Recommendations for 1st year E&M practice/exercises

  • Classical
  • Thread starter notgoodatphysics
  • Start date
  • Tags
    E&m Year
In summary: It wouldn't hurt to let the lecturer know what you said here—that you feel the homework isn't preparing you adequately for the exams.
  • #1
notgoodatphysics
8
0
Currently in 1st year (UK) going through E&M right now, the recommended textbook is University Physics by S&Z. Recently had my-mid term test and got 40%.

The problem is I’m overestimating my ability as the exercises in UP are not challenging at all, the majority of them are just plugging in numbers. Whereas our lecturers problems are much more difficult, they focus more on relationships, derivations and mathematical ability. We don’t need a calculator for any of these whereas almost all of UP exercises do. So they are completely different. The limited practice questions in tutorials aren’t hacking it, and there also are only a couple of past papers - I assume due to the lecturer being fairly new and having only uploaded past papers written by herself.

Does anyone have any suggestions? I was thinking of doing the problems in Griffiths as its highly recommended, but its not for first year E&M..

Cheers
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
If you struggle with UP, then going onto electrodynamics isn't going to help at all.

Many of the exercises in UP are pretty computational, but there are more challenging ones amongst them. They are labelled with stars I believe. If you can solve all the three star problems and the challenge problems correctly, you should be in good shape.

You could try Physics for Scientists and Engineers by Serway. I have both because I like having an abundance of practice problems. Alternatively, Matter and Interactions looks interesting, but I have not used it myself.
 
  • Like
Likes notgoodatphysics and scottdave
  • #3
Another thing you could do is ask the instructor what you can work on to be better prepared. There may be some exceptions, but I think most profs will appreciate that you show an interest to improve.
 
  • Like
Likes notgoodatphysics
  • #4
Mondayman said:
If you struggle with UP, then going onto electrodynamics isn't going to help at all.

Many of the exercises in UP are pretty computational, but there are more challenging ones amongst them. They are labelled with stars I believe. If you can solve all the three star problems and the challenge problems correctly, you should be in good shape.

You could try Physics for Scientists and Engineers by Serway. I have both because I like having an abundance of practice problems. Alternatively, Matter and Interactions looks interesting, but I have not used it myself.
No that’s the issue, UP are far too easy in comparison to the questions we are given by our professor. I‘ll have a look at both of them, cheers.
 
  • #5
I looked at my bookshelf and forgot to mention one more. Early editions of Physics by Halliday-Resnick-Krane (not Fundamentals of Physics by Halliday-Resnick-Walker). I have the 4th edition. The problems are much better than the later, watered down editions.

Also, MIT has free online courses for E&M. This one has an online textbook that is pretty good.

https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/8-02-physics-ii-electricity-and-magnetism-spring-2007/pages/syllabus/

Two more:

https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/8-02t-electricity-and-magnetism-spring-2005/pages/syllabus/

https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/8-02x-p...xperimental-focus-spring-2005/pages/syllabus/

You can use their problem sets to supplement UP.
 
  • Like
Likes Falgun and scottdave
  • #6
It might also help to derive (on your own) all the results that are derived in the text. Hopefully, you'll see how it's the same principles being applied over and over and perhaps learn a little math along the way. It'll definitely get you away from the "find the right formula" mindset that students often get from doing homework problems.

It wouldn't hurt to let the lecturer know what you said here—that you feel the homework isn't preparing you adequately for the exams. If the entire class didn't do well, she may have an idea that there's a problem, but your specific observation may help her better prepare the class for future exams.
 
  • Like
Likes Falgun, scottdave and notgoodatphysics
  • #7
Mondayman said:
I have the 4th edition. The problems are much better than the later, watered down editions.
Do you mean that the 4th edition of HRK has better problems than the 5th (current) edition of HRK? Or do you mean that the 4th edition of HRK has better problems than the 12th (current) edition of HRW?
 
  • #8
Muu9 said:
Do you mean that the 4th edition of HRK has better problems than the 5th (current) edition of HRK? Or do you mean that the 4th edition of HRK has better problems than the 12th (current) edition of HRW?
I haven't seen every edition of "Physics" by HRK, only the 3rd and 4th. I find them both to be superior to "Fundamentals of Phyics" by HRW. I'm sure the 5th is as well.
 
  • #9
scottdave said:
Another thing you could do is ask the instructor what you can work on to be better prepared. There may be some exceptions, but I think most profs will appreciate that you show an interest to improve.
vela said:
It might also help to derive (on your own) all the results that are derived in the text. Hopefully, you'll see how it's the same principles being applied over and over and perhaps learn a little math along the way. It'll definitely get you away from the "find the right formula" mindset that students often get from doing homework problems.

It wouldn't hurt to let the lecturer know what you said here—that you feel the homework isn't preparing you adequately for the exams. If the entire class didn't do well, she may have an idea that there's a problem, but your specific observation may help her better prepare the class for future exams.
Great, appreciate the advice, thanks! I’ll arrange a time with her and see what she says.
Mondayman said:
I looked at my bookshelf and forgot to mention one more. Early editions of Physics by Halliday-Resnick-Krane (not Fundamentals of Physics by Halliday-Resnick-Walker). I have the 4th edition. The problems are much better than the later, watered down editions.

Also, MIT has free online courses for E&M. This one has an online textbook that is pretty good.

https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/8-02-physics-ii-electricity-and-magnetism-spring-2007/pages/syllabus/

Two more:

https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/8-02t-electricity-and-magnetism-spring-2005/pages/syllabus/

https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/8-02x-p...xperimental-focus-spring-2005/pages/syllabus/

You can use their problem sets to supplement UP.
Perfect, cheers!
 
  • #10
notgoodatphysics said:
No that’s the issue, UP are far too easy in comparison to the questions we are given by our professor. I‘ll have a look at both of them, cheers.

Could you give some specific examples of these [exam?] questions,
as well as the practice problems?
 
  • #11
notgoodatphysics said:
Currently in 1st year (UK) going through E&M right now, the recommended textbook is University Physics by S&Z. Recently had my-mid term test and got 40%.

The problem is I’m overestimating my ability as the exercises in UP are not challenging at all, the majority of them are just plugging in numbers. Whereas our lecturers problems are much more difficult, they focus more on relationships, derivations and mathematical ability. We don’t need a calculator for any of these whereas almost all of UP exercises do. So they are completely different. The limited practice questions in tutorials aren’t hacking it, and there also are only a couple of past papers - I assume due to the lecturer being fairly new and having only uploaded past papers written by herself.

Does anyone have any suggestions? I was thinking of doing the problems in Griffiths as its highly recommended, but its not for first year E&M..

Cheers
In general, the problems from run of mill intro physics books are very similar. There are exceptions such as Alonso and Finn, Shankar's intro books, and Purcell to name a few.

Are you doing as many physics problems without looking at solutions? Are you able to derive the formulas used? Are you understanding the actual physics and not just symbol pushing? Are you trying to rote memorize, instead of conceptual understanding?

Many students fall into the trap believing exams should be exactly like hw problems, so maybe your instructor exam depends on mastering the hw problems, and using that understanding to learn something new. Have you gone to office hours?

That S&Z book is decent. Post the exam, so we are able to better advice you.
 

1. What are the key concepts to focus on in first year E&M practice and exercises?

The key concepts to focus on in first year E&M practice and exercises include understanding electric and magnetic fields, electric potential and potential difference, capacitance and inductance, and the behavior of charged particles in electric and magnetic fields.

2. How can I improve my problem-solving skills in E&M?

To improve your problem-solving skills in E&M, it is important to practice regularly and seek help from your instructor or peers when needed. It is also helpful to break down problems into smaller steps and use diagrams and equations to visualize and understand the concepts.

3. Are there any recommended resources for additional E&M practice and exercises?

Yes, there are many resources available for additional E&M practice and exercises, such as textbooks, online tutorials, and practice problems from other universities. Your instructor may also have recommended resources or materials for you to use.

4. How can I prepare for exams in first year E&M?

To prepare for exams in first year E&M, it is important to review your notes and practice problems regularly. Make sure you understand the key concepts and can apply them to different types of problems. It is also helpful to work on past exams or practice exams to get a sense of the types of questions that may be asked.

5. What strategies can I use to approach difficult E&M problems?

Some strategies to approach difficult E&M problems include breaking down the problem into smaller steps, drawing diagrams to visualize the problem, and using equations and formulas to help solve the problem. It is also helpful to think about real-life examples or applications of the concepts being used in the problem.

Similar threads

  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
4
Views
5K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
8
Views
989
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
2
Views
11K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
2
Views
14K
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
28
Views
2K
  • STEM Educators and Teaching
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
4
Views
2K
Back
Top