The velocity of light in the medium

  • Level: Graduate 
  • Thread starter Thread starter ENDLESSYOU
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Light Medium Velocity
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Start your own thread to ask a follow-up.
3 replies · 3K views
ENDLESSYOU
Messages
29
Reaction score
0
We know that light travels at the same speed in vacuum regardless of the observer.And light also travels at a speed of c/n in the medium.My question is since c/n is the limit speed in medium,then do we have the similar Lorentz transformation in the medium which just replace c with c/n?
For example, suppose space is filled with medium.And the observer is in S-frame in the medium. A light is traveling in S'-frame which is also in the medium and is moving at the speed of u respect to S.Then what's the speed of light that the observer measures in S? c/n?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
ENDLESSYOU said:
We know that light travels at the same speed in vacuum regardless of the observer.And light also travels at a speed of c/n in the medium.
c/n is the phase velocity of the light in the medium.
My question is since c/n is the limit speed in medium,then do we have the similar Lorentz transformation in the medium which just replace c with c/n?
c/n is not the limit speed, c is. (Check out: Cherenkov radiation) The Lorentz transformations remain as usual.
For example, suppose space is filled with medium.And the observer is in S-frame in the medium. A light is traveling in S'-frame which is also in the medium and is moving at the speed of u respect to S.Then what's the speed of light that the observer measures in S? c/n?
No. The speed measured by the observer will be the relativistic sum of those velocities (using the relativistic addition of velocity).
 
ENDLESSYOU said:
For example, suppose space is filled with medium.And the observer is in S-frame in the medium. A light is traveling in S'-frame which is also in the medium and is moving at the speed of u respect to S.Then what's the speed of light that the observer measures in S? c/n?

Doc Al said:
No. The speed measured by the observer will be the relativistic sum of those velocities (using the relativistic addition of velocity).

In fact, this was first observed by Fizeau in the 1850s. Of course, he didn't recognize it as relativistic velocity addition, but Einstein did, more than fifty years later!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fizeau–Foucault_apparatus#Speed_of_light_in_moving_media
 
jtbell said:
Of course, he didn't recognize it as relativistic velocity addition, but Einstein did, more than fifty years later!

Nevertheless Fizeau's experiment was a major step toward to relativity because the experiments of Michelson and Morley can not be interpreted correctly without falsification of a complete aether drag.