These embarassing fumes make me sick

  • Thread starter Thread starter Newai
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around the experience of feeling physically ill after encountering strong odors in men's restrooms, particularly a "napalm disaster" smell. Participants explore the potential causes of this reaction, suggesting it could be psychosomatic, where the disgust from the smell triggers a physical response. They argue that bad odors themselves do not cause diseases, but rather may provoke a gag reflex or nausea due to emotional reactions. The conversation also touches on the possibility of allergic reactions to cleaning products, although this is noted to be more acute rather than a delayed response. Additionally, the idea that diseases have incubation periods is mentioned, indicating that sudden illness is unlikely to be directly caused by foul smells. Overall, the consensus leans towards a psychological and physiological interplay rather than a direct link between odors and illness.
Newai
Messages
32
Reaction score
1
What is this? Once in a long while, I enter the mens room and someone has dropped a serious napalm disaster. Fine in just about every situation, but here I end up getting sick. I know it's coming when my throat starts hurting the way it does. I know I'm going to be really sick tomorrow. How can a specific fume do that? And only to me?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Psychosomatic.
 
could be you're already getting sick.
 
By long while, I mean like two or three years. It's not in my head.
 
Newai said:
By long while, I mean like two or three years. It's not in my head.

the things that smell bad wouldn't give you a disease. gag reflex, maybe. and you've even got taste receptors in your throat, fwiw.

also, diseases tend to have incubation periods, so you shouldn't expect a sudden onset.
 
Could this be some sort of allergic reaction to cleaning and or other products used in toilets?
 
Proton Soup said:
the things that smell bad wouldn't give you a disease. gag reflex, maybe. and you've even got taste receptors in your throat, fwiw.

also, diseases tend to have incubation periods, so you shouldn't expect a sudden onset.

re: bolded: I'd add that the ones which are completely asymptomatic in that period are not uncommon, although a sense of malaise (feeling generally sick) often precedes frank symptoms. The ones that fulminate on the other hand, tend to just explode and kill you, so we can rule that out.

Here's my theory: It's psychosomatic. Now, don't jump up and say it's been 3 years and I'm calling you crazy. You clearly have a strong reaction to these... fumes... which you also describe as "embarrassing". If you smell something which disgusts you emotionally, you WILL have a physical reaction, although usually it's limited to change in pupilary dilation, and other markers.

What else happens when we're confronted with something that makes us feel disgusted in our minds?... usually we have a physical reaction that's fairly brief. One of them is gagging or even throwing up, but what if you don't just throw up on the spot? What if instead, you're a little more upset by this than most, or perhaps you have acid reflux already in a small way. I'm guessing that the "sickness", is the result of increased acid production, which can feel exactly like a stomach ailment, and even impart a sore throat and sinuses if you sleep on it.

I could be completely off, but let me say this: bad odors do not, because they are bad odors, make you ill. True, hydrogen sulfide smells terrible (at first), and its deadly, but so is CO2 and we breath it all of the time. The notion that ill vapors caused illness died along with the dark ages.
 
Dadface said:
Could this be some sort of allergic reaction to cleaning and or other products used in toilets?

Not uncommon, but usually acute and would be occurring when the head was just cleaned, not soiled. Otherwise, good idea, although nausea would be an odd reaction unless it's an organophosphate, and then I'd expect the full SLUDGE.
 
Back
Top