1)=1[/tex]

[tex]f(e_{32})=e_1[/tex]

[tex]f(e_{13})=e_2[/tex]

[tex]f(e_{21})=e_{21}[/tex]

This almost works, in fact:
[itex]f(xy)=f(x)f(y)[/itex] always holds with one exception:

[tex]f(e_1 e_2) = -e_{21} = f(e_2)f(e_1)[/tex]
So, in this case, the morphism f does not preserve well the geometric product.
Is it possible to make the whole thing work?
 
What you have written doesn't quite make sense. Since you have not defined [tex]f(e_i)[/tex] for [tex]i=1,2[/tex].

I think what you wanted was
[tex] f(e_{12}) = -f(e_{21}) = -e_{21} = -e_2 e_1 = -f(e_{13})f(e_{32})<br /> =-f(e_{13}e_{32})=f(e_{12})[/tex]
which is all as it should be.
 
You got all right squares and all right anticommutators. So it works.
And indeed , there is something wrong with your last formula. It is not clear what you were trying to do.
 
thanks for both your replies.
Maybe I now understood the mistake.

Now, please tell me if this is the correct way to proceed:
I want to find an isomorphism between the subalgebra of quaternions [tex]\mathcal{C}\ell^{+}_{3,0}[/tex] and the algebra [tex]\mathcal{C}\ell_{2,0}[/tex]

I define [tex]f:\mathcal{C}\ell^{1}_{3,0} \rightarrow \mathcal{C}\ell^{1}_{2,0}[/tex] as:

[tex]f(1)=1[/tex]
[tex]f(e_1)=e_1[/tex]
[tex]f(e_2)=e_2[/tex]
[tex]f(e_3)=e_{12}[/tex]

Now, I simply verify that the quaternion rules [tex]i^2 = j^2 = k^2 = ijk = -1[/tex], where [itex]i=e_{32}[/itex] [itex]j=e_{13}[/itex] [itex]k=e_{21}[/itex] correctly hold as follows [tex]f(i^2) = f(j^2) = f(k^2) = f(ijk) = f(-1)[/tex]

Does this make more sense?
 
Well, you need to show that [tex]f(e_i e_j)=f(e_i)f(e_j)[/tex].
If you have that [tex]f(e_1 e_2 e_3)=f(e_1)f(e_2)f(e_3)[/tex] then [tex]f(e_1e_2)=f(e_3)[/tex]
[tex]f(e_1)f(e_2)f(e_3)=-1,[/tex] therefore (multiply on the right by [tex]f(e_3)[/tex])
[tex]f(e_1)f(e_2)=f(e_3)=f(e_1 e_2),[/tex]
and you are home.
If this is what you mean, then you are alright.
 
Last edited:
What you did is a particular case of a general theorem:

If the quadratic form [tex]q[/tex] on [tex]E[/tex] is non-zero, the even subalgebra [tex]C_+[/tex] of [tex]C(E;q)[/tex] can be, in a natural way, considered as the Clifford algebra [tex]C(E_1;q_1)[/tex] of the subspace [tex]E_1=e_1^{\perp}[/tex]
of [tex]E[/tex], orthogonal to a regular vector [tex]e_1[/tex], where [tex]q_1=-q(e_1)q[/tex].

For this you define [tex]f(y)=e_1 y,[/tex] [tex]y\in e_1^{\perp}[/tex].

Then [tex]f(y)^2 = e_1 y e_1 y = -e_1^2 y^2 = -q(e_1)q(y).[/tex]

P.S. I am using the convention [tex]C(E;q)= \mathcal{C} l (E,-q)[/tex]
 
Last edited:
Sorry,
I am a bit confused again now.
After sleeping over it, What I wrote in my previous post doesn't sound correct anymore, because the quaternion units do not square to -1 in [tex]\mathcal{C}\ell_{2,0}[/tex].

For example, let's take one quaternion unit in [tex]\mathcal{C}\ell_{3,0}[/tex]:

[tex]i = e_{32}[/tex]

We have that:

[tex]f(e_{32}e_{32}) = f(-1) = -1 \neq f(e_{32})f(e_{32})[/tex]

so f is not a morphism because it does not preserve the geometric-product.PS: @arkajad: could you please give me a reference for that general theorem (if possible)?
 
Last edited:
Rene Deheuvels, "Tenseurs et Spineurs", Presses Universitaires de France, (1993), pp. 247-248 (Very good book. Good to have in the library.)

I have scanned for you the Theorem, its proof, and and example
 
Attachments
  • Page of French text from a mathematics book: Théorème VI.2.B on Clifford algebras with its proof, including formulas for the quadratic form q1 = -q(e1)q and the map φ1(y) = e1y.
    d1.jpg
    48.2 KB · Views: 489
  • Page of printed French text on Clifford algebras, with a worked example about the even subalgebra C+(E3) being isomorphic to the quaternions H and C(2) = H ⊕ iH.
    d2.jpg
    59.7 KB · Views: 580
Last edited:
... it seems to me that it is not possible to create an isomorphism between [tex]\mathcal{C}\ell_{2,0}[/tex] and the quaternion subalgebra [tex]\mathcal{C}\ell^{+}_{3,0}[/tex], unless one reverses the metric signature into:

[tex]\mathcal{C}\ell_{0,2}[/tex]

This is probably the only way to obtain [tex]e_i e_i = -1[/tex].
 
Which convention are you using for Cl(q)?

xy+yx = 2(x,y) or xy+yx = - 2(x,y)

I should have asked this question first.
 
I was assuming the first one: xy+yx = 2(x,y).
Sorry for having skipped that.
 
Then indeed you have an isomorphism of [tex]Cl^+(3,0)[/tex] with [tex]Cl(0,2)[/tex]

P.S. I was too quick in my first replies!
 
Last edited: