Relative Velocities: Engineering Mechanics Dynamics - Hibbeler

  • Thread starter serverxeon
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Relative
1 reply · 2K views · last reply
serverxeon
Messages
100
Reaction score
0
Textbook problem text reading: Planes A and B fly at the same elevation and have the motions shown in Fig. 16-36. Determine the velocity and acceleration of A as measured by the pilot of B.

Diagram of two aircraft, A on the left and B on the right, with x-y axes at B and a curved path of radius 400 km; A is 4 km from B, with speeds 700 km/h and 600 km/h and accelerations 50 km/h² and 100 km/h² labelled.

Source: Engineering Mechanics Dynamics - Hibbeler
----------------------
My friends and I have discussed and have no idea how to solve.
So we looked at the textbook.

We were told to use this equation.

Relative velocity equation written as v_A = v_B + ω × r_A/B + v_A/B, with vector arrows over v_A, v_B, ω, r_A/B and v_A/B.


In this equation, A/B means 'A respect to B'
Also, the equation is derived based on an intermediate frame attached to point B, which is rotating at [itex]\omega[/itex].

In the textbook's solution below, however, the intermediate frame is attached to point B, but the [itex]\omega[/itex] is to the right of the frame (the centre of the prescribed circle). The [itex]\omega[/itex] is no longer about the frame through point B.

Hence, we have our suspicious of the textbook solution.
Anyway has got any idea if we're wrong, or is the textbook wrong?

--------------------
Worked solution showing vA = vB + Ω × rA/B + (vA/B)xyz, with vB = {600j} km/h, Ω = 600/400 = 1.5 rad/h giving Ω = {-1.5k} rad/h, rA/B = {-4i} km, and the result (vA/B)xyz = {94j} km/h.