The Motion of Charged Particle in Electric Fields Problem

2 replies · 3K views · last reply
Freeq
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
3. Two electrons are fired at 3.5x10^6 m/s directly at each
other.
(a) Calculate the smallest possible distance between the
two electrons.

(b) Is it likely that two electrons in this situation will actually
get this close to each other if the experiment is
performed? Explain your answer.

Hello, let's look at question 3(a). I just did that question, but I got different answer than the one in the book.
There is the book solution is in the attachment.

I'm concerned about a mistake in the formula. I think that there is no square in r. Even two pages after, you can see that there is no square there. How is this Possible?
 
Attachments
  • Slide titled Key Equations listing: F_E = kq1q2/r^2; k = 9.0 x 10^9 N·m²/C² (Coulomb's law); E = kq1/r^2; E_E = kq1q2/r (boxed in red); V = kq1/r; ΔE = qΔV for charged plates; e = 1.602 x 10^-19 C elementary charge; q = Ne.
    dsa2.jpg
    10.6 KB · Views: 638
  • Handwritten-style worked solution from a textbook: energy equations E_T = E'_T and 2E_K = E'_E lead to mv^2 = ke^2/r^2, then r = sqrt(ke^2/mv^2), with a red arrow pointing at the square root term, followed by numeric substitution giving r = 4.5x10^-6 m.
    dsa3.jpg
    19.5 KB · Views: 576
Hi Freeq! :smile:
Freeq said:
I'm concerned about a mistake in the formula. I think that there is no square in r. Even two pages after, you can see that there is no square there. How is this Possible?

Yes, you're right. :smile:

The dimensions there are completely wrong (and the units at the end combine to m1/2, not m). :frown:

energy = qV = Fr = kq1q2/r not kq1q2/r2 :rolleyes:

(which book is this?)​
 
Nelson 12 Physics. It looks like they used formula for electric force, but not energy. However, I still think it is a good book.