Solid state physics, lattice constants, ionic radii, nacl

Click For Summary
The discussion focuses on calculating the lattice constant of KBr based on the ionic radii of NaCl, NaBr, and KCl, which share the same structure. The initial calculations provided an estimated lattice constant of 6.07 Å for KBr, but the expected answer is 6.64 Å, indicating a potential error in the approach. The relationship between ionic radii and lattice parameters is emphasized, with the suggestion to use the known radius of Na+ to derive the radii of other ions. The correct method involves using the sum of the ionic radii to determine the lattice parameter accurately. Understanding the geometric relationships in ionic compounds is crucial for these calculations.
izzy93
Messages
34
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



NaCl (a0 = 5.64A° ), NaBr (a0 = 5.98A° ) and KCl (a0 = 6.30A° ) all have the same structure, which
is the NaCl structure.

(a) Assuming the spacings are determined by the ionic radii of the relevant ions, what would value
would you expect for the lattice constant of KBr?
(b) If the Na+ ion has a radius of 0.97A° , determine the radii of the other ions.


Homework Equations



lattice constant for nacl type structure =2cl-radius + 2 na+ radius ??

The Attempt at a Solution



a, I used the interionic distance of NaBr= 5.98A°/2 = 2.99A°

and then pythagorous to finde the diameter of Br- =4.228A°

do the same with KCl, I got the cl- diameter to be 4.455A°

and then as the lattice parameter = the length of one side of the cubic structure;
2cl-radius + 2 k+ radius = 6.30A°
k+ radius =0.9225A°

therefore the lattice constant of kbr = 2(0.9225A°) + 2(4.228/2) = 6.07 A°

The answer given is 6.64 A°. Is there another way to do this or have I got the definition of the lattice parameter entirely wrong?

b, got this part right r_Cl:1.85A° r_Br:2.02A° r_K:1.30A°

Any help would be much appreciated
 
Physics news on Phys.org
izzy93 said:

Homework Statement



NaCl (a0 = 5.64A° ), NaBr (a0 = 5.98A° ) and KCl (a0 = 6.30A° ) all have the same structure, which
is the NaCl structure.

(a) Assuming the spacings are determined by the ionic radii of the relevant ions, what would value
would you expect for the lattice constant of KBr?
(b) If the Na+ ion has a radius of 0.97A° , determine the radii of the other ions.

Homework Equations



lattice constant for nacl type structure =2cl-radius + 2 na+ radius ??

The Attempt at a Solution



a, I used the interionic distance of NaBr= 5.98A°/2 = 2.99A°

and then pythagorous to finde the diameter of Br- =4.228A°

do the same with KCl, I got the cl- diameter to be 4.455A°

and then as the lattice parameter = the length of one side of the cubic structure;
2cl-radius + 2 k+ radius = 6.30A°
k+ radius =0.9225A°

therefore the lattice constant of kbr = 2(0.9225A°) + 2(4.228/2) = 6.07 A°

The answer given is 6.64 A°. Is there another way to do this or have I got the definition of the lattice parameter entirely wrong?

b, got this part right r_Cl:1.85A° r_Br:2.02A° r_K:1.30A°

Any help would be much appreciated

The distance between the nearest positive and negative ions is approximately equal to the sum of the ionic radii, but the distance between the negative ions, a0/√2 is not quite equal to their diameter. See picture. The opposite can be also true, in case of big negative ions they touch each other, but the positive ions do not touch the negative ones. Use only the lattice parameters and the given radius of the Na ion to get the radii of the other ions and the lattice parameter of KBr. You got rK and rBr: the lattice parameter of KBr is equal to twice the sum of these radii.

ehild
 

Attachments

  • NaCLradii.JPG
    NaCLradii.JPG
    7.8 KB · Views: 719
Last edited:

Similar threads

Replies
4
Views
14K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
18K