Statically indeterminate beam problem

10 replies · 4K views · last reply
yecko
Gold Member
Messages
275
Reaction score
15

Homework Statement


Diagram of a fixed-support beam from A with a uniform downward load W over length L/2, a pin-like roller support at C, and a roller support at B a further L/2 to the right, with dimension labels L/2 above each span.


Homework Equations


Beam problem
Deflection
Statically indeterminate

The Attempt at a Solution


Handwritten superposition working for a statically indeterminate beam: deflection at C and B from a uniform load w and reactions Rc and RB, using Gere Table G-1 cases 1, 2, 4 and 5, ending with Rc = -3wL/16 and RB = 13wL/16 solved from the compatibility equations.


Am I correct? Or should the assumed deflection at B be the difference in deflection between B and C? Thanks
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten superposition working for a statically indeterminate beam: deflection at C and B from a uniform load w and reactions Rc and RB, using Gere Table G-1 cases 1, 2, 4 and 5, ending with Rc = -3wL/16 and RB = 13wL/16 solved from the compatibility equations.
    B02BCA7F-F9F1-4BAA-91D7-E1EA9C83F96E.jpeg
    39.9 KB · Views: 1,262
  • Diagram of a fixed-support beam from A with a uniform downward load W over length L/2, a pin-like roller support at C, and a roller support at B a further L/2 to the right, with dimension labels L/2 above each span.
    4BD38064-B683-4B47-93D0-DA96E951766E.png
    17.8 KB · Views: 2,923
It looks like you are solving this as the superposition of three separate loadings, but you don't provide enough information (text) about the separate solutions to the three loading problems. Please provide more detailed discussion, rather than just a reference to some table.
 
Sorry that i forgot to embed the reference here. The two photos are the reference i used.
Table of beam deflection formulas: case 1 shows a uniformly distributed load q over full span L on a cantilever with v = -qx^2/(24EI)(6L^2 - 4Lx + x^2), and case 2 shows load q over length a of a cantilever with v and v' expressions for 0 ≤ x ≤ a and a ≤ x ≤ L.
Table of beam deflection formulas for cantilever cases 4, 5 and 6, showing v, v', delta_B and theta_B expressions in terms of P, L, a, x and EI.
 
Attachments
  • Table of beam deflection formulas: case 1 shows a uniformly distributed load q over full span L on a cantilever with v = -qx^2/(24EI)(6L^2 - 4Lx + x^2), and case 2 shows load q over length a of a cantilever with v and v' expressions for 0 ≤ x ≤ a and a ≤ x ≤ L.
    image.jpg
    58.1 KB · Views: 810
  • Table of beam deflection formulas for cantilever cases 4, 5 and 6, showing v, v', delta_B and theta_B expressions in terms of P, L, a, x and EI.
    image.jpg
    50.9 KB · Views: 749
Here is the numerical calculation derived from post #1, that i thought you may not need it.
You can just take it as reference.
Handwritten derivation of beam reactions with several crossed-out terms: Rc = -WL^3 (L/2)/(8EI) style expression, a deflection equation with WL^3/EI and RB L^3/(3EI) terms, and the result RB = -(13/512) WL.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten derivation of beam reactions with several crossed-out terms: Rc = -WL^3 (L/2)/(8EI) style expression, a deflection equation with WL^3/EI and RB L^3/(3EI) terms, and the result RB = -(13/512) WL.
    image.jpg
    18.3 KB · Views: 761
Chestermiller said:
Please provide more detailed discussion,
Indeed, i have no idea with how to derive the formula from the cases in the reference. However, do you mind to tell me if my method of utilising the formulae correct?or should the assumed deflection at B be the difference in deflection between B and C? Thanks
 
What you need to do is express the displacements at B and C in the following form:

$$\delta_B=C_1W+C_2R_B+C_3R_C$$ and $$\delta_C=C_4W+C_5R_B+C_6R_C$$where the subscripted C's are obtained from the solutions to the separate problems in terms of the property- and geometric parameters. You then set ##\delta_B## and ##\delta_C## equal to zero and solve the results pair of linear algebraic equations for the two unknowns, ##R_B## and ##R_C##.
 
Handwritten working on lined paper for a statically indeterminate beam: a uniformly loaded beam with reaction R_B and R_C, deflection equations for cases 1, 4, 6 and 2, and compatibility equations leading to equations marked (1) and (2).

Handwritten working on lined paper: equation 1 gives RB = 24 × (5Rc/48 − 5wL/192); equation 2 shows −wL/384 + 5/2(5/48 Rc − 5wL/192) + Rc/3 = 0, then −13/192 wL + 19/32 Rc = 0, Rc = 12/114 wL, and RB = 5/2 Rc − 5/8 wL = 5/2 · 13/114 wL − 5/8 wL = −133/192 wL.

Am i correct to calculate like this? Thanks
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten working on lined paper for a statically indeterminate beam: a uniformly loaded beam with reaction R_B and R_C, deflection equations for cases 1, 4, 6 and 2, and compatibility equations leading to equations marked (1) and (2).
    3d367454-bb29-408d-93da-3fe668b80fa4-jpeg.jpg
    33.9 KB · Views: 1,076
  • Handwritten working on lined paper: equation 1 gives RB = 24 × (5Rc/48 − 5wL/192); equation 2 shows −wL/384 + 5/2(5/48 Rc − 5wL/192) + Rc/3 = 0, then −13/192 wL + 19/32 Rc = 0, Rc = 12/114 wL, and RB = 5/2 Rc − 5/8 wL = 5/2 · 13/114 wL − 5/8 wL = −133/192 wL.
    52635064-3390-4305-be35-96236a921279-jpeg.jpg
    20.9 KB · Views: 1,097
sorry for unable to type all my formulae out.
I have got "δ=δW+δRB+δRC+δM" for B and C, for which each are using the formula from reference list.
thank you very much
 
I get the following: $$\frac{R_B}{24}+5\frac{R_C}{48}=\frac{WL}{128}$$ and
$$5\frac{R_B}{48}+\frac{R_C}{3}=7\frac{WL}{(16)(24)}$$
This simplifies to:
$$R_B+\frac{5}{2}R_C=\frac{3}{16}WL$$and$$\frac{5}{2}R_B+8R_C=\frac{7}{16}WL$$

So, $$R_B=\frac{13}{56}WL$$
and $$R_C=-\frac{WL}{56}$$
 
Last edited:
Handwritten derivation of deflection compatibility equations for a propped-cantilever beam with uniform load W, supports at C and B, using Gere Table G deflection formulas, ending in Rc = -83/456 WL and RB = 1/456 WL.
Well, the sign of my equations are different from yours, the answer is different...
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten derivation of deflection compatibility equations for a propped-cantilever beam with uniform load W, supports at C and B, using Gere Table G deflection formulas, ending in Rc = -83/456 WL and RB = 1/456 WL.
    9B900622-3B9E-4C70-AE24-CABE7D2EE8BF.jpeg
    55.4 KB · Views: 747
Last edited: