Statics and Structural Analysis Question

AI Thread Summary
Understanding the connections of beams, particularly whether they are pinned at joints, is crucial before solving structural problems. The recommended approach involves calculating known reaction forces, starting with points A and F, which then allows for determining other unknown forces. Once all forces are identified, shear and moment diagrams can be created. For additional problems, the same method applies: calculate the easiest support forces first and work towards the columns. Both cases discussed are statically indeterminate, requiring specific procedures to solve for loads effectively.
track1716
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
TL;DR Summary
Could Someone help me out with this question? I have no idea where to begin.
I am able to draw shear and bending moment diagrams. We were never taught how to even start with a problem like this.
 

Attachments

  • BEE781A8-6C08-46F8-80BF-0B39F3D52E29.jpeg
    BEE781A8-6C08-46F8-80BF-0B39F3D52E29.jpeg
    13.5 KB · Views: 371
Engineering news on Phys.org
First, are the beams connected with pin joints at B and E? That needs to be understood before proceeding.

After you are clear on the problem to be solved, the technique is to start wherever you can calculate something. Usually, you can calculate at least one unknown force, and the result will allow you to find another unknown force. Keep going until you have all unknown forces. Then you will be ready to start the shear and moment diagrams.

The reaction forces at A and F would be a good place to start. From those, you can find the reaction forces at B and E, followed by ...
 
  • Like
Likes Lnewqban
jrmichler said:
First, are the beams connected with pin joints at B and E? That needs to be understood before proceeding.

After you are clear on the problem to be solved, the technique is to start wherever you can calculate something. Usually, you can calculate at least one unknown force, and the result will allow you to find another unknown force. Keep going until you have all unknown forces. Then you will be ready to start the shear and moment diagrams.

The reaction forces at A and F would be a good place to start. From those, you can find the reaction forces at B and E, followed by ...
Thank you! It’s a continuous beam. I think I can solve it now. I ran into 2 other problems i’m having trouble with as well. How would I draw the loading diagrams for these 2 problems? How do I calculate the force pushing up on either end where the column joints are? If that even makes sense...
 

Attachments

  • 0847DFAB-885D-4B70-ABA7-07F1CE9A26FA.jpeg
    0847DFAB-885D-4B70-ABA7-07F1CE9A26FA.jpeg
    28.3 KB · Views: 337
Same procedure - calculate the support forces that are easiest to calculate, then keep at it until all have been calculated. Keep at it until you succeed. Both problems are solvable. Both will take some time.

Another approach is to calculate the loading on each beam, then work outward to the columns.

These two cases are statically indeterminant, so you will need to use the procedure for statically indeterminant systems to get the loads.
 
  • Like
Likes Lnewqban
Back
Top