Discussion Overview
The thread explores the topic of strange or bizarre covers of songs deemed as "best songs," inviting participants to share their experiences and opinions on unconventional interpretations of popular music. The discussion encompasses various genres and styles, focusing on the subjective nature of what constitutes a "strange" cover.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Debate/contested
- Conceptual clarification
Main Points Raised
- One participant mentions a cover of "Child in Time" by Gregorian, expressing initial confusion followed by a slight appreciation for its strangeness.
- Another participant shares a cover titled "Oy to the World, a Klezmer Christmas" by the Klezmonauts, questioning the potential for a cover of "Oy Como Va."
- A participant discusses vkgoeswild, a classically trained pianist, noting that while some parts of her covers sound good, others are perceived as lame or awful.
- There is a suggestion that covers by classical musicians can often lack the lyrical development found in pop music, leading to a perception of them as less engaging.
- One participant expresses a desire for others to share their views on what they find strange or bizarre, indicating that perceptions of strangeness can vary widely.
- Another participant points out that Gregorian chants have had popular success, questioning the basis for labeling the cover as strange.
- There is a mention of a cover of "Highway Star" by a middle-aged Japanese man, highlighting the diversity of interpretations.
- A participant notes that the cover might be perceived as better than the original, indicating subjective preferences in music interpretation.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
The discussion reflects a lack of consensus on what constitutes a "strange" or "bizarre" cover, with participants expressing differing opinions on specific examples and the nature of musical interpretation.
Contextual Notes
Participants acknowledge that perceptions of strangeness in music can be influenced by individual psychological or personality traits, suggesting a complex interplay between personal taste and cultural context.