Tension of rope between two trees

2 replies · 4K views · last reply
PhizKid
Messages
477
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement


Diagram of a uniform rope hanging in a sagging curve between two trees, with angle theta marked at each end, and problem 2.22 text with answer clue T_end = W/√2, T_middle = W/2 at theta = 45°.



Homework Equations


F = ma

The Attempt at a Solution


say I project the weight onto T
then I get the right answer
if theta = pi / 4 then Wcostheta = W / sqrt2
but if I project the tension onto the weight, i don't get the right thing
i get the opposite, Tcostheta = W
which makes no sense
i guess the question is
is Wcostheta - T = 0
or is Tcostheta - W = 0?
which forces actually balance out
im trying to see what balances out
i mean its really intuitively obvious that Tcostheta - W = 0 should be true
but that doesn't give the right answer
its not accelerating vertically so Tcostheta - W = 0 should be true
weird that it isnt
i don't think weight is just W there
 
Two trees are supporting the weight of the rope. What does that tell you about the vertical component of the tension at each end? What then is the tension?

At the midpoint of the rope only horizontal forces are acting in tension. The trees are providing the horizontal reaction force (equal and opposite, so nothing is moving). What's the horizontal component of the tension found above?