U.S. warns Germany on World Cup sex workers

  • Thread starter Thread starter jimmie
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Germany world cup
AI Thread Summary
The U.S. government has urged Germany to take stronger measures against human trafficking, particularly in light of the upcoming soccer World Cup, while opposing prostitution, which is legal in Germany. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice emphasized the moral imperative to combat human trafficking, labeling it a "sordid trade in human beings." The discussion raises questions about the U.S.'s moral authority to critique other nations on this issue, especially given the legality of prostitution in parts of the U.S., such as Nevada. Participants debated whether the U.S. can claim moral superiority when it has its own inconsistencies regarding prostitution and human rights. The conversation ultimately highlights the complexities of legal and ethical standards surrounding prostitution and human trafficking.
  • #51
Jimmie, I moved your thread here to hopefully remove the politics from it so people can just address your ethical question.

Ok.

Thanks for the consideration.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #52
Good move, LYN, but I suspect that the politics can't be removed. Prostitution has never been an ethical issue; it's purely a matter of morality, which is determined by religious/political indoctrination.
 
  • #53
jimmie said:
Really? The question was: why doesn't the U.S. make more moral suggestions on various other harmful and dehumanizing topics, as well as adhere to its all of its own suggestions, so as to truly be the moral authority it projects itself to be?

If the answer is obvious, please share it with us.

Like I said, replace "prostitution" with "human trafficking" and your question is:

why doesn't the U.S. make more moral suggestions on various other harmful and dehumanizing topics (like human trafficking), as well as adhere to its all of its own suggestions, so as to truly be the moral authority it projects itself to be?

The answer being; we do. Well, the "adhere" bit can be contested to various degrees depending on the specific issue, but we do make efforts against human trafficking and the like and we offer plenty of suggestions on such matters as well. As for moral authority, again, the standing up against such things as inarguably wrong as human trafficking is the authority in itself.
 
  • #54
Going back to the thread title...

If it's about the US imposing it's moral views on European policy.

I'm not sure if many Europeans care what the US think these days. Certainly when I read a story like this, ie. on the sex workers and the WC, it amuses me. I shouldn't really brush over the story but beacuse of GWB, stories that come out of the US don't hold much credibility for me any more. It's a generalistion I shouldn't make but it seems to be at the fore these days.
 

Similar threads

Replies
29
Views
10K
Replies
49
Views
8K
  • Poll Poll
Replies
8
Views
5K
Replies
46
Views
6K
Replies
2
Views
3K
Replies
37
Views
7K
Back
Top