- #1

- 68

- 4

Hello. This is a question for the philosophers. I know just a little bit about QT and GR, but have a solid background in QM, classical physics and some particle physics.

I was wondering about the stress energy tensor. I know that the graviton must have spin 2 because the source of gravity is a rank 2 tensor.

Now, the stress energy tensor contains properties like mass density, pressure and shear stress. These are large scale macro-properties, no? Seems like a continuum hypothesis for the mass/energy is assumed. So my question is how can one make a quantum theory of gravity while using these concepts? Seems like trying to make a quantum theory of atoms or particles using properties like bulk-modulus and mass density?

If one looks at the mass as a collection of many many single particles. Then, the contribution to the warping of space-time from each single particle shouldn't contain concepts like shear or pressure? Couldn't, in this picture, the source of gravity be a rank 1 tensor (i.e. four-momentum), and the 2nd rank only comes after we consider the effect of all these single particles?

I was wondering about the stress energy tensor. I know that the graviton must have spin 2 because the source of gravity is a rank 2 tensor.

Now, the stress energy tensor contains properties like mass density, pressure and shear stress. These are large scale macro-properties, no? Seems like a continuum hypothesis for the mass/energy is assumed. So my question is how can one make a quantum theory of gravity while using these concepts? Seems like trying to make a quantum theory of atoms or particles using properties like bulk-modulus and mass density?

If one looks at the mass as a collection of many many single particles. Then, the contribution to the warping of space-time from each single particle shouldn't contain concepts like shear or pressure? Couldn't, in this picture, the source of gravity be a rank 1 tensor (i.e. four-momentum), and the 2nd rank only comes after we consider the effect of all these single particles?

Last edited: