Solving Problems in Projectile Motion, SHM of Charge Ring & Electric Quadrapole

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around three physics problems: projectile motion involving an electron in an electric field, simple harmonic motion (SHM) of a particle on the axis of a charge ring, and the electric field generated by a quadrupole arrangement of charges. Participants are exploring the underlying concepts and mathematical relationships in these areas.

Discussion Character

  • Mixed

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the projectile motion problem, focusing on the use of trigonometric identities and the role of the electric field in determining the trajectory. There is uncertainty about how to incorporate the electric field into the calculations.
  • In the SHM problem, participants express confusion about deriving the frequency from the electric force and relate it to the spring force analogy presented by the professor.
  • The electric quadrupole problem prompts discussions on calculating the electric field from multiple charge contributions and the simplifications that can be made under certain assumptions.

Discussion Status

Some participants have provided guidance on using trigonometric identities and the relationship between force and motion in the SHM context. There is ongoing exploration of the mathematical relationships and physical principles involved, with no clear consensus reached yet.

Contextual Notes

Participants note challenges with the mathematical complexity of the problems and the need for clarification on the application of concepts such as energy conservation and electric fields. There are indications of assumptions being questioned, particularly regarding the simplifications made in the electric quadrupole problem.

Gale
Messages
683
Reaction score
1
i have a few problems that i was struggling with.

Projectile motion:
An electron is fired in an electric field E=-720j. Its launched with a velocity of 9550 m/s. if you want the x distance it travels to be 1.27mm, what are the two values of theta that will work? how long does it take?

so, like i do all projectile problems, i found t using the x components, (which i left in terms of theta,) because there's no force in x. then i plugged t into y_f= 1/2at^2 +v_ot. my problem was that i was left with cos and sin's and i didn't know what to do with them. i couldn't easily solve for theta. and at any rate, i wasn't really sure how to use the electric field. when i thought about gravity fields, i thought that i should be using energy or something, and i just got confused.

SHM of charge ring:
i forget the wording of this one, but its just like, show that the frequency of a particle moving on the axis of a ring is [tex]f=\frac{1}{2\pi}*(\frac{kQq}{ma^3})^1/2[/tex]

i tried starting with the electric field, and getting the force from that. when my prof did an example with the spring force in class, he did this really weird thing i can't follow now. he was like f=1/s and so if F=kx=ma then k/m*x=d^2x/dt^2, and what function looks like its second derivative? sin. and then we have the constant k/m, which must be frequency squares since sin(ax)'s second deriv is a^2sin(ax). and that's how he found the frequency for the spring. i have NO idea how to do that with the electric force. i tried working backwards too, but i couldn't really make sense of it because there's x's in the denominator of the force and not the frequency, and yeah, I'm stuck.

The last problem I'm stuck on is this-
Electric quadrapole:
whats the electric field along the y-axis if there's a quadrapole on the x axis, with charge q at (-a,0), -2q at (0,0) and q at (a,0)?

so i started with writing the field generated by each. knowing that the x components of the two q charges would cancel, and their y's would be equal. so i got two terms, and i simplified and used the binomial theorem, and i couldn't get it right. but i think I'm going to try this one again.

thanks!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
i really do need help on the harmonic motion one. I'm super stuck. I'm doing the first one with work-energy theorem, and i think I'm just screwing up the math in the third one, but the second one I'm really clueless on.
 
Gale said:
i have a few problems that i was struggling with.

Projectile motion:
An electron is fired in an electric field E=-720j. Its launched with a velocity of 9550 m/s. if you want the x distance it travels to be 1.27mm, what are the two values of theta that will work? how long does it take?

so, like i do all projectile problems, i found t using the x components, (which i left in terms of theta,) because there's no force in x. then i plugged t into y_f= 1/2at^2 +v_ot. my problem was that i was left with cos and sin's and i didn't know what to do with them. i couldn't easily solve for theta. and at any rate, i wasn't really sure how to use the electric field. when i thought about gravity fields, i thought that i should be using energy or something, and i just got confused.

Rewrite everything in terms of [tex]tan (\theta)[/tex] (you will need to use [tex]{1 \over cos^2 \theta} = 1 + tan^2 (\theta)[/tex]). Then you wilh have a quadratic formula for [tex]tan (\theta)[/tex] . Solve and then take the inverse tan of the two roots.


SHM of charge ring:
i forget the wording of this one, but its just like, show that the frequency of a particle moving on the axis of a ring is [tex]f=\frac{1}{2\pi}*(\frac{kQq}{ma^3})^1/2[/tex]

i tried starting with the electric field, and getting the force from that. when my prof did an example with the spring force in class, he did this really weird thing i can't follow now. he was like f=1/s and so if F=kx=ma then k/m*x=d^2x/dt^2, and what function looks like its second derivative? sin. and then we have the constant k/m, which must be frequency squares since sin(ax)'s second deriv is a^2sin(ax). and that's how he found the frequency for the spring. i have NO idea how to do that with the electric force. i tried working backwards too, but i couldn't really make sense of it because there's x's in the denominator of the force and not the frequency, and yeah, I'm stuck.


That's right. All you have to do is to show that the electric force on the point charge has the form [tex]- C~ y[/tex] where C is a constant. Then, y(t) has to follow simple harmonic motion with [tex]\omega[/tex] given by [tex]\omega = {\sqrt {C \over mass}}[/tex]. So all you have to know is the electric field of a ring along its axis and that times the charge of the point charge will give you the force.
 
For your first question:
[tex]\vec{a} = \vec{F}/m_e = \frac{-e(-720\vec{j})}{m_e}[/tex]

[tex]at = v_0 \sin(\theta)[/tex]
[tex]\Delta x = v_0 \cos(\theta) t[/tex]
substituting t with other stuff
[tex]\Delta x = v_0 \cos(\theta) v_0 \sin(\theta) / a[/tex]

I think what you needed was trigonometic identity [tex]2 \sin(\theta) \cos(\theta) = \sin(2 \theta)[/tex]

Use it and you have

[tex]\sin(2 \theta)/2 = \frac{\Delta x a}{v_0^2}[/tex]
which you can easily solve for the angle.

For the second one, I guess you mean an axis passing through the middle of a ring, perpendicular to the surface of ring. The force for it is:
[tex]\frac{kqQx}{(x^2 + a^2)^{3/2}}[/tex]
where a is the radius of circle, Q is the charge of ring, and q is our hero. It appears that you've assumed a>>r, so the force would be simplified into
[tex]\frac{kqQx}{a^3}[/tex]. Plugging this to 2nd law of Newton
[tex]\frac{md^2}{dt^2} = \frac{kqQx}{a^3}[/tex]
It's solution Asin(wt) + Bcos(wt) where w is [tex]\sqrt{\frac{kqQx}{ma^3}}[/tex]. Since [tex]\omega = 2 \pi f[/tex]...

And finally, or the third: E at (0,y) should be the superposition of all three. For q charges, it's [tex](kq/{r^2}) \sin(\theta) = (kq/{r^2}) \frac{y}{r}[/tex], and [tex]r=\sqrt{y^2+a^2}[/tex]. There're 2 of them. And for -2q, it's simply [tex]k(-2q)/{y^2}[/tex]. Just add the 3 then.
 

Similar threads

Replies
11
Views
4K
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • · Replies 68 ·
3
Replies
68
Views
8K
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
2K
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
3K