Tensor Products - Understanding Cooperstein, Theorem 10.2

  • Level: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Math Amateur
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Tensor Theorem
1 reply · 2K views · last reply
Math Amateur
Gold Member
MHB
Messages
3,920
Reaction score
48
I am reading Bruce N. Coopersteins book: Advanced Linear Algebra (Second Edition) ... ...

I am focused on Section 10.1 Introduction to Tensor Products ... ...

I need help in order to get a basic understanding of Theorem 10.2 regarding the basis of a tensor product ... ...

My apologies if my previous questions on this matter are similar to earlier questions ... but I have been puzzling over this theorem for some time ... and still do not have a full understanding of it ...Theorem 10.2 reads as follows:
Screenshot of a textbook page showing Theorem 10.2 on bases of tensor products, followed by its proof with a multilinear map and an isomorphism argument, using Z, Z', U and X' notation.

My questions are as follows:

1. What is the nature/form of the elements of ##X'## and ##X## and how are they related to each other ...

2. What are the nature/form of the elements of ##Z## and ##Z'## and how are they related to each other ... and further, what is the form of the non-basis elements of ##Z## and ##Z'## ... ...

Apologies ... ... I know I have not formulated the question very precisely ... ...
frown.png
... ... but nonetheless I hope someone is able to help ...

Peter============================================================

*** EDIT ***

I have been reflecting on my own questions above ... here are my thoughts ...

Elements of ##X'## would be of the form

##x = (v_1, v_2, \ ... \ ... \ , v_m)## with ##v_i \in \mathcal{B}_i##Elements of ##X = V_1 \times V_2 \times \ ... \ ... \ \times V_m## would be of the form

##x = (v_1, v_2, \ ... \ ... \ , v_m)## with ##v_i \in V_i##and ... ...

... since I imagine ##\mathcal{B}_i \subseteq V_i ## ... then we have ##X' \subseteq X## ... ... (Now ... can we say any more about the form of the elements of X' and X?

Is the above all we can say? )

Now, before outlining the form of the elements of ##Z'## ... we just note that we are asked to identify each element ##x = (v_1, v_2, \ ... \ ... \ , v_m) \in X' ## with ##\chi_x \in Z'## ... ...Now, ##Z'## is a vector space over the field ##\mathbb{F}##, so there will be an operation of addition of elements of ##Z'## and a scalar multiplication ... ...

So ... if ##x_1 = (v_{11}, v_{21}, \ ... \ ... \ , v_{m1}) \in X'## and if ##c_1 \in \mathbb{F}## ... ...

... then ##c_1 \chi_{x_1} \in Z'##Similarly ##c_2 \chi_{x_2} \in Z'## and so on ...

So, by operations of addition we can form elements of the form

##c_1 \chi_{x_1} + c_2 \chi_{x_2} + \ ... \ ... \ + c_n \chi_{x_n}## ... ... ... ... ... (1)


... and (1) above is the general form of elements in ##Z'## ... ...
If we then identify ##c_i \chi_{x_i}## with ##x_i## we can view the elements of ##Z'## as ##c_1 (v_{11}, v_{21}, \ ... \ ... \ , v_{m1}) + c_2 (v_{12}, v_{22}, \ ... \ ... \ , v_{m2}) + \ ... \ ... \

+ c_n (v_{1n}, v_{2n}, \ ... \ ... \ , v_{mn})##
BUT ... THEN ... what form do the elements of ##Z## have ... especially those that are in ##Z##] but not in ##Z'## ... ... ?Can someone please critique my analysis ... and comment on the elements of ##Z## ... especially those not in ##Z'##... ...
========================================================
========================================================NOTE:

The early pages of Cooperstein's Section 10.1 give the notation and approach to understanding tensor products and hence to understanding the notation and concepts used in Theorem 10.2 ... ... hence I am providing the first few pages of Section 10.1 as follows:
Textbook page titled 10.1 Introduction to Tensor Products, with a universal mapping problem definition and a commutative diagram of sets X, V and W with maps i, j and T.

Solution page from a linear algebra textbook (Figure 10.2) showing a diagram of a map from set X to vector space V and a proof that a function on X is a basis of V, with a theorem number and proof text.

Printed textbook page showing Remark 10.1, Notation, Lemma 10.1 and its proof, with definitions of tensor products over a field and multilinear maps.

Printed page of a linear algebra text showing the proof of Theorem 10.1 on the existence of the tensor product, with set definitions, a multilinear map gamma, and quotient space notation.
 
Attachments
  • Screenshot of a textbook page with Theorem 10.2 on tensor product bases and its proof, using notation for vector spaces V_i, bases B_i, and the set of pure tensors.
    Cooperstein - 3 - Theorem 10.2 .... ....png
    57.5 KB · Views: 783
  • Textbook page titled 10.1 Introduction to Tensor Products, with a universal mapping problem definition and a commutative triangle diagram with maps i, j and T between X, V and W.
    Cooperstein - 1 - Section 10.1 - PART 1 ....png
    70.8 KB · Views: 701
  • Solution text for Theorem 10.2 showing a labelled diagram of sets X, V and W with maps i, j and T, followed by a proof that a basis of the vector space over X is linearly independent and spans.
    Cooperstein - 2 - Section 10.1 - PART 2 ....png
    38.4 KB · Views: 684
  • Printed textbook page showing the definition of a tensor product of vector spaces, Remark 10.1, Notation, Lemma 10.1 with its proof, and multilinear map equations.
    Cooperstein - 3 - Section 10.1 - PART 3 ....png
    35.3 KB · Views: 681
  • Typeset page of mathematical text from a linear algebra book: the proof of Theorem 10.1 on the existence of the tensor product, with definitions of the vector space Z, the elements u_{i,c} and the quotient space V.
    Cooperstein - 4 - Section 10.1 - PART 4 ....png
    33.1 KB · Views: 703
Good morning Peter. Your analysis looks good, with the minor exception that where you write:
Math Amateur said:
If we then identify ##c_i \chi_{x_i}## with ##x_i## we can ...
I think you meant
If we then identify ##\chi_{x_i}## with ##x_i## we can ...
Also, this
##c_1 \chi_{x_1} + c_2 \chi_{x_2} + \ ... \ ... \ + c_n \chi_{x_n}##......(1)
seems to imply that infinite sums are permissible and they are not (in this context).

You have asked what the elements of ##Z## are. But the attached text does not give a definition of ##Z##. All we know is that it is a superset of ##Z'##.
Nevertheless, I would guess, since ##Z## appears to be larger than ##Z'##, that it is the set of all finite sums of maps ##\chi_v## where ##v\in V##.
That is:

$$Z\equiv\{\sum_{k=1}^ma_k\chi_{u_k}\ :\ \forall k\ a_k\in\mathbb{F}\wedge u_k\in X\}$$

then we can see how ##Z'## is a subspace of this, because its definition is exactly the same, except that we replace ##X## by the subset ##X'##.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Math Amateur