Question about movement in isolated system

  • Thread starter Kenan
  • Start date
  • #1
31
0
I'm new to the forums and unfortunately I have a pretty dumb question...

So in isolated system internal forces cancel each other out every single time,like pushing on a door of your car does not create any motion of your car at all.

You basically can't pull yourself up by the bootstraps.

I also know that momentum which is mass*velocity is conserves in an isolated system so if there is no velocity,there is no momentum,there is no conservation.

But here is the question:

Why does the rocket move,gun recoils if forces in such systems (as you know they are isolated,at least it says so) cancel each other out,are not they isolated JUST like the car-door system,hair-human system?

I know that there is conservation of momentum,but are not forces supposed to make the body stay still,be in equilibrium?

Or maybe forces do not prevent the momentum from appearing because of 1 Newton's law where it clearly states that the body can move without acceleration even though forces on it cancel each other out?

It's just this is the main explanation for such problems such as Münchausen,pushing boat while being inside of it,pushing door of your car while being inside of it - forces cancel each other out but forces cancel each other out in rocket/gun system but they DO move!

So basically there is no other way to explain the reason of body's movement in an isolated system but saying that in this example there is no momentum and in that example there is momentum?

I'm really puzzled...
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
Doc Al
Mentor
44,987
1,259
Why does the rocket move,gun recoils if forces in such systems (as you know they are isolated,at least it says so) cancel each other out,are not they isolated JUST like the car-door system,hair-human system?
Realize that the rocket ejects fuel and the gun ejects a bullet. If you look at the complete system of "rocket + ejected fuel" or "gun + bullet" there will be no change in the momentum of the center of mass. But if you just take the rocket or gun by itself, then the ejected material exerts forces and that subsystem is not isolated.
 
  • #3
Drakkith
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
20,991
4,809
I also know that momentum which is mass*velocity is conserves in an isolated system so if there is no velocity,there is no momentum,there is no conservation.
Not true. Conservation laws always apply. For a system with zero momentum, this means that the momentum must remain zero unless an external force acts on the system.

Why does the rocket move,gun recoils if forces in such systems (as you know they are isolated,at least it says so) cancel each other out,are not they isolated JUST like the car-door system,hair-human system?
Conservation of momentum says that the center of mass of the system cannot change if only internal forces act on the system. As a rocket or gun expels mass, the center of mass of the system (CoM of the rocket/gun + expelled mass) does not move.
 
  • #4
HallsofIvy
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
41,833
956
Why does th be rocket move,gun recoils if forces in such systems (as you know they are isolated,at least it says so) cancel each other out,are not they isolated JUST like the car-door system,hair-human system
I can't speak for what "it says" but those are NOT isolated systems because in the case of the rocket movement you are not including the rocket exhaust and in the case of the gun recoil you are not including the bullet or other projectile.

If you did include the rocket exhaust you would find that the center of mass of the entire system, rocket and rocket exhaust, would not move. And in the case of the gun, the center of mass of gun and bullet would not move.
 
  • #5
31
0
Realize that the rocket ejects fuel and the gun ejects a bullet. If you look at the complete system of "rocket + ejected fuel" or "gun + bullet" there will be no change in the momentum of the center of mass. But if you just take the rocket or gun by itself, then the ejected material exerts forces and that subsystem is not isolated.
Yes,my bad,I meant rocket+fuel and gun+bullet and I do understand that momentum conserves but I don't understand how does the velocity appears if forces are balanced,why does it move if forces are equal to zero?There is no explanation to that?

They clearly state that car does not move when you push it's door because forces are equal and opposite,equal to zero in an isolated system but in the rocket/gun example there is movement,there is velocity.
 
  • #6
Drakkith
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
20,991
4,809
I don't understand how does the velocity appears if forces are balanced,why does it move if forces are equal to zero?There is no explanation to that?
The forces aren't balanced. The force acting on the rocket from the exhaust is not balanced by anything, so the rocket accelerates. Similarly, the force acting on the exhaust from the rocket is also no balanced by anything.

Pay careful attention to which force is acting on which object. If two forces are equal and opposite, but acting on different objects, then they DON'T cancel out.
 
  • #7
Doc Al
Mentor
44,987
1,259
Yes,my bad,I meant rocket+fuel and gun+bullet and I do understand that momentum conserves but I don't understand how does the velocity appears if forces are balanced,why does it move if forces are equal to zero?There is no explanation to that?
Just because two things (bullet and gun, say) exert equal and opposite forces on each other (per Newton's 3rd law) does not mean that they cannot accelerate. That depends on the situation.

They clearly state that car does not move when you push it's door because forces are equal and opposite,equal to zero in an isolated system but in the rocket/gun example there is movement,there is velocity.
What is required for the "car + person" to start moving if you push on the door is an external force acting on it. In the gun case, the bullet is not attached to the gun so it exerts an external force on the gun. Not so in the car case, where multiple forces are involved that prevent you or the car from moving. You push on the door and on the seat (for example) and the door and the seat push on you.
 
  • #8
31
0
The forces aren't balanced. The force acting on the rocket from the exhaust is not balanced by anything, so the rocket accelerates. Similarly, the force acting on the exhaust from the rocket is also no balanced by anything.

Pay careful attention to which force is acting on which object. If two forces are equal and opposite, but acting on different objects, then they DON'T cancel out.
Are not forces in system "car" acting on different objects too?Hands act on the door and the door acts on hands yet there is no movement because how they say the system is isolated,so the forces altogether are equal to zero.
So they consider rocket+fuel/gun+bullet systems isolated,so forces altogether are equal to zero,yet rocket moves and gun recoils.

Here's what I've read:

"You Can't Bully Yourself...
Have you ever noticed that you can't push yourself? You can push a book and it accelerates, and you can push another person and they accelerate, but you can't accelerate yourself by pushing yourself.

You can lift a book off the table, and you can lift another person off the ground, but you can't lift yourself off the ground. (A person can't literally "pull themselves up by the bootstraps" as the old saying says...)

Because:
Suppose that one part of an object is pushing on another part - your right hand is pushing on your left hand. Newton's Third Law tells you that both hands exert forces, and that the force on your right hand is equal and opposite to the force on your left. Previously,[/PLAIN] [Broken] you saw that the force that your right hand exerts on your left hand accelerates your left hand, and that the force your left hand exerts on your right hand accelerates your right hand - and you can see and feel that happening.

Notice, though, that no matter how hard you push, the forces your hands exert on one another will not accelerate your body as a whole.

Forces exerted by one part of an object on another part of the same object are called internal forces - and

internal forces never influence the motion of an object.
Newton's Third Law action/reaction forces between objects do not cancel - but internal forces (Newton's Third Law action/reaction forces withinan object) do cancel.

Forces between distinct, separate objects are called external forces, and external forces DO influence the motion of objects"
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #9
Drakkith
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
20,991
4,809
Are not forces in system "car" acting on different objects too?Hands act on the door and the door acts on hands yet there is no movement because how they say the system is isolated,so the forces altogether are equal to zero.
You're missing another pair of forces though. The car acts on the door and the door acts on the car at the hinge point. These forces keep the car and door together even though you've pushed on the door. If the door wasn't connected to the car, there would indeed be motion when you pushed on the door (though the center of mass wouldn't change).
 
  • #10
Doc Al
Mentor
44,987
1,259
Suppose that one part of an object is pushing on another part - your right hand is pushing on your left hand. Newton's Third Law tells you that both hands exert forces, and that the force on your right hand is equal and opposite to the force on your left.
Don't mix up Newton's 2nd and 3rd laws. If you want to know if something accelerates, you must use Newton's 2nd law, which involves summing all forces acting on the object/system.
Previously,[/PLAIN] [Broken] you saw that the force that your right hand exerts on your left hand accelerates your left hand, and that the force your left hand exerts on your right hand accelerates your right hand - and you can see and feel that happening.
Are you sure about that?

Do this: Put your palms together and push them against each other. They exert equal and opposite forces on each other, yet your hands don't move. Why is that?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #11
31
0
Don't mix up Newton's 2nd and 3rd laws. If you want to know if something accelerates, you must use Newton's 2nd law, which involves summing all forces acting on the object/system.

Are you sure about that?

Do this: Put your palms together and push them against each other. They exert equal and opposite forces on each other, yet your hands don't move. Why is that?
I've read that from some site and oh,what they meant in palm example is that forces acting ON both of the hands are not equal and opposite.

I still don't understand though...I thought that forces in gun+bullet system are external just like in rocket+fuel system.They say that THESE systems are isolated so forces in such systems always cancel each other out just like in example where Münghausen pulls his hair to raise himself from the swamp or whatever.
 
  • #12
Doc Al
Mentor
44,987
1,259
I still don't understand though...I thought that forces in gun+bullet system are external just like in rocket+fuel system.
If you define your system as "gun" or "bullet" (keep them as separate systems) then they exert external forces on each other. If you define your system as "gun + bullet", then there are no external forces and the center of mass of the composite system will remain at rest (if it was at rest). That doesn't mean that the separate pieces (the gun and the bullet) cannot move away from each other.
 
  • #13
Drakkith
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
20,991
4,809
To bounce off of what Doc Al said, if you consider the bullet and the gun as separate systems, then the forces acting on each system are external forces and the center of mass of each system DOES move.
 
  • #14
Nugatory
Mentor
12,988
5,699
Are not forces in system "car" acting on different objects too?Hands act on the door and the door acts on hands yet there is no movement because how they say the system is isolated,so the forces altogether are equal to zero.
You have to include all the forces. Hands push on door, door pushes on hands; because the door is pushing on the hands and the hands are attached to you... what's stopping you from moving? You're pushing against the seat and the seat is pushing back on you. And the seat is attached to the car, which is attached to the door... so the car is pushing the door one direction and you're pushing the door the other direction, and the door doesn't move. Likewise, the door is pushing on you, but the seat is pushing on you in the opposite direction, so you don't move.... And it's that way for every piece of the chain.
 
  • #15
31
0
If you define your system as "gun" or "bullet" (keep them as separate systems) then they exert external forces on each other. If you define your system as "gun + bullet", then there are no external forces and the center of mass of the composite system will remain at rest (if it was at rest). That doesn't mean that the separate pieces (the gun and the bullet) cannot move away from each other.
I think I understand what you mean,like i have 2 balls in the space and one pushes another,I can make 2 separate systems or a single [ball+ball] system and it won't stop their movement.

Ok so if there is no way for me to keep 2 objects as separate systems like the example with baron Münhausen's hands and his hair - the system is his entire body (I cannot separate these systems,it just won't work) , then there is no movement,right?

I just don't understand how is it possible to keep rocket and fuel as separate systems since it is inside of the rocket...
 
  • #16
A.T.
Science Advisor
10,641
2,231
I just don't understand how is it possible to keep rocket and fuel as separate systems since it is inside of the rocket...
How you choose to define your system is independent of that.
 
  • #17
31
0
How you choose to define your system is independent of that.
I know,I know but on one site there were 3 problems and in each problem we had to determine the isolation of the system,if it was not possible then the body could move,if it was then the body could not move.

Like in the example with 2 balls the system is not isolated so there IS motion but in the example with Münhausen the system IS isolated so there is no motion.
 
  • #18
A.T.
Science Advisor
10,641
2,231
we had to determine the isolation of the system
Just check if there are forces on parts of the system by something that is not part of the system.
 
  • #19
31
0
Yes but I think what they mean is that if in isolated system there is no movement then there is a certain system that basically satisfies the reason body moves or not,like with Münhausen - the isolated system in this case is the body because body does not move at all when he pulls himself by his hair.
 
  • #20
31
0
Yes but I think what they mean is that if in isolated system there is no movement then there is a certain system that basically satisfies the reason body moves or not,like with Münhausen - the isolated system in this case is the body because body does not move at all when he pulls himself by his hair.
Am I right,guys?
 
  • #21
HallsofIvy
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
41,833
956
Am I right,guys?
It is impossible to say whether you are right or wrong because you haven't told us what you mean by "movement". You have been told repeatedly that the center of mass of such a system will not move but that parts of it will move relative to each other, In particular, the body of the rocket will move in one direction, the exhaust in the opposite direction. Most people would say that the rocket has moved. Do you disagree?
 
  • #22
31
0
It is impossible to say whether you are right or wrong because you haven't told us what you mean by "movement". You have been told repeatedly that the center of mass of such a system will not move but that parts of it will move relative to each other, In particular, the body of the rocket will move in one direction, the exhaust in the opposite direction. Most people would say that the rocket has moved. Do you disagree?
Let me get this straight:

In isolated system the total momentum and total energy conserves no matter what,right?Right.
In isolated system any internal force cancels out other internal forces,so only external forces can make the body move,no?

So if I have an isolated system i must have some external force to bring it to the motion,no?!

Like we have 2 bodies,body A and body B.Body A pushes body B and body B moves,if I create a system [body A+body B] then the system becomes isolated because no external forces are acting on it,does it mean that both bodies will NOT move or it does not matter?

I'm just trying to understand why objects move in certain isolated systems and don't move in other isolated systems like gun+bullet system - even though it's isolated both bodies move.

If I create a system man inside of a boat+boat the boat will not move(like if i push the boat while being inside of it,everybody knows that it won't move).

Are not in both of the examples parts of the same object are acting on each other?That's why I thought there should be no movement.

I've read the info about external and internal forces here:
http://www.batesville.k12.in.us/physics/phynet/mechanics/newton3/Internal_Forces.html

It seems like a good site.
 
  • #23
Doc Al
Mentor
44,987
1,259
I just don't understand how is it possible to keep rocket and fuel as separate systems since it is inside of the rocket...
You do realize that for the rocket to create thrust it must eject the burnt fuel. That's what pushes it forward.
 
  • #24
31
0
You do realize that for the rocket to create thrust it must eject the burnt fuel. That's what pushes it forward.
I know,I know that it happens because of the conservation of momentum but I cannot understand why does it happen if it clearly says that the forces inside of a rocket are acting on parts of the same object,of the rocket and if forces are acting on the parts of the same object then the body does not move at all.

http://www.batesville.k12.in.us/physics/phynet/mechanics/newton3/Internal_Forces.html
 
  • #25
Doc Al
Mentor
44,987
1,259
if forces are acting on the parts of the same object then the body does not move at all.
That depends on whether the "object" is made of pieces that can be separated. That's why it's best to speak of a system.

Imagine you and your twin brother are standing next to each other on frictionless ice. You give him a shove. You both go flying backward along the ice. Considering the two of you as one system, there were no external forces so there can be no motion of your center of mass. But obviously you can each move.
 

Related Threads on Question about movement in isolated system

  • Last Post
2
Replies
32
Views
4K
Replies
2
Views
535
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
5K
  • Last Post
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
798
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
660
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
5
Views
5K
Top