Calculus Really need to read the textbook?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around the necessity of reading the textbook in a calculus course, with varying opinions on its importance. Some participants argue that reading the textbook is essential for a deeper understanding of calculus, as it may contain additional concepts and problems not covered in lectures. They emphasize that relying solely on lectures could lead to gaps in knowledge, especially when professors might test on material from the textbook. Others express a more dismissive attitude, suggesting that if the goal is merely to pass the course, reading the textbook may not be necessary. However, they are cautioned that this approach could hinder long-term comprehension and success in future courses. The conversation highlights a tension between immediate academic goals and the value of thorough understanding in mathematics.
Ethan Hummel
Messages
28
Reaction score
2
Hello everybody, I am taking a calculus 1 course at my local community college this summer. I was wondering if it is absolutely necessary to read the textbook in math because I see it that the professor teaches the theory and techniques in lecture, and covers the same exact material. Right? What was it like when you went to college? Thank you for any feedback.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Yes, you absolutely need to read the textbook.
 
  • Like
Likes theBin
Why not read it? There may be more ideas than you think and you may see something that will prompt a question to the prof.

Also some profs, teach one thing in class and then test on stuff from the book + the lecture notes.
 
jedishrfu said:
Why not read it? There may be more than you think and you may see something that will prompt a question to the prof.

Also some profs, teach one thin in class and then test on stuff from the book + the lecture notes.
It takes a lot of time
 
  • Like
Likes theBin
Ethan Hummel said:
It takes a lot of time

says the lazy student.
 
  • Like
Likes theBin
Ethan Hummel said:
It takes a lot of time

Yes, studying calculus should take a lot of time.
 
  • Like
Likes theBin
jedishrfu said:
says the lazy student.
Yeah not going to lie. I don't find it necessary to waste my time though when the professor would cover it in lecture
 
micromass said:
Yes, studying calculus should take a lot of time.
I don't get why i would waste my time though when the professor is going to cover the same material in lecture.
 
Ethan Hummel said:
Yeah not going to lie. I don't find it necessary to waste my time though when the professor would cover it in lecture

1. You won't make it very far in science
2. You won't properly understand calculus
3. It's not a waste of time

But sure, you might pass the course this way.
 
  • Like
Likes theBin
  • #10
micromass said:
1. You won't make it very far in science
2. You won't properly understand calculus
3. It's not a waste of time

But sure, you might pass the course this way.
As long as I pass and get that A
 
  • #11
Ethan Hummel said:
As long as I pass and get that A

Yep sure. If that's your goal, then you don't need to read the textbook at all.
 
  • #12
micromass said:
Yep sure. If that's your goal, then you don't need to read the textbook at all.
Is that sarcasm
 
  • #13
Ethan Hummel said:
As long as I pass and get that A

What did you expect us to say? Why did you even bother to ask this knowing what we would say?

I really hope the prof gives you a problem found only in the book and that its one of the tricky ones. Only then will you understand that there's more to getting an A than getting an A. Why not try for a perfect grade of no mistakes now?

Eventually you'll discover that Calculus is child's play compared to the more advanced courses you'll be taking in the future.
 
  • #14
jedishrfu said:
What did you expect us to say? Why did you even bother to ask this knowing what we would say?

I really hope the prof gives you a problem found only in the book and that its one of the tricky ones only then will you understand that there's more to getting an A than getting an A.
Well he wouldn't because that's not fair
 
  • Like
Likes theBin
  • #15
Ethan Hummel said:
Is that sarcasm

Not at all. If your only goal is to pass the course, then you don't need to read the textbook at all. No sarcasm.

I just find it incredibly stupid to take a course without trying to properly understand the subject completely.
 
  • Like
Likes theBin
  • #16
Ethan Hummel said:
Well he wouldn't because that's not fair

It is fair.
 
  • #17
micromass said:
Not at all. If your only goal is to pass the course, then you don't need to read the textbook at all. No sarcasm.

I just find it incredibly stupid to take a course without trying to properly understand the subject completely.
Well if I get an A doesn't that mean I do understand the material comprehensively?
 
  • #18
Ethan Hummel said:
Well if I get an A doesn't that mean I do understand the material comprehensively?

Not at all.
 
  • Like
Likes Amrator
  • #19
Ethan Hummel said:
Well he wouldn't because that's not fair

You have so many misconceptions about college. It might not be fair in high school but in college anything is fair even if he mentions some obscure book that pertains to his or her lecture. I've had profs like these and its darn hard to get even a B in the class.

I think its time to close this thread.
 
  • Like
Likes smodak and Amrator

Similar threads

Replies
17
Views
7K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
47
Views
5K
Replies
4
Views
4K
Replies
12
Views
4K
Replies
27
Views
19K
Replies
20
Views
8K
Back
Top