I Solve equation from dimensional analysis: 3 eq., 6 unknowns

Click For Summary
Carlton's discussion focuses on the derivation of the thrust of a marine propeller based on various parameters, including diameter, speed of advance, rotational speed, fluid density, viscosity, and static pressure. The proportional relationship derived indicates that thrust (T) can be expressed in terms of these parameters with specific exponents for each variable. The confusion arises around solving for the constants c, f, and g, given three equations and six unknowns. The calculations suggest that setting c, f, and g to zero leads to a simplified solution, but this feels incorrect to the author. The lack of this solution in Carlton's text raises questions about its validity and the completeness of the derivation.
phillip_at_work
Messages
13
Reaction score
2
TL;DR
Text book conducts dimensional analysis to derive an equation. Analysis involves 6 variables and 3 basic units (mass M, length L, and time T). This results in three equations and six unknowns. The final equation can be solved using three of those unknowns. However, with only three equations, I don't see how to find those three unknowns to actually get a solution for the derived equation. Text: Carlton 2007, Marine Propellers and Propulsion p89.
Carlton writes on page 89:
"The thrust of a marine propeller... may be expected to depend upon the following parameters:
(a) The diameter (D)
(b) the speed of advance (Va)
(c) The rotational speed (n)
(d) The density of the fluid (ρ)
(e) The viscosity of the fluid (μ)
(f) The static pressure of the fluid at the propeller station (p0-e)"

What follows is Carlton's derivation:

T ∝ ρaDbVacndμf(p0-e)g

And by dimensional analysis, we get:

MLT-2 = (ML-3)aLb(LT-1)c(T-1)d(ML-1T-1)f(ML-1T-2)g

which results in the following equations:

for mass M: 1 = a + f + g
for length L: 1 = -3a + b + c - f - g
for time T: -2 = -c - d - f - 2g

and hence:

a = 1 - f - g
b = 4 - c - 2f -g
d = 2 - c - f - 2g

And so that proportion can be updated to be:

T ∝ ρ (1-f-g) D (4-c-2f-g)Vacn(2-c-f-2g)μf(po-e)g

For the final equation as:

T = ρn2D4(Va/ nD)c* (μ / ρnD2)f* ( (p0-e) / pn2D2)g

I can follow this derivation without issue. What is confusing is how I solve for T. How can I know the values of `c`, `f`, and `g` as I have three equations and six unknowns? What am I missing?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I think I solved my own question. Happy for feedback.

Constant exponents are derived for ρa, nd and Db. These are ρ1, n2, and D4.

That is, a=1, d=2, and b=4. If I apply these to the system of three equations:

a = 1 = 1 - f - g
b = 4 = 4 - c - 2f -g
d = 2 = 2 - c - f - 2g

I compute,

g = f = c = 0

Which feels incorrect, but perhaps I'm over thinking. If this was correct, I'm not sure why Carlton wouldn't write this solution in the chapter, which s/he does not. Any feedback is much appreciated.
 
Hello, I'm joining this forum to ask two questions which have nagged me for some time. I am in no way trolling. They both are presumed obvious, yet don't make sense to me. Nobody will explain their positions, which is...uh...aka science. I also have a thread for the other question. Yes, I'm questioning the most elementary physics question we're given in this world. The classic elevator in motion question: A person is standing on a scale in an elevator that is in constant motion...