spacelike
- 35
- 0
So there's something that has bothered me for quite some time.
I know the normal equations of time dilation and length contraction are the following:
[tex]\Delta t'=\gamma \Delta t[/tex] and [tex]L'=\frac{L}{\gamma}[/tex]
where the primed variables are in reference frame S' and the unprimed variables are in reference frame S. With frame S' moving with velocity v relative to frame S.
Ok, so far so good. Now when we try to look at the same thing with Lorentz transformations (in other words: derive the above from Lorentz transformations)
we have:
[tex]t'=\gamma(t-\frac{v}{c^{2}}x)[/tex]
[tex]x'=\gamma(x-vt)[/tex]
When deriving time dilation we simply take it that the event which lasts duration t in reference frame S, is at x=0. Therefore we immediately get:
[tex]t'=\gamma t[/tex]
[tex]\Delta t'=t'_{2}-t'_{1}=\gamma t_{2}-\gamma t_{1}[/tex]
[tex]\Delta t'=\gamma \Delta t[/tex]
Great, that gives us time dilation as expected.. Now the problem I'm having is with length contraction. So starting again from the lorentz equation:
[tex]x'=\gamma(x-vt)[/tex]
This time we consider that we measure the length at t=0, leaving us with:
[tex]x'=\gamma x[/tex]
Now to get length:
[tex]L'=x'_{2}-x'_{1}=\gamma x_{2}-\gamma x_{1}=\gamma L[/tex]
That means that according to Lorentz transformations:
[tex]L'=\gamma L[/tex]
However, according to the formula for length contraction which I wrote at the top:
[tex]L'=\frac{L}{\gamma}[/tex]
These are totally opposite!
what am I doing wrong?
Thanks
I know the normal equations of time dilation and length contraction are the following:
[tex]\Delta t'=\gamma \Delta t[/tex] and [tex]L'=\frac{L}{\gamma}[/tex]
where the primed variables are in reference frame S' and the unprimed variables are in reference frame S. With frame S' moving with velocity v relative to frame S.
Ok, so far so good. Now when we try to look at the same thing with Lorentz transformations (in other words: derive the above from Lorentz transformations)
we have:
[tex]t'=\gamma(t-\frac{v}{c^{2}}x)[/tex]
[tex]x'=\gamma(x-vt)[/tex]
When deriving time dilation we simply take it that the event which lasts duration t in reference frame S, is at x=0. Therefore we immediately get:
[tex]t'=\gamma t[/tex]
[tex]\Delta t'=t'_{2}-t'_{1}=\gamma t_{2}-\gamma t_{1}[/tex]
[tex]\Delta t'=\gamma \Delta t[/tex]
Great, that gives us time dilation as expected.. Now the problem I'm having is with length contraction. So starting again from the lorentz equation:
[tex]x'=\gamma(x-vt)[/tex]
This time we consider that we measure the length at t=0, leaving us with:
[tex]x'=\gamma x[/tex]
Now to get length:
[tex]L'=x'_{2}-x'_{1}=\gamma x_{2}-\gamma x_{1}=\gamma L[/tex]
That means that according to Lorentz transformations:
[tex]L'=\gamma L[/tex]
However, according to the formula for length contraction which I wrote at the top:
[tex]L'=\frac{L}{\gamma}[/tex]
These are totally opposite!
what am I doing wrong?
Thanks