- #36

hutchphd

Science Advisor

Homework Helper

2022 Award

- 5,514

- 4,699

You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.

You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

- I
- Thread starter mark2142
- Start date

- #36

hutchphd

Science Advisor

Homework Helper

2022 Award

- 5,514

- 4,699

- #37

mark2142

- 146

- 33

Ok! I am simply asking how is “right everywhere” is same as “right from everywhere”?

You can see in the logic I had put a question mark. The math says only “right from everywhere” not “right everywhere”.This does not happen. We can write the correct laws using the new coordinates. There is no absolute space and origin from which the laws are right. So it’s right everywhere or from everywhere?

- #38

- 10,342

- 11,104

Take a piece of equipment and study it. Move it somewhere and study it again from a distance. Is it working the same? Repeat and repeat until you are convinced that the laws you have that describe the instrument are "right everywhere".Ok! I am simply asking how is “right everywhere” is same as “right from everywhere”?

Bring the equipment back to you. Now

- #39

mark2142

- 146

- 33

It’s already been explained before in many posts and I already know the laws don’t change upon displacement. I want to understand the proof that Feynman gave. I am unable to follow from math that laws don’t change upon displacement. The math is proving the law is same for different observers.Take a piece of equipment and study it. Move it somewhere and study it again from a distance. Is it working the same? Repeat and repeat until you are convinced that the laws you have that describe the instrument are "right everywhere".

Bring the equipment back to you. Nowyoumove somewhere and study it again from a distance. The laws governingyourfunction don't change (we just established that) and the equipment hasn't moved. Thus the results will be the same and the laws are "right from everywhere".

- #40

- 22,471

- 13,394

F. Scheck, Mechanics (5th ed.), Springer (2007)

- #41

hutchphd

Science Advisor

Homework Helper

2022 Award

- 5,514

- 4,699

Is the OP aware of the Messenger Lecture on symmetry? He does some fun hand waving on Noether.

- #42

gmax137

Science Advisor

- 2,343

- 2,047

It’s already been explained before in many posts and I already know the laws don’t change upon displacement. I want to understand the proof that Feynman gave. I am unable to follow from math that laws don’t change upon displacement. The math is proving the law is same for different observers.

I think @Ibix has answered this question, essentially, "Feynman has not

... So Feynman is proving that his model of the laws of physics are translation invariant and hence his equipment is predicted to be translation invariant. He does not prove (and you cannot prove) that this is a correct model of reality, but it's been an accurate model every time so far.

"his model" in this case is Newton's ##\vec F = m \vec a##

- #43

- 10,342

- 11,104

I think the only difference is how you interpret the offset, ##a##. Is it the distance between two coordinate system origins, or is it the negative of the x displacement between two pieces of identical equipment measured in the same coordinate system? (I may have incorrectly assigned the negative sign there, so beware.) Depending which way you interpret it you are proving either.The math is proving the law is same for different observers.

- #44

mark2142

- 146

- 33

(Now this means that there exists a way to measure x, y, and z on three perpendicular axes, and the forces along those directions, such that these laws are true.)Depending which way you interpret it you are proving either.

Do we measure x by scale and F by some machine?

Can you tell how do we measure and write newtons law?

- #45

- 24,026

- 15,718

By doing physics theory in the classroom and experiments in the lab.Can you tell how do we measure and write newtons law?

- #46

mark2142

- 146

- 33

So if we assume right most vertical line as origin and the body move to middle vertical line y’ then we can write a law which we call newtons law for the displacement. Then body moves to left most line y and again we can write the same law with different coordinates. So if we see we can realise that the law doesn’t change from middle line y’ to left most line y. Law is translational invariant. That’s what I think of. Yes?

Share:

- Replies
- 15

- Views
- 641

- Last Post

- Replies
- 6

- Views
- 551

- Replies
- 2

- Views
- 1K

- Last Post

- Replies
- 5

- Views
- 583

- Replies
- 46

- Views
- 921

- Replies
- 35

- Views
- 1K

- Last Post

- Replies
- 15

- Views
- 531

- Replies
- 1

- Views
- 617

- Last Post

- Replies
- 18

- Views
- 571

- Last Post

- Replies
- 9

- Views
- 305