Substitution method for finding an integral's interval changes

Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The discussion centers on the validity of multiple substitutions in definite integrals, specifically in the context of finding the volume of a solid of revolution using the integral \pi \int_{-3}^{5}3^{2}-(\sqrt{\frac{y+3}{2}}+1)^2dy. The user successfully transformed the variable from y to u, and then from u to w, adjusting the limits accordingly. Experts confirmed that multiple substitutions are valid, but suggested that a single substitution, such as w = \frac{y + 3}{2}, would simplify the process. Additionally, they noted a minor error in the factor during the final expression.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of definite integrals and their properties
  • Familiarity with substitution methods in integral calculus
  • Knowledge of volume calculations for solids of revolution
  • Basic algebraic manipulation skills, including expanding binomials
NEXT STEPS
  • Study the method of substitution in integral calculus
  • Learn about calculating volumes of solids of revolution using integrals
  • Practice expanding binomials and simplifying expressions in integrals
  • Explore the implications of changing limits of integration during substitutions
USEFUL FOR

Students and educators in calculus, particularly those focusing on integral calculus and volume calculations, as well as anyone seeking to improve their skills in substitution methods.

thegreengineer
Messages
54
Reaction score
3
Look, I was wondering if substituting the variable more than once is valid and hence the definite integral intervals change this way.
Consider the following integral (I'm working for finding the volume of a solid of revolution):
*\pi \int_{-3}^{5}3^{2}-(\sqrt{\frac{y+3}{2}}+1)^2dy
Personally I hate to work hard (in this case I mean I would not rather to expand that binomial (\sqrt{\frac{y+3}{2}}+1)^2 because it has a division within a square root and we also have a binomial which is y+3 so it would be so much time-wasting in my opinion to expand all that. So what I did was to transform that y+3 into u so:
u=y+3
du=dy
Also I changed the intervals (if u=y+3 then the new interval would be obtained by substituting the values within the y+3 so the first interval would be a=(-3)+3=0 and the other b=5+3=8 so the integral would become:
*\pi \int_{0}^{8}3^{2}-(\sqrt{\frac{u}{2}}+1)^2du
This integral now it seems easier than the original, however, it's still kind of time wasting in my opinion to have a division within the root, so now I convert \frac{u}{2} into w so:
w=\frac{u}{2}
dw=\frac{du}{2}
Since I made another substitution then the integral interval must be changed once again so if w=\frac{u}{2} then the first limit of the interval is got by replacing the value of the first limit of the last integral into w=\frac{u}{2} so a=\frac{0}{2}=0 and b=\frac{8}{2}=4, therefore the integral becomes:
*(1/2)\pi \int_{0}^{4}3^{2}-(\sqrt{w}+1)^2dw.

I don't know if this is valid, I would appreciate if someone told me because I'm failing in integral calculus. Thanks.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
MarcusAu314 said:
Look, I was wondering if substituting the variable more than once is valid and hence the definite integral intervals change this way.
Consider the following integral (I'm working for finding the volume of a solid of revolution):
*\pi \int_{-3}^{5}3^{2}-(\sqrt{\frac{y+3}{2}}+1)^2dy
Personally I hate to work hard (in this case I mean I would not rather to expand that binomial (\sqrt{\frac{y+3}{2}}+1)^2 because it has a division within a square root and we also have a binomial which is y+3 so it would be so much time-wasting in my opinion to expand all that. So what I did was to transform that y+3 into u so:
u=y+3
du=dy
Also I changed the intervals (if u=y+3 then the new interval would be obtained by substituting the values within the y+3 so the first interval would be a=(-3)+3=0 and the other b=5+3=8 so the integral would become:
*\pi \int_{0}^{8}3^{2}-(\sqrt{\frac{u}{2}}+1)^2du
This integral now it seems easier than the original, however, it's still kind of time wasting in my opinion to have a division within the root, so now I convert \frac{u}{2} into w so:
w=\frac{u}{2}
dw=\frac{du}{2}
Since I made another substitution then the integral interval must be changed once again so if w=\frac{u}{2} then the first limit of the interval is got by replacing the value of the first limit of the last integral into w=\frac{u}{2} so a=\frac{0}{2}=0 and b=\frac{8}{2}=4, therefore the integral becomes:
*(1/2)\pi \int_{0}^{4}3^{2}-(\sqrt{w}+1)^2dw.

I don't know if this is valid, I would appreciate if someone told me because I'm failing in integral calculus. Thanks.
Yes, it's valid to make more than one substitution, changing the limits of integration each time.

It would be simpler, though, to just make one substitution: ##w = \frac{y + 3} 2##. Then dw = dy/2.

Alternatively, expanding ##(\frac{y + 3}{2} + 1)^2## isn't really that hard. You probably could have done it in the time it took you to type your question. After expanding, get common denominators (of 4), and bring out a factor of 1/2 outside the radical.
 
(Previous comment deleted, just saw Mark44 said prerty much the same)

There is just one thing in your last formula, you got a factor wrong - note that ##dw=\frac{du}{2}## so ##du=2dw##.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
4K