PAllen
Science Advisor
- 9,325
- 2,537
Just to add a little more to this, if this idealized ball of dust starts with trajectories such that they are mutually at rest (i.e. some initial slice in fermi-normal coordinates based on one of them is 4-orthogonal to all of them), then:PeterDonis said:If the individual dust grains all start out on comoving trajectories, i.e., expanding, and if the dust is far enough from all gravitating masses, and if the dust has negligible self gravity, yes. But in practice no real ball of dust will satisfy all these conditions.
1) if the second derivative of a(t) is positive (rate of expansion increasing), they ball will expand
2) if it is zero (the Milne cosmology), they will remain at mutual rest
3) if it is negative (decreasing rate of expansion, not decreasing scale factor), then this ball will contract.
The initial conditions of the ball matter a lot.