Troubleshooting Flash Drive Compatibility Between Linux and Windows

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around troubleshooting compatibility issues with a flash drive used between Linux and Windows operating systems. Participants explore various technical aspects, including file systems, device recognition, and file management across different platforms.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • The original poster (OP) reports that their flash drive is recognized on Windows but not on a Linux machine.
  • One participant inquires about the file system used on the flash drive, suggesting FAT32, FAT, or NTFS as possibilities.
  • The OP confirms the file system is FAT32, which is generally compatible with both Linux and Windows.
  • Another participant suggests testing the flash drive on a different Linux machine to rule out local issues with the specific computer.
  • A user describes their experience with a flash drive that has its own operating system, which complicates recognition on Linux systems.
  • There are discussions about the proper way to delete files from the flash drive on macOS, with one participant emphasizing the need to highlight and empty the trash to fully clear the drive.
  • Another participant mentions that if an operating system is present on the flash drive, it may not be recognized by Linux, leading to confusion about device detection.
  • One user shares their experience of resolving the issue with the help of a local computer store, clarifying the steps needed to manage files on macOS.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express various viewpoints on the compatibility of flash drives across different operating systems, with no consensus reached on the underlying cause of the OP's issue. Multiple competing views remain regarding file management practices and the impact of embedded operating systems on device recognition.

Contextual Notes

Some participants note the importance of checking system outputs (e.g., using dmesg on Linux) to diagnose recognition issues, while others highlight the potential for confusion in file management across different operating systems.

Alamino
Messages
69
Reaction score
0
I bought a Flash Memory Drive and I was using it in my computer in the university, which runs Linux, and in my computer at home, which runs Windows. Today, suddenly, my comp. at the university simply does not even recognize the flash drive, although it's still working perfectly on Windows. Does anyone know what could be the problem and how can I fix it?
 
Computer science news on Phys.org
what file table are you using? FAT32 FAT, NTFS etc
 
Sorry, but I'm not a computer scientist (just a physicist...) and I have not any idea about this. The only thing I know is that I've already have this problem in the past with floppies, but in that case I've simply thrown them away...
 
Ok. Now I found it. My file system is FAT32.
 
Fat32 is compatible with both systems so that isn't the problem...

Have you tryed a different Linux box, it could be a local problem to that 1 particular box
 
Hi,

I'm using a flash drive, a Memorex 1GB, and loading music onto it, then transferring that file onto my MacBook using OS X 10.4 Tiger, then when the file is in iTunes I drag the file icon to the trash, the icon in the flash drive window. This should empty the flash drive yes? But then when I go back to download more music on the flash drive the loading device says the drive is full ! Somehow I am not correctly emptying the flash drive, but at the Memorex site and in the Apple directions and in the instructions for the flash drive there are no specific directions on how to empty the drive. I mean they are empty-able and reusable, yes? It would seem like they are not a one time use, and you can't empty them and refill them.

There are instructions to reformat the flash drive, but that seems excessive, all I need to do is empty it.

Anyone have familiarity in how this is usually done?
 
In windows explorer, go to the flash drive when it's plugged in, locate the files and delete them?
 
Alamino, perhaps we can see what's happening when you plug your flash drive into the linux box.

Post the output of:
dmesg | tail
immediately after you have inserted your flash drive.EDIT: Just realized that someone went and dug up an old thread.
 
then when the file is in iTunes I drag the file icon to the trash, the icon in the flash drive window. This should empty the flash drive yes?

I think all this does is prepare the flash drive to be disconnected, similar to "Eject".

What you need to do is to "format" the drive, which means erase and format for new data. I am not a mac user so try searching using the key term "format".
 
  • #10
if you have a OS on your flash drive it will only appear on windows...as for the flash drive itself you may have to "mount" the device in which case you will need to know what device you are adding.

However the flashdrive should automatically be detected on linux, as etiher the company name or "removable" which is what my sandisk comes up as.

Might help if you post what linux IDE you are running

as for the mac problem: doesn't MAC bring up a do you want to delete message? if that doesn't come up maybe you aren't deleteing properly...

all and all YAY FOR WINDOWS.
 
  • #11
To the OP: I have a Sandisk 2GB flashdrive with its own operating system, that it loads into memory everytime I use it. Its quite pathetic, however, as I am usually done transfering my files before the OS loads itself, and as such I hardly deal with it at all. If the OS (aka Sandisk virus) does manage to load itself, then I have to format the drive or else trying to use it is a punishment.

In any case, if the OS is on the drive then the RedHat Linux machine does not even notice me put it in, but without the OS it works properly.
 
  • #12
In any case, if the OS is on the drive then the RedHat Linux machine does not even notice me put it in, but without the OS it works properly.
Did you check the output of dmesg to make sure that it really didnt recognize the flash drive? It seems rather odd that it would just ignore an inserted device. I ask this because I have a drive with one of those OS things. It works perfectly. I don't have the automatic "detect and mount device" [automount] thing enabled. So I have to check what device linux sees my flash drive as...
 
  • #13
Thanks for your advice. I went into town today and the local computer store has a very helpful young man. He put the TravelDrive into a USB cable and showed me the files were still there, and then deleted them. He was using a Windows OS. What I have to do in OSX is to 'select' the file icon (highlite it), then drag it to the trash, then empty the trash. All three operations must be done to empty the TravelDrive. I didn't highlite, or empty the trash; so my system showed no files, and the music loading device still saw files. I guess it took a different system to see the files. All is well now, it is just a frustrating learning curve, as even the smallest misstep will cause an error, and who is here to tell me of my small missteps? This is a great site, and at some future time I'll make use of the higher math capabilities. Caio
 

Similar threads

Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
4K
  • · Replies 51 ·
2
Replies
51
Views
7K
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • · Replies 18 ·
Replies
18
Views
3K
Replies
9
Views
3K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
2K
  • Poll Poll
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
5K