Discussion Overview
The discussion centers around the visibility distance of tall buildings, specifically the Burj Khalifa, from the ground. Participants explore the mathematical relationships involved in determining how tall a building must be to be seen from a distance of 250 kilometers, involving concepts of geometry and the curvature of the Earth.
Discussion Character
- Technical explanation
- Mathematical reasoning
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- One participant questions the claim that a building needs to be 4.9 km tall to be visible from 250 km away and requests an explanation of the equation used to arrive at this figure.
- Another participant asserts that their calculations indicate the height required is slightly more than 4.9 km, using the polar Earth diameter and the distance as line of sight.
- A participant provides their own equation for calculating the height needed for visibility, suggesting that the initial approach may have been inaccurate.
- Further calculations are presented, with one participant refining their earlier approximation to 4.90058148 km based on a more precise Earth radius at a specific latitude.
- Another participant discusses using the same formula to determine the distance from which the Burj Khalifa can be seen, based on its actual height and the Earth’s radius.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express differing views on the calculations and assumptions regarding the height required for visibility. There is no consensus on the correct height, and multiple competing calculations are presented.
Contextual Notes
Participants rely on various approximations and definitions of the Earth's radius, which may affect their calculations. Some assumptions about the visibility conditions and the geometry involved are also not fully resolved.