- #1

- 23

- 1

- Homework Statement
- Tan ##2 \theta=4 /(1-1)##. This means ##2 \theta=90^{\circ}## and ##\theta=45^{\circ}##

- Relevant Equations
- None

One of my solutions had this in one part. Why is this the case?

You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.

You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

- #1

- 23

- 1

- Homework Statement
- Tan ##2 \theta=4 /(1-1)##. This means ##2 \theta=90^{\circ}## and ##\theta=45^{\circ}##

- Relevant Equations
- None

One of my solutions had this in one part. Why is this the case?

- #2

For what values of ##\alpha## does ##\tan{\alpha}## diverge to positive infinity?

- #3

- 24,258

- 16,013

You know that as ##\theta \rightarrow \frac \pi 2## then ##\tan \theta \rightarrow +\infty##?Homework Statement::Tan ##2 \theta=4 /(1-1)##. This means ##2 \theta=90^{\circ}## and ##\theta=45^{\circ}##

Relevant Equations::None

One of my solutions had this in one part. Why is this the case?

- #4

- 23

- 1

Also, is this also correct?

##\begin{array}{l}

\cot 2 \theta=0 \\

\frac{\cos 2 \theta}{\sin 2 \theta}=0 \\

\cos 2 \theta=0 \\

2 \theta=90

\end{array}##

- #5

- 24,258

- 16,013

Also, is this also correct?

##\begin{array}{l}

\cot 2 \theta=0 \\

\frac{\cos 2 \theta}{\sin 2 \theta}=0 \\

\cos 2 \theta=0 \\

2 \theta=90

\end{array}##

That's right where ##2\theta## is between ##0## and ##180°##. Another solution could be ##2\theta = 270°##.

- #6

- 688

- 210

Isn't ##1-1## a bit ambiguous, though? Was this a limit like ##x-1##?

- #7

Isn't ##1-1## a bit ambiguous, though? Was this a limit like ##x-1##?

A related example... if we parameterise a circle with ##(x,y) = (a\cos{\theta}, a\sin{\theta})## s.t. ##y' = -\frac{\cos{\theta}}{\sin{\theta}}## and wanted to see where the circle is vertical, would you also take issue with identifying ##\sin{\theta} = 0 \implies \theta = 0, \pi##?

- #8

Mentor

- 37,045

- 9,146

1 - 1 = 0, which is not at all ambiguous. However, the fraction ##\frac 4 {1 - 1}## is undefined.Isn't ##1-1## a bit ambiguous, though? Was this a limit like ##x-1##?

- #9

- 688

- 210

No problem with identifying the vertical part, but ##y'## either goes to infinity or negative infinity depending on how you choose to make ##\theta## go to either of those values (right or left of ##0## or ##\pi##).A related example... if we parameterise a circle with ##(x,y) = (a\cos{\theta}, a\sin{\theta})## s.t. ##y' = -\frac{\cos{\theta}}{\sin{\theta}}## and wanted to see where the circle is vertical, would you also take issue with identifying ##\sin{\theta} = 0 \implies \theta = 0, \pi##?

The same thing with the ##1/(1-1)## fraction. Whether you have it ##1-x## or ##x-1##, then, however ##x## approaches ##1##, you will get different results (##\pi/2## or ##-\pi/2##).

@Mark44 this is what I was aiming at.

- #10

No problem with identifying the vertical part, but ##y'## either goes to infinity or negative infinity depending on how you choose to make ##\theta## go to either of those values (right or left of ##0## or ##\pi##).

The same thing with the ##1/(1-1)## fraction. Whether you have it ##1-x## or ##x-1##, then, however ##x## approaches ##1##, you will get different results (##\pi/2## or ##-\pi/2##).

@Mark44 this is what I was aiming at.

I see your point, and I the interpretation would be clearer from context.

In most cases where I've seen these sorts of steps, it hasn't mattered from which side you approach ##x## (e.g. for my circle example, a gradient of ##\infty## is equivalent to one of ##-\infty## for purposes of determining the vertical tangent).

- #11

- 561

- 262

$$\tan 2x = \frac{2 \tan x}{1-\tan^2 x} = \frac{4}{0} \rightarrow 0 = 4-4\tan^2 x \rightarrow \tan^2 x = 1$$

And from here the ##\frac{\pi}{4}## falls out "neatly", along with all the other solutions. But be careful, this is "illegal" math. However, you started off with a statement of ##\frac{4}{0}##, I feel okay using hand-wavy tactics here.

- #12

- 39,899

- 9,079

Is that really the problem as given to you? I suggest that you had done some work to arrive at that. If so, please post the actual problem.Homework Statement::Tan ##2 \theta=4 /(1-1)##.

- #13

Gold Member

- 2,237

- 291

I seem not to understand this problem, well what i know is that,

##tan 2x## = ##\dfrac {2 tan x}{1-tan ^2 x}## and given that (from OP)##tan 2θ## = ##\dfrac {4}{1-1}## if indeed ##2tan x=4## then ##⇒tan x=2## which clearly contradicts with ##tan^2 x=1##.

##tan 2x## = ##\dfrac {2 tan x}{1-tan ^2 x}## and given that (from OP)##tan 2θ## = ##\dfrac {4}{1-1}## if indeed ##2tan x=4## then ##⇒tan x=2## which clearly contradicts with ##tan^2 x=1##.

Last edited:

- #14

Science Advisor

Homework Helper

Gold Member

- 4,183

- 2,487

With 0 in the denominator the problem is not well defined so there is no point wasting your time trying to understand it, move on.I seem not to understand this problem

Share:

- Replies
- 5

- Views
- 1K

- Replies
- 8

- Views
- 1K

- Replies
- 1

- Views
- 421

- Replies
- 5

- Views
- 994

- Replies
- 6

- Views
- 516

- Replies
- 13

- Views
- 384

- Replies
- 7

- Views
- 186

- Replies
- 1

- Views
- 511

- Replies
- 8

- Views
- 249

- Replies
- 8

- Views
- 199