The discussion revolves around the theoretical implications of applying a sinusoidal AC voltage across a zero resistance conductor, specifically in the context of superconductors. Participants explore the behavior of current waveforms in such a scenario, the assumptions involved, and the implications of inductance and resistance.
Participants generally do not reach a consensus, with multiple competing views regarding the assumptions and implications of the thought experiment. Some agree on the theoretical nature of the discussion, while others challenge the foundational premises.
Participants note limitations in the assumptions made, such as the definition of a zero resistance conductor and the implications of inductance. The discussion acknowledges that ideal conditions are assumed, but the practicality of such conditions is questioned.
DaleSpam said:
Good point. If the premise gets rid of part of Maxwell's laws, why not some other part also.Phrak said:
Phrak is right, forget what I said. You are making up a magical conductor so feel free to make up a magical voltage as well. Use whatever fantasy-land answer you want.b.shahvir said:I'm sorry, but i cannot seem to interpret your statement. In my opinion, a voltage can be applied across the abnormal conductor, just that it would not 'appear' across it as there is no impedance available for the voltage to drop across and 'reflect' itself externally...as all the voltage will be 'used up' in driving infinite current thru the said conductor!