Solid bounded by different region

34 replies · 5K views · last reply
chetzread
Messages
798
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


By using cylindrical coordinates , evaluate the volume of solid bounded on top of sphere (x^2) + (y^2) + (z^2) = 9 and it's sides by (x^2) + (y^2) = 4x . [/B]

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


I have sketched out the diagram , but i dun know which part is the solid formed... Can someone highlight the solid formed ? [/B]
 
Attachments
  • Hand-drawn 3D sketch of a sphere centred at the origin with x, y and z axes labelled, a vertical cylinder rising from the xy-plane, and the labels 3, 2, 3 and 4 marked on the axes.
    9899.jpg
    14.9 KB · Views: 468
chetzread said:

Homework Statement


By using cylindrical coordinates , evaluate the volume of solid bounded on top of sphere (x^2) + (y^2) + (z^2) = 9 and it's sides by (x^2) + (y^2) = 4x . [/B]

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


I have sketched out the diagram , but i dun know which part is the solid formed... Can someone highlight the solid formed ? [/B]

Is the wording you wrote the exact statement of the problem? If so, it is confusing, and in English may easily be misinterpreted. There is a difference in meaning between saying "bounded on top of sphere... "; the "on top" says to me that the region lies above the sphere---it is on top of the sphere. However, maybe it means "bounded on top BY the sphere..." which means the region lies below the sphere: the sphere is the top of the region. I suspect that the second interpretation is intended, but the wording of the problem could be taken to imply the opposite.

Anyway, what about a lower limit? is the opposite side of the sphere also the bottom of the region? If we don't specify a bottom, we can have ##z## extending to ##-\infty##, giving an infinite volume.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: chetzread
Ray Vickson said:
Is the wording you wrote the exact statement of the problem? If so, it is confusing, and in English may easily be misinterpreted. There is a difference in meaning between saying "bounded on top of sphere... "; the "on top" says to me that the region lies above the sphere---it is on top of the sphere. However, maybe it means "bounded on top BY the sphere..." which means the region lies below the sphere: the sphere is the top of the region. I suspect that the second interpretation is intended, but the wording of the problem could be taken to imply the opposite.

Anyway, what about a lower limit? is the opposite side of the sphere also the bottom of the region? If we don't specify a bottom, we can have ##z## extending to ##-\infty##, giving an infinite volume.
sorry , i made a typo . The original question is evaluate the volume of solid bounded on top by the sphere (x^2) + (y^2) + (z^2) = 9...
Here's after correction , the cylinder span from z = -3 to 3 ...
What is the portion of the solid bounded on top of sphere (x^2) + (y^2) + (z^2) = 9 and it's sides by (x^2) + (y^2) = 4x ?
I couldn't imagine
 
Attachments
  • Hand-drawn 3D sketch of a sphere of radius 3 centred at the origin, with x, y and z axes marked, and a vertical cylinder whose base circle passes through the origin, with labels 2 and 4 on the y-axis.
    408.jpg
    32.5 KB · Views: 484
chetzread said:
or there's something wrong with my diagram ?
Neither of your diagrams is very helpful, and both are incorrect. You have the circular cylinder located in the wrong place in both diagrams, and your drawing of the sphere just looks like a circle. Here's a quick sketch I did that attempts to show the portion of a sphere in the first octant.
3D coordinate axes with z vertical and x and y horizontal, showing a curved dome-shaped surface rising from the origin in the first octant, bounded by curves on the xz and yz planes.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: chetzread
@chetzread: In the ##xy## plane, draw the two circles ##x^2+y^2 = 9## (which is where the sphere cuts the ##xy## plane) and ##x^2+y^2 = 4x## (after you get it right). That picture should help you figure out the ##xy## region that your cylindrical coordinate ##r,\theta## region needs to describe. Hopefully you will see that you need two different integrals to set it up.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: chetzread
Mark44 said:
Neither of your diagrams is very helpful, and both are incorrect. You have the circular cylinder located in the wrong place in both diagrams, and your drawing of the sphere just looks like a circle. Here's a quick sketch I did that attempts to show the portion of a sphere in the first octant.
View attachment 108124
@Mark44 , @LCKurtz , is my cylinder located at the wrong position ?

So , i have chnaged the location ... Pls refer to the latest diagram i uploaded here

Here's what i did :

##x^2+y^2 = 4x##

##x^2-4x+y^2 = 0##

##(x-2)^2 -4 +y^2 =0##

##x^2-4x+4-4+y^2 =0##

##x^2+y^2=4x##

So , the circular part of cylinder located at x =2 , right ?
 
Attachments
  • Hand-drawn 3D sketch of a solid cylinder with its axis along the x-axis, labelled 4 on the x-axis and 3 and -3 on the z-axis, with a bulging ellipsoid-like shape inside.
    413.jpg
    30.2 KB · Views: 466
Last edited:
LCKurtz said:
@chetzread: In the ##xy## plane, draw the two circles ##x^2+y^2 = 9## (which is where the sphere cuts the ##xy## plane) and ##x^2+y^2 = 4x## (after you get it right). That picture should help you figure out the ##xy## region that your cylindrical coordinate ##r,\theta## region needs to describe. Hopefully you will see that you need two different integrals to set it up.
 
chetzread said:
@Mark44 , @LCKurtz , is my cylinder located at the wrong position ?

So , i have chnaged the location ... Pls refer to the latest diagram i uploaded here

Here's what i did :

##x^2+y^2 = 4x##

##x^2-4x+y^2 = 0##

##(x-2)^2 -4 +y^2 =0##

##x^2-4x+4-4+y^2 =0##

##x^2+y^2=4x##

So , the circular part of cylinder located at x =2 , right ?
The central axis of the cylinder goes through (2, 0, 0), yes, and is vertical. Your diagram is close to correct, except the sphere is slightly too large.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: chetzread
Mark44 said:
The central axis of the cylinder goes through (2, 0, 0), yes, and is vertical. Your diagram is close to correct, except the sphere is slightly too large.
Ok, my problem now is which is the region that the solid formed? Can you sketch the part that the solid form using my diagram? I have problem visualizing it...
 
chetzread said:
Ok, my problem now is which is the region that the solid formed? Can you sketch the part that the solid form using my diagram? I have problem visualizing it...
Draw a 2-D sketch of the projections of the two objects in the x-y plane.
 
Mark44 said:
Draw a 2-D sketch of the projections of the two objects in the x-y plane.
do you mean the green part is the solid formed ?
 
Attachments
  • Hand-drawn 3D sketch on lined paper with x, y and z axes; a solid of revolution with circular cross-sections is shown, with labels 3 and -3 on the z-axis and 4 on the x-axis. A green highlighted curved band marks the outer right region.
    413.jpg
    30.4 KB · Views: 450
That's not what I had in mind. It's not a two-dim. sketch. Also, the solid is bounded on top by the sphere. As I read the problem description, the solid is inside the sphere, not outside it, as you show in your sketch.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: chetzread
LCKurtz said:
@chetzread: In the ##xy## plane, draw the two circles ##x^2+y^2 = 9## (which is where the sphere cuts the ##xy## plane) and ##x^2+y^2 = 4x## (after you get it right). That picture should help you figure out the ##xy## region that your cylindrical coordinate ##r,\theta## region needs to describe. Hopefully you will see that you need two different integrals to set it up.

Mark44 said:
Draw a 2-D sketch of the projections of the two objects in the x-y plane.

We have both suggested this. You need to do it to make progress on this problem.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: chetzread
LCKurtz said:
We have both suggested this. You need to do it to make progress on this problem.
here it is ...
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten sketch on lined paper of two overlapping circles in the xy-plane, with x and y axes; one circle is centred at the origin and the other is shifted right, with tick marks labelled 1 and 2 on the x-axis.
    416.jpg
    16.7 KB · Views: 457
About time to hit the sack here. Where is the origin ##x=0## and ##x=1## on your sketch? Get it correct, then we can continue tomorrow.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: chetzread
LCKurtz said:
About time to hit the sack here. Where is the origin ##x=0## and ##x=1## on your sketch? Get it correct, then we can continue tomorrow.
here it is x = 0 ...
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten sketch of two overlapping circles on x and y axes, with the y-axis marked 3 and the x-axis marked 1, 2 and 3 and the origin labelled 0.
    416.jpg
    17.3 KB · Views: 435
Mark44 said:
Now, how about another two-dim. sketch, this time looking at the x-z plane?
here
 
Attachments
  • Hand-drawn sketch on lined paper of a circle in the y-z plane with axes labelled z (up) and x (right), with z-axis marks 3 and -3 and a labelled point 4 on the x-axis; a square lies to the right of the circle.
    417.jpg
    14.2 KB · Views: 428
chetzread said:
The original question is evaluate the volume of solid bounded on top by the sphere (x^2) + (y^2) + (z^2) = 9...
Here's after correction , the cylinder span from z = -3 to 3 ...
OK, now do you have an idea of what the solid looks like? One thing that's not clear to me from your description (copied above), is the solid also bounded on the bottom by the sphere, or is it just bounded on the top by the sphere?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: chetzread
Mark44 said:
OK, now do you have an idea of what the solid looks like? One thing that's not clear to me from your description (copied above), is the solid also bounded on the bottom by the sphere, or is it just bounded on the top by the sphere?
Here's the original question
By using cylindrical coordinates , evaluate the volume of solid bounded on top by the sphere (x^2) + (y^2) + (z^2) = 9 and it's sides by (x^2) + (y^2) = 4x .

so , i just sketched out the whole sphere ( include the portion on negative z axis)...No , i am still not sure how the solid looks like ...

Is it the diagram i posted in post #13 , the green part ?
 
Mark44 said:
OK, now do you have an idea of what the solid looks like? One thing that's not clear to me from your description (copied above), is the solid also bounded on the bottom by the sphere, or is it just bounded on the top by the sphere?
bump
 
chetzread said:
Here's the original question
By using cylindrical coordinates , evaluate the volume of solid bounded on top by the sphere (x^2) + (y^2) + (z^2) = 9 and it's sides by (x^2) + (y^2) = 4x .

so , i just sketched out the whole sphere ( include the portion on negative z axis)...No , i am still not sure how the solid looks like ...

Is it the diagram i posted in post #13 , the green part ?
No, the sketch in post #13 (green part) isn't right.

Also, you didn't answer my last question.
is the solid also bounded on the bottom by the sphere, or is it just bounded on the top by the sphere?
 
In order to facilitate getting this thread finished I am including a picture:
3D plot of a sphere and a vertical cylinder intersecting, viewed nearly down the z axis, with axes x from 0 to 4, y from -3 to 3 and z from 0 to 3.

This is looking almost straight down the z axis. You can see that the portion of the sphere inside the cylinder lies above the region which I will call ##D## which is the intersection of the two circles in the xy plane. So if you want the volume under the sphere and above the xy plane you have to set up the integral for the volume under the sphere over the region ##D## in polar coordinates. If you want to include the volume under the xy plane you would double that. That is what this problem is really about -- setting up that integral properly.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: chetzread
LCKurtz said:
In order to facilitate getting this thread finished I am including a picture:
View attachment 108270
This is looking almost straight down the z axis. You can see that the portion of the sphere inside the cylinder lies above the region which I will call ##D## which is the intersection of the two circles in the xy plane. So if you want the volume under the sphere and above the xy plane you have to set up the integral for the volume under the sphere over the region ##D## in polar coordinates. If you want to include the volume under the xy plane you would double that. That is what this problem is really about -- setting up that integral properly.
sorry , i really have problem understanding your diagram , can you explain further ? do you mean it's the view looking down from z a-xis ? if so , then i still can't understand it
 
LCKurtz said:
In order to facilitate getting this thread finished I am including a picture:
View attachment 108270
This is looking almost straight down the z axis. You can see that the portion of the sphere inside the cylinder lies above the region which I will call ##D## which is the intersection of the two circles in the xy plane. So if you want the volume under the sphere and above the xy plane you have to set up the integral for the volume under the sphere over the region ##D## in polar coordinates. If you want to include the volume under the xy plane you would double that. That is what this problem is really about -- setting up that integral properly.
do you mean green part = sphere (x^2) + (y^2) + (z^2) = 9 ?
yellow part = (x^2) + (y^2) = 4x ??

But , why isn't the (x^2) + (y^2) = 4x closed ? it's a cylinder , right ?
 
LCKurtz said:
In order to facilitate getting this thread finished I am including a picture:
View attachment 108270
This is looking almost straight down the z axis. You can see that the portion of the sphere inside the cylinder lies above the region which I will call ##D## which is the intersection of the two circles in the xy plane. So if you want the volume under the sphere and above the xy plane you have to set up the integral for the volume under the sphere over the region ##D## in polar coordinates. If you want to include the volume under the xy plane you would double that. That is what this problem is really about -- setting up that integral properly.
OK , but how do the solid formed look like ? I have problem of visualizing it . . . . . Can you sketch a separate diagram for the solid formed ?
 
chetzread said:
do you mean green part = sphere (x^2) + (y^2) + (z^2) = 9 ?
yellow part = (x^2) + (y^2) = 4x ??
Yes, the green part is the upper half of the sphere,
chetzread said:
But , why isn't the (x^2) + (y^2) = 4x closed ? it's a cylinder , right ?
It's a circular cylinder - the view, as LCKurtz said, is almost straight down the z-axis. The upper and lower ends of the cylinder are open, so I'm not sure what you're saying.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: chetzread
Mark44 said:
Yes, the green part is the upper half of the sphere,
It's a circular cylinder - the view, as LCKurtz said, is almost straight down the z-axis. The upper and lower ends of the cylinder are open, so I'm not sure what you're saying.
Then the Object Formed Is A plane Instead Of solid? ? I Cant ImagIne Tge Solid Fomed